Hello, we're finally getting somewhere, and I don't mind it.
I thought they really missed an absolute gimme of a plot line in this episode, but that may draw back to them not being allowed to touch too much on the First Age stuff. Elrond and oaths. Oh my god, does Elrond ever know about oaths and the damage they can cause. They could have done so much with that, with his being fostered by Maedhros and Maglor and his seeing the dreadful consequences of the Oath of Feanor firsthand. But I guess that's way too much First Age stuff for the show to be able to work in.
It does seem Elrond's backstory is going to need more explaining though, as Earendil is described by Celebrimbor as a mortal man, which is both technically true (in his writings Tolkien confirmed that the children of elf/mortal marriages are mortal by default unless granted otherwise by the Valar or Eru) but also not true, as Earendil was the son of an elf/mortal marriage, and his wife, Elwing, was the daughter of a marriage between an elf and a half-elf/half-mortal. So casual viewers who picked that tidbit up are probably going to be scratching their heads as to how Elrond is so very clearly an elf, and also I don't think the show has connected that Elrond is the twin brother of Elros the first King of Numenor yet.
Anyway, I didn't much like the whole mithril-bringing-back-the-light thing, and I very much didn't like how Elrond worded it to Durin; a wordsmith like him could have made it much clearer that he'd been manipulated into the situation. But I'm glad Elrond and Durin are still friends. Their friendship is quite fun.
Meanwhile over in Numenor, I'm glad we're getting to see more of manipulative Pharazon, which is much more canonical. Miriel being told not to go to Middle Earth is a bit of a headscratcher, but I'm glad she's still going and holding to her faith, also more canonical. I really thought Pharazon's creepy son was going to try and claim Isildur was burning the boat when Isildur lied to cover his ass, but he didn't, mercifully.
Galadriel seemed much more mature this episode, which is a relief, and I'm glad she apologised to Halbrand. I'm also glad that we got to see a little more of Halbrand's past, but even with all the darkness behind him I'm so thrilled he chose to return to Middle Earth and take up the Kingship of the Southlands once more...even though we know his people are doomed because the Southlands will become Mordor.
We had a lovely moment with the Stranger getting accepted by the Harfoots only for that weird ice incident to happen. This was one thing that made no sense to me. Nori has seen the Stranger do a dozen scary things, even some directed at her. Why has this incident freaked her out? It was her fault for putting her hand on his arm.
And I'm glad the men who chose to leave the tower and take the offer of "mercy" from the orcs have learned quickly what that really means, even if it came at poor Rowan's expense.
Anyway, at least things are finally moving. Interested for next week's episode.