Skaters who 'own the ice'?

Definitely Pluschenko. I never really enjoyed his skating watching on TV and i only saw him live at Europeans 2012 (well past his prime) and it was unbelieveable. In practices he skated as i expected but the minute he stepped onto competition ice there was something absolutely commanding about him. Even rewatching the same performance on the TV afterwards i thought "meh" but in person it was incredible.
 
For me anyways, what 'owning the ice' refers to is being as one with the ice and in the performance, and that for me first and foremost means complete effortlessness and surety, and also natural movements.

I think no one epitomize that phrase more so than Michelle Kwan and Patrick Chan.
The thing with Patrick Chan that was so rare was that it was his actual basic skating that drew you in, not the elements. Seeing him live, even when he had a crappy skate, his movement across the ice was just so awe-inspiring that even a bad skate was absolutely fantastic due to the 'in between'. It really made me understand why his PCS were so high when he bombed, because his basic skating was just THAT good. Not many skaters can command your attention based on edgework and flow.
 
Madison Hubbell and Zachary Donohue. You know they're there. They command you to watch them, because there's something so dynamic and compelling. I think there's a bit of an 'unknown' or 'unpredictable' factor too, and of course their fabulous chemistry as a dance couple. I'm not a dance fan, but H/D create a dance in the classic sense, in that the sum of the two partners is far, far greater than their individual parts. Oh, and their speed and deep, deep edges.

Ashley Cain-Gribble and Timothy Leduc. They create an electric thrill simply by their mutual passion and dedication to unison and synchronicity. Every moment, they're in that moment together, again, because of their mutual passion for their music. They embody the character and cadence of the music; they bring it to life. I was stunned by their speed in person as well. They're in it for more than the competition; they want to give something and they gain energy by give-and-take with the audience.

Evan Lysacek. He did a thrilling, lightning-speed triple jump right in front of me, and it was like a split-second journey into outer space. I'd never thought of a jump as embodying or becoming beauty before, but his did. Also through the screen, I always felt his desire and determination to accomplish what he set out to do, and his love for skating. He was a great competitor, and that creates its own circle of energy.

Ashley Wagner. I didn't even know who she was, but at 2013 Skate America she stepped out onto the ice, and it was like a field of energy came into being. Her Ice Presence was just remarkable. She invited everyone in the arena to be on the ice with her. Then and always, Ashley had the magical ability to create a moment.

Scott Hamilton. I was in the nose-bleed seats, and he was a tiny stick figure. But the minute he stepped onto the ice, I could feel that he wanted to make every person in the arena happy. All however many thousand there were. He wanted to lift people out of their troubles or even just their ordinary thoughts. Make us happy for three minutes, and carry that happiness and those special minutes forward within us. And I have.

"Reach out with your feelings, Luke." --Obiwan Kenobe. That's how I think of owning the ice. Reach out to the audience, have the desire to give something, take something, some moment, some experience. Create synergy in the universe ... and as energy doesn't dissipate, it transmutes into something we can take with us.
 
Last edited:
Pluschenko - my first thought on seeing him live at 2001 Worlds was "he skates like he owns the ice" - even though I never liked his programs, his attitude, or a lot of his skating.

For very different reasons, as others have mentioned, Patrick Chan. The first time I saw him was at a junior men's practice at his first "big" Canadians, just after his 14th birthday. He had so much power in his skating, although he was several years younger than most of the competitors. (He won)

And Hanyu - compelling every time I've seen him live.
 
She is not the fastest skater of all time, so she doesn't tick that box requested by the original poster, but Samantha Cesario controlled the arena at Skate America in 2013. I don't know what all of you thought about her, but if you didn't see her live and wondered if she commanded attention, the answer from me is a definite "yes." She was captivating and the opposite of a skater who just throws in elements because her choreographer tells her they are needed (cough, cough). She was so musical that our own Claire Cloutier wrote about her in a blog post and got my approval to quote my praise of Sam's skills. She is missed.
 
A skater with mastery over the blades can be considered 'owning the ice'.Berezhnaya Sikharulidze had mastery Over the ice. They could gain speed with just a couple of cross overs and connect difficult moves. Same can be said of Gordeeva Grinkov's movement over the ice. I particularly loved their 1994 SP in their footwork sequence. One could watch these skaters for a long time, mesmerised by their command of the ice. I would add Johnny Weir to this list. Current skaters - PAPADAKIS and Cizeron.
 
