VGThuy
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 41,179
To be fair, Chock/Bates have always been able to get level 4s on steps and patterns (hello 2015 Worlds) but that hasn't stopped people from saying her edges aren't on par with some of her peers and with Evan. Maybe they're talking about overall edge quality. Maybe this is one of those things people talk about regarding how ice dance judging and level calling doesn't appropriately judge ice dance anyway when we had the discussion about how the new -5/+5 GOE range took power away from the callers and some people argued it was a good thing as some see it as sort of a ridiculous way to judge ice dance anyway. However, maybe the fact Chock is able to get level 4 also shows FSU narratives or "established facts" like "Chock/Gilles has bad edges" or "they're weaker than their partners" are hard to kill once they've been spread long enough even when some facts indicate those narratives may not be entirely true like if say Gilles/Chock manage to hit higher levels on their partners in the elements where each partner are individually called now.