I saw I, Tontya- finally.
This is a well liked movie (7.7 on imd.com), but I was disappointed, for various reasons.
First, the positives.
The movie was well structured, despite having 4 characters narrating the story (Tonya, her mother, Jeff Gilooly, and. .?) and using flashbacks. The audience seemed to love the movie, laughing at times or shocked at times. So the movie definitely touched the general public.
The acting was good throughout, but is it possible that a mother could be as bad as portrayed here? Not taking anything away from Allison Janney's performance, because the whole story was told from Tonya's perspective.
They explained in the very beginning what a triple axel was, why it was so difficult, and no American woman had landed it. This prepared the audience to understand this was a rare athlete.Cute kids skating as young Tonya added to the story.
Seeing Tonya's original 91 US nationals LP while the end credits rolled was a real treat. Tonya was an amazing athlete. This was such a tragedy!
Now the Negatives.
Margot Robbie, despite her good acting, was the wrong choice to play Tonya. When Tonya won the nationals in 91, with her triple axel, she was just 20, and even younger in the earlier competitions. Robbie looked like someone in the late twenties (she was born in 1990, so she is 27 now). This is not a big age difference, but she did not look Tonya's age on the screen. Other actresses who played younger than themselves in movies looked the age of the characters. The best example may be Jennifer Gray (27-28) playing 17 year old Baby in Dirty dancing, very convincingly. Another example may be Charmian Carr (21) playing 16 year old Liesl in The Sound of Music. Carr wrote in her book that many talented actresses were rejected because they they didn't Look 16. IMO this movie needed to find the right actress to play the role. I don't criticize Robbie's acting ability, but she didn't look the part except when she was telling the story.
Had Robbie looked Tonya's age from 18-21, it would have been easier to understand her involvement and marriage to Gilooly. She was vulnerable. Here we saw a grown up woman. She looked ok at age 23 (94 Olympics) but not earlier.
This movie portrays Tonya as a victim of abuse by mother, boyfriend/husband, and showing a lot of violence in the process, when fewer scenes would have sent the message. This is really 'in your face' movie. I prefer a more skilled presentation.
Later, she is portrayed as a helpless pawn used by others. It is known now that Tonya at least knew about the plan and she lied about it. The movie needed to show positives and negatives of her character.
Did Tonya actually walk back on the ice to argue with the judges after her marks were announced? I don't believe this for a second. A judge she approaches (he is in a car) tells her that she doesn't fit in. There isbsome truth in it, but it is also true that Tonya never tried to make changes to her programs based on feedback from judges. Neither did Elvis Stojko, but he focused on what he did well, and never fought against the judges. (Sorry I am OT)
In the end the Judge sentences her with community service, fine, and the Usfsa decision to ban her for life. I think
the Usfsa decision came separately, and not in the courtroom. The movie used it as an opportunity to show how heartbroken Tonya was, about being banned from skating (understandably). It was ok for a movie, but was it necessary to say she Had to go into boxing to make a living? She could have cleaned houses, or worked at a restaurant, for example.
The movie was too soft on Tonya, like she had no flaws, and what happened to her was everyone Reese's fault. I have a problem with that.
Finally, I think there was a goof in the medal podium. They showed Kristi in a bronze position and Nancy in a silver position, when Tonya won the gold at the nationals (correct me if I am long).
Sorry this is such a long post, but this is about Figure Skating!