For very different reasons, as others have mentioned, Patrick Chan. The first time I saw him was at a junior men's practice at his first "big" Canadians, just after his 14th birthday. He had so much power in his skating, although he was several years younger than most of the competitors. (He won)
I was at those Canadians too. I didn't know his name, and only saw a brief moment of him skating, but when I was in the arena later on for a Seniors thing, I asked a friend who'd been there the whole time about the junior men, and they said Patrick Chan won. I asked if that was the really good kid we'd seen earlier, and they said yes. So even when I didn't know his name, or even see a whole skate of his, he was memorable.
 
A skater with mastery over the blades can be considered 'owning the ice'.Berezhnaya Sikharulidze had mastery Over the ice. They could gain speed with just a couple of cross overs and connect difficult moves. Same can be said of Gordeeva Grinkov's movement over the ice. I particularly loved their 1994 SP in their footwork sequence. One could watch these skaters for a long time, mesmerised by their command of the ice. I would add Johnny Weir to this list. Current skaters - PAPADAKIS and Cizeron.
I'm surprised that I forgot to say Gordeeva/Grinkov! They were amazing live.
 
I am not a fan of Plushenko and will never be but holy cow, in person, the guy owned the ice and the entire building. His programs pandered to the judges, being mostly choreographed between the blue lines but fudge it, you watched, such charisma.
 
Last edited:
Robin Cousins. His skating presence captured my full attention. I saw him skate in person only once, but it has stayed with me.
There was a yearly exhibition skating evening called Super Skates at MSG in the 70s. A young Robin Cousins was on the bill one year and the following when he appeared again he was introduced as “back again by popular demand, Robin Cousins.” He absolutely owned the ice and captured the audience, no doubt about it.
 
I never thought Bauil command the ice. I mean she brought the :drama: to the ice, but her actual skating never moved me.
I remember seeing Oksana at COI and her blades just skimmed the ice. She just moved so differently than any other skater- including Viktor.

I saw Brian Boitano and Katerina Witt live when they had their own show and Brian Boitano was the most magestic skater I had ever seen. He was strong moving across the ice especially in his spread eagle. He was something else.
 
I remember seeing Oksana at COI and her blades just skimmed the ice. She just moved so differently than any other skater- including Viktor.

I saw Brian Boitano and Katerina Witt live when they had their own show and Brian Boitano was the most magestic skater I had ever seen. He was strong moving across the ice especially in his spread eagle. He was something else.
"Majestic" is the perfect word.
 
Boitano was the most magestic skater I had ever seen. He was strong moving across the ice especially in his spread eagle. He was something else.
He is to this day ...


... He is even learning spins now that would fit the CoP.

 
Last edited:
Midori Ito in 1988. Her LP at the Olympic Games was really amazing.

I saw Katia Gordeeva skating live in Beijing back in 2017 (I think). The way she seduced the audience with those big smiles...I really enjoyed her performance. I also so Evgeny Plushenko and the devastating effect he had on the crowd during his Sex Bomb routine.
 
A skater with mastery over the blades can be considered 'owning the ice'.Berezhnaya Sikharulidze had mastery Over the ice. They could gain speed with just a couple of cross overs and connect difficult moves. Same can be said of Gordeeva Grinkov's movement over the ice. I particularly loved their 1994 SP in their footwork sequence. One could watch these skaters for a long time, mesmerised by their command of the ice. I would add Johnny Weir to this list. Current skaters - PAPADAKIS and Cizeron.
IMO "mastery of the ice" means something different. Blade mastery a separate category. Blade control can be excellent, and still not "own' the ice.
.
Think: Irina, Ashley W. Gracie, Alyssa Ciszney, Sasha, S/H, and Alisa Liu, Scott H. Brian B.

It is also personal. For example, I know Gracie has mastery and ownership over the ice, but she is not someone who draws me in (I am fully aware that the is me and may or may not reflect reality
 
The ones I immediately thought of:

Katerina Witt
Brian Boitano
Christopher Bowman
Gordeeva/Grinkov
Michelle Kwan
Yuzuru Hanyu
Javier Fernandez
Papadakis/Cizeron
Nathan Chen
 
IMO "mastery of the ice" means something different. Blade mastery a separate category. Blade control can be excellent, and still not "own' the ice.
.
Think: Irina, Ashley W. Gracie, Alyssa Ciszney, Sasha, S/H, and Alisa Liu, Scott H. Brian B.

It is also personal. For example, I know Gracie has mastery and ownership over the ice, but she is not someone who draws me in (I am fully aware that the is me and may or may not reflect reality
Obviously the term is interpreted differently by different people. I am somewhat open minded about it. It can mean mastery of the blade. It could also mean audience connection at a high level (meaning skating plus pulling audience in, not just cheap theatrics).
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information