Gymnastic news #22 - Tokyo or bust

Status
Not open for further replies.
Carolla5501 said:
Compared to what we get for figure skating Daggett is great. Since somebody at NBC seems to be deathly in love with the sideshow act if they dumped him they probably put in Johnny and Tara there because they need something to do in the summer.l
NBC’s standards are pathetic
Click to expand...
I think Tim is much improved since Terry and Nastia have joined him. It seems he’s loosened up a bit and the man knows the scoring system and can explain it. I could do without the constant Simone love but all three of them are guilty of that.
 
mattiecat13 said:
I think Tim is much improved since Terry and Nastia have joined him. It seems he’s loosened up a bit and the man knows the scoring system and can explain it. I could do without the constant Simone love but all three of them are guilty of that.
Click to expand...
I like Tim. He leans a bit toward the Scott Hamilton School of Broadcasting and some of his commentary is repetitious, but he is okay.
 
As a gymnastics newbie, I don't mind Tim. He does seem to know his stuff in terms of the elements. And he doesn't seem particularly biased toward anyone, which is important. (One reason why I can't take Johnny as a commentator is I feel that his personal biases are waaaayyy too evident.) I can't really say that Nastia adds too much to the commentary, although she doesn't detract either (unlike Tara). Her comments tend toward the generic, such as "She is so on today" or "She is so elegant when she hits" etc., etc.

Without knowing any teknik, I kind of like Kayla Dicello for the final team spot after Biles, Chiles, and Lee (the latter two seem like near-locks). I enjoyed watching her, she just seems good all-around, nice line and finish, but also a lot of power. I thought Kara Eaker was more impressive on beam than Riley McCusker was on bars.

Skinner seems to be the object of dislike for many--just curious why?
 
Aceon6 said:
Toss up for me between Kara on beam and Riley on bars.
Click to expand...

Rukia said:
Yeah I feel like Riley on bars might be the choice but idk
Click to expand...

I think Riley is a neat lock for that spot. Bars is really the only spot where we have room for a specialist. Taking Kara seems silly to me when she might very well finish 3rd or 4th of the Americans in the event she’d be going for. Seems like a waste. Second bar finalist is the only way to use that spot

VGThuy said:
I think if Wong hits beam on day 2 and scores what she potentially should score with a hit routine, she’ll be on the team. She beat MyKayla Skinner on bars and floor and had a freak beam performance. She needs to hit on day 2 though.
Click to expand...

TBH, I’m surprised so many people are mentioning Wong. Wong looked great night 1 of nationals, but ever since then, it feels like she’s been making small/medium/large mistakes depending on the routine. I don’t think there’s any chance the US would want to count on her. She just seems very inconsistent. I could be wrong, though. In some ways, the hard thing is that the Top 3 are so great, it’s hard to find anyone to put up there with them.

I feel like skinner mostly has strengths in places where the US top 3 are already strong.
 
BaileyCatts said:
:shuffle: I like Tim Daggett commentating. He explains technical stuff well and I learn stuff that I don't know since I don't know anything technical about gymnastics and the elements and he points out how they made a mistake or why a skill is so much better from A than B. I think he's a good commentator. :p
Click to expand...
I love having the technical stuff explained. I think the problem with this broadcast team is that there seems to be a lot of disorganization. I find it hard to follow at times, and to know who it is they're talking about.
 
I think they should just take the top four for the team. It doesn't really matter, and it will help with their credibility with the general public. I was appalled at some of Skinners antics five years ago, but she's a woman now and seems to get along great with her peers. Her gymnastics is messy, but she's got a Katarina Witt level of grit. She will have to hit tomorrow night and if she "Missy Marlowes" (see how old I am ?) her way onto the team, more power to her.
 
I kinda enjoy Tim. He seems like a passionate gymnerd. Sure a little OTT, but nothing terrible.

I think Nastia CAN provide insight and actual analysis, though it seems few and far between in terms of her saying much of substance. I remember at trials in 2016 her very clearly articulating why Gabby Douglas wasn’t going to get credit for a skill on bars after Tim tried to say he thought she might still be given credit. So I think it’s in there, it’s just not coming to the surface most of the time. I have to wonder if she’s been instructed to keep it simple and not get in the weeds.

