rfisher
Let the skating begin
- Messages
- 73,921
I'd be thrilled for Sakhanovich to get a spot. Not just for Sima, but to see Plushenko at the boards.
Good for them. They should have received that spot from the beginning, IMO.
Why should they? Last season they didn’t even qualify for Russian nationals. I am happy they got it now, but at the same time it is fair that they had to prove themselves. Why should they get the host event based on last year results when the results were not that great?
I would love it if Kailani would grab a GP spot. However, I don't know if her Olympic spot is secured yet, if not she might need to compete at other events with Brooklee instead.
The problem is that test skates took place a month ago. A lot can change in that time. (See how much changed in junior pairs since their test skates! ) To give someone spot only because someone has a better program is not a good enough reason in my opinion. One needs to skate better, not to have a better program.I can't speak for @Marta24, but I thought after watching the Russian test skates that it was evident that the spot should have gone to Popova/Mozgov. They have better programs, and I think it would be hard to argue that Evdokimova/Bazin are better skaters or a superior ice dance team, regardless of what happened last season with respect to Russian Nationals. Now, clearly P/M have proven themselves at two Challengers and the spot has now gone to them - but unfortunately in the process, E/B have lost the spot, which wouldn't have happened if it had been awarded outright to P/M.
I would love it if Kailani would grab a GP spot. However, I don't know if her Olympic spot is secured yet, if not she might need to compete at other events with Brooklee instead.
I hadn't thought of that. I heard a rumour from an acquaintance who heard it from someone else (so take it for what it is worth) that they will have to skate off for the Olympic spot.
Just a theoretical question (as I fear I will never get this GP subs rules ):
Could Schott be given the one of the open Skate Canada spots too as a 2nd GP?
Or is her 'right' gone, after she got considered as a substitute for a GP already?
(Just in theory, I am happy with one spot already )
Popova/Mozgov got CoR host spot instead of Evdokimova/Bazin
http://www.isuresults.com/events/cat03108221.htm
Just for the record: Evdokimova/Bazin were not pulled out in favour of Popova/Mozgov. Sofia broke her rips, thus the wirthdrawal.Good for them. They should have received that spot from the beginning, IMO.
They are still listed as subtitles in Minsk, hopefully she will be ok by that time.Just for the record: Evdokimova/Bazin were not pulled out in favour of Popova/Mozgov. Sofia broke her rips, thus the wirthdrawal.
(they had to pull out of CS Minsk too, where they were replaced by Solovieva/Vlasenko)
I'm sure ISA have a plan in place for if either one got a GP spot.
Such a skate-off may take place at Nationals, of course.
Marco posted in the Australian news thread: https://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/threads/australian-skating-news.98953/page-13#post-5143768I thought I read somewhere that it had to do with their international rankings and if they were more than 20 places apart, the higher one got the spot. If less than twenty then they had to compete at an international comp together and see where the ranking were after that. I could have sworn I read that ... maybe I am losing it?
Marco posted in the Australian news thread: https://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/threads/australian-skating-news.98953/page-13#post-5143768
ETA:
Anastasia Galustyan (ARM) has replaced Soyoun Park at Rostelecom: http://www.isuresults.com/events/cat03108219.htm
She's #63 on the 2016-17 ISU SB list (and she doesn't need a visa?).
https://twitter.com/USFigureSkating/status/918137458113597442See on Twitter that Courtney Hicks got one of the open spots at Skate Canada.
Excellent! Good job, Skate Canada. Good sportsmanship to go with someone near the top of the list and not worry if she's a threat to the home skaters.
The Olympic Winter Games Institute announced that Australia's Kailani Craine has been invited to compete in the ladies' event at the ISU Grand Prix - Skate Canada International.
Chafik Besseghier is out of Skate Canada
Collapsed lung is serious, but you recover pretty fast afterwards! I know what I am talking aboutChafik Hope he recovers soon, collapsed lung sounds serious...
35 Hicks USA - replaced Rodeghiero or N. Kim at Skate CanadaEdmunds SB from 15-16 of 183.20 from 2015 Rostelecom Cup places her as SB 35, between Glenn and Hicks, because return skaters "will be ranked in the list of Season’s Best scores by taking the Season’s Best points of their most recent season..." and within the Top Ten for the alternates list.
Just a theoretical question (as I fear I will never get this GP subs rules ):
Could Schott be given the one of the open Skate Canada spots too as a 2nd GP?
Or is her 'right' gone, after she got considered as a substitute for a GP already?
(Just in theory, I am happy with one spot already )