The Dance Hall 13: When You Dance on the Ice and Your Feet Twizzle Twice, That's Amore

I am aware of that and that was your point that I was responding to. Having everyone ignore something isn't really a good thing. And, again, I am not happy when tech panels don't even review a problem. There needs to be the same level of scrutiny for all the skaters.

Isn't it though? I mean I genuinely don't know, but were others punished from willy-nilly mistakes then? I do think it's outrageous that CZ and CH judges gave them GOE 4 for clearly poorly executed twizzle, but others did note it to varying degree. On the other hand, about the rotational lift, none of the judges saw a problem, not even those whom overall placed Americans #1, or the one judge who gave negative GOE from the twizzle. So that, at least, is consistent judging.

I have been a sport judge, and one of the main lessons we were given was "It's not a big deal if you screw up, if you screw up same way for everyone".
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information