I think Valieva would win if this was a competition. But there are no "ifs". The Russian Federation, for the first time in a long time, did not have the judges scoring the Test Skate. On the other hand, there are many skating professionals, who are singling out Valieva as the most impressive (Byanova, Zhulin, Bestemianova, Averbuch... articles available), and all are saying they are quite impressed with Shcherbakova and Trusova, praising different aspects of skating in each one.And today Trusova would win if this was a competition.