Laurie is clearly a natural in front of the camera. She has always been great at interviews, but I thought she handled those segments last night phenomenally. I could see her being brought in for the future. Either to commentate or in another capacity.
 
Theatregirl1122 said:
I think Riley is a neat lock for that spot. Bars is really the only spot where we have room for a specialist. Taking Kara seems silly to me when she might very well finish 3rd or 4th of the Americans in the event she’d be going for. Seems like a waste. Second bar finalist is the only way to use that spot



TBH, I’m surprised so many people are mentioning Wong. Wong looked great night 1 of nationals, but ever since then, it feels like she’s been making small/medium/large mistakes depending on the routine. I don’t think there’s any chance the US would want to count on her. She just seems very inconsistent. I could be wrong, though. In some ways, the hard thing is that the Top 3 are so great, it’s hard to find anyone to put up there with them.

I feel like skinner mostly has strengths in places where the US top 3 are already strong.
Click to expand...
I just think Wong for sure is better than Skinner on 3 out of 4 events. With a cleanish beam routine, she would outscore Skinner by some margin. If she can’t make it than I don’t mind Grace who can fill the FX hole we have, which is more useful than what Skinner can provide on VT.
 
VGThuy said:
I just think Wong for sure is better than Skinner on 3 out of 4 events. With a cleanish beam routine, she would outscore Skinner by some margin. If she can’t make it than I don’t mind Grace who can fill the FX hole we have, which is more useful than what Skinner can provide on VT.
Click to expand...

I’d rather Grace than McKayla. I like Leanne better than McKayla, but I just don’t think what she’s shown over the last 2/3 days of competition is doing it. McKayla feels redundant to me.
 
Okay, I’ve looked at the numbers and I feel like I have a better sense and I get why Leanne Wong is a still top choice for some. Focusing on trials so far because that’s the most important and I think also the best indicator of where they will be in a month:

Jordan, Simone, and Suni essentially maxes out bars and beam. Only putting Kara on the team to just do beam or Riley to just do bars would help. On a 5 member team, we honestly might put Riley on for bars. So the only thing the 4th member needs to do is be a solid backup on those two apparatuses in prelims.

So it comes down to vault and floor. Looking at the first day of trials, Grace, Leanne, McKayla, Kayla, and Shilese outscored Suni on both of those apparatuses yesterday. Shilese barely outscored Suni on floor, so I think not enough to matter.

Looking only at trials, Grace outscored Kayla on both apparatuses so it would be odd to take Kayla over Grace, but if you go back to nationals, Kayla was better than Grace. That being said, Grace has experience and momentum on her side.

Right now I feel like that leaves McKayla with the highest vault, Grace with the highest floor, and Leanne in the middle on both. I would put those 3 as my top contenders going into the last day but wouldn’t count Kayla out yet.
 
I like Leanne Wong a lot, I think her gymnastics is beautiful, but her consistency doesn't seem to be there right now which is the only reason I'm not sure about putting her on this team. McKayla does seem to be redundant with Simone so unfortunately, I see her being named an alternate again because of that reason. IMO, Grace has been getting stronger and more consistent over the weeks which is why I give her the edge on that fourth spot as of right now. I see Grace as the Kyla Ross of this team....nothing gigantic or out of this world but strong, consistent, and confident, and someone that could be sent up first on beam or bars to set the tone for the team. Tomorrow night will definitely be exciting to see who brings it on Day Two! :cheer:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)

Similar threads

Rob
Gymnastics #25 - Onward to LA
Replies
17
Views
1K
Coco
Coco
MsZem
In the best shape of their lives: The 2025 MLB thread
Replies
26
Views
2K
Kasey
Kasey
Sylvia
2024-2025 Synchro News
Replies
6
Views
2K
just tuned in
J
shutterbug
2025–26 Canadian Women: News and Updates
Replies
10
Views
2K
honey
H
Sylvia
"MAO RINK" has opened in Tachikawa, western Tokyo
Replies
2
Views
1K
Sylvia
Sylvia
Back
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information