I love S/D but I think technically they are not very good. M/C have good SS and they were world junior champions.
Well, in 2015-16 Hubbell & Donohue lost to Paradis & Ouellette and a less-than-clean performance by Paul & Islam at the start of the season in Canada. (It was a club event, but still--P&O never had the skating skills that H&D have or had).
McNamara & Carpenter will grow from here. I'm quite proud of them. Before the competition, I swore to myself that I would be happy if they skated two solid programs in this deep field, and they did. Smart & Diaz had a beautiful FD performance at this event. All three teams (M&C, S&D, and the Danes) skated well in the FD here. Good for them. Everyone dropped levels and can improve, but learning is what early CS events are all about.
Some takeaways from this weekend:
1. I really liked Bobrova & Soloviev's FD performance. It is the only program that made me
feel something (which is quite an accomplishment at this stage of the season).
2. I hope the Russian Fed is feeling just a tad sheepish about not inviting Popova & Mozgov to Rostelecom. I don't have any crazy expectations for this team at this stage, but I do think they are better than Evdokimova & Bazin. I get that P&M do not have a ranking from Nationals. But that didn't bother anyone back when Ilinykh & Zhiganshin started competing. (Honestly, I think P&M are paying a bit for that disaster rather than just their own re-teaming).
3. The field at Nepela had no very established senior teams after B&S, but the top two young teams skated well & I am happy for P&M and the Parsons. Also kudos to Min & Gamelin, who look ready for the season and had the highest levels in the FD along with Bobrova & Soloviev.
4. I think Weaver & Poje's FD has potential and a story arc. I'm struggling with the lack of excitement in the beginning, but the elements are well placed and the ending is nice. I am curious to see how it develops.
February is a long way away and I have a feeling a few of us will be changing our minds about the programs by then.
This is so true!