Conventional wisdom held that while some judges might prefer the French team's style, Virtue and Moir's technical ability -- particularly in the short dance -- would prevail. It did during the 2016-17 season, when the Canadians won the Grand Prix Final and worlds. In the lead-up to PyeongChang, though, Papadakis and Cizeron upped their game, skating with noticeably greater speed and clarity. They defeated Virtue and Moir for the first time in December 2017 at the Grand Prix Final after the Canadians made what Moir called "a few uncharacteristic glitches."
The loss prompted Virtue and Moir and their coaches to take a fresh look at their programs.
"We went through every element and just thought, 'What could possibly be a reason for a judge not to give a +3 (Grade of Execution)?' We wanted to eliminate those," Virtue said in PyeongChang. "Looking at it that way gave us a different baseline."
Papadakis and Cizeron sat out the team event in PyeongChang, training with longtime coach Romain Haguenauer while Virtue and Moir led Team Canada to gold. The Canadians entered the individual event as slight underdogs but put out what they considered their finest performances of the season to edge the French -- who made obvious errors in their short dance, after Papadakis suffered a costume malfunction -- by 0.79 points to win their second Olympic title.
"We were trying to drive the power and speed more; we knew we would need that against the French," Moir said. "We're in great shape. We feel we have more power in our blades, more power in our knees than we have ever had."
To Belbin White, the Canadians more than achieved their goals: They won, and they were better than ever. "In PyeongChang, it felt more natural, it felt more organic," Belbin White said. "In the past, it was like they were showing you a dream. In PyeongChang, it was, 'This is us, this is what we came to do, and we're going to do it.' It felt like they were putting themselves into the characters on the ice, and when you put yourself out there so honestly, it resonates."
Virtue and Moir own five Olympic medals -- two individual golds (2010 and 2018), an individual silver (2014), a team gold (2018) and a team silver (2014) -- making them the most decorated figure skaters in Olympic history. They also won three world titles (2010, 2012 and 2017).
"They've rewritten what an ice dance team can do," said Alex Shibutani, who won ice dance bronze with sister Maia in PyeongChang.
"They were born under good stars, they found each other at a young age -- it's a partnership that kept growing," Dubreuil said. "Twenty years of skating together, eyes closed they know what the other one is doing."
Belbin White doesn't hesitate to call her old Canton training partners the G.O.A.T.s (greatest of all time).
"I use that term in reverence," she said. "The facts are in front of you. What else would you call them?"