topaz
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 15,236
Yes, those are no longer needed to be champion in Ice Dance. If they're not going to reward the actual technical skating aspect for Ice Dance and continue to hold up teams that have great lifts and tricks without showing the technical expertise needed, then let the sport die.Putting skating skills piece by piece I think it is a tragedy to be honest. What precedence does this set? That skating skills, deep edges and perfection are no longer important?
Personally, I think the difficulty in G/F program in more evident than the Brits. My mom who's not a technical person noticed the Italians had more difficult entrances into the lifts and they skate closer together. I think the details in the Italians program are skated with more difficulty. Ice dance - we should see deep edges, speed, effortlessly displaying difficult/different holds, posture, line - aka dancing, not posing.Given the scores these teams have been receiving, I don't see those predictions even close to loco. We know G/P and C/B are battling it out for Gold and the other three teams are battling it out for bronze. G/F have been consistently underscored and there is no reason to think that will change for Worlds so having them in 5th is not an outrageous a prediction.
Mostly agree except I do think Fear/Gibson have been working on their skating skills. They used to be much sloppier and more upright.
Also, it's possible all these teams have topped out skill-wise and so, even if they are working on improving, we aren't going to see big improvements or possibly anything at all if the improvements are subtle enough or a bad program obscures them.
I guess I just have a hard time believing all six teams don't care about improving. In particular, the bottom five probably want to be the top three.
The Italians have the highest total score and they're going into the GPF as 3rd. I will always cheer for the best SKATERS to win, not the most flashy program. It's interesting to me how some folks responding on this thread can comment on other single skaters skating skills and technical ablity in other disciplines but not recognize those same skating skills qualities in the Italians.
Last edited: