hanca
Values her privacy
- Messages
- 12,549
You right they don't. But following the "line of thought" in the discussion that was taking place. The idea you expressed was "don't get excited about younger girls because a lot can happen as they grow older" which comes with usual list of issues. you gave examples of Gubanova and Nugumanova. my point was that in their case the down-spin was not because of "those typical issues" (puberty, weight, growing, injuries, any physical/mind issues) but because they had "coach issues" and made "miscalculations". no biggie, just clarifying.
I am not sure if everything can be attributed to coach changes. With Nugumanova there may be attitude problems if one believes to what Mishin said in his interview. So some problems may be because of that. I also feel that maybe she has a bit of a black mark against her name thanks to Mishin, because while skating with Mishin she never received as many underrotations as she has nowadays. So either she suddenly started underotated whereas before she didn’t, or the judges stopped overlooking those issues when she skates.
With Gubanova the situation is even more unclear. I think the puberty does have a part in it a little bit. She already started being inconsistent during her second junior season (2017-18), for example being fourth at one of her JGP event, and she switched coaches only after that season.