starrynight
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 3,234
The rather complex guidelines for deciding GOE on dance patterns are set out here:
https://www.isu.org/inside-single-p...e-of-execution-of-pattern-dance-elements/file
I've copied out the positive and negative features below:
Positive
So for a +1 GOE you need plus 1 -2 positive features and at least 75% of Steps/Edges held for required number of beats (for both partners)
For +5 GOE you need more than 8 positive features, no negative features and 100% of Steps/Edges held for required number of beats (for both partners)
So I would say either:
- the judges that gave +5 and +1 for the same pattern are either very harsh or forgiving. OR one judge thought that they needed to work on holding their edges.
Not sure if I would necessarily hold out their pattern as being the flawless level +5 is meant to represent. I suspect the judges fell into a bit of 6.0 relative scoring at this event.
Is there video of Souicisse/Firus' RD anywhere?
https://www.isu.org/inside-single-p...e-of-execution-of-pattern-dance-elements/file
I've copied out the positive and negative features below:
Positive
- Good quality - correctness, cleanness and sureness of Edges/Steps/Turns
- Edges deep.
- Smooth and Effortless
- Unison and oneness throughout the element
- Reflects character and style of the chosen rhythm
- Glide and flow maintained (movement across the ice)
- Holds and positions precise, consistent and close spacing between partners
- Body lines and carriage of both partners elegant.
- Maximum utilization of the ice surface with the correct Pattern
- Timing accurate 100%
- Per each Stumble
- Per each Loss of Balance
- Poor quality and/or Laboured and/or Uncontrolled and/or Minor Errors and/or Major Error(s) (max of negative features per Element)
- Lack of unison
- Does not reflect character and style of the chosen rhythm
- Lack of glide and flow (movement across the ice)
- Holds and positions incorrect and/or uncontrolled and/or variable spacing in between partners
- Crossing the Long Axis
– exception for 2018/19: Tango Romantica Steps #3-5 and Steps #10-12 ) per each - Pattern incorrect
- Not started on the prescribed beat (for each Section/Sequence)
So for a +1 GOE you need plus 1 -2 positive features and at least 75% of Steps/Edges held for required number of beats (for both partners)
For +5 GOE you need more than 8 positive features, no negative features and 100% of Steps/Edges held for required number of beats (for both partners)
So I would say either:
- the judges that gave +5 and +1 for the same pattern are either very harsh or forgiving. OR one judge thought that they needed to work on holding their edges.
Not sure if I would necessarily hold out their pattern as being the flawless level +5 is meant to represent. I suspect the judges fell into a bit of 6.0 relative scoring at this event.
Is there video of Souicisse/Firus' RD anywhere?
Last edited: