Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,059
She earned the 4CCs assignment and I'd rather have her there than at Jr Worlds where she's likely to have a similar placement and earn less WS points.Sarah Everhardt
She earned the 4CCs assignment and I'd rather have her there than at Jr Worlds where she's likely to have a similar placement and earn less WS points.Sarah Everhardt
Hold on, this wasn't just any ol' 6th place finish at the JGPF. That was their WORST performance of the season, where they scored nearly 10 points below their lower JGP score.A 6th place finish at the GPF/JGPF--especially a GPF/JGPF the other team didn't attend--should never hurt an athletes' chances. It is both earned based on a consistent season and is a form of experience. An experience which the Mullens do not have.
As I said, it's stupid.
It's like thinking you can arbitrarily swap Green & Parsons for Bratti & Somerville and that it won't matter. Yes, it matters. Experience matters.
Well, we know that athletes have multiple pathways for selection to the Grand Prix - unless the GP Host Commission is revamping the selection process entirely, which is something we won't know until the ISU publishes next season's GP Announcement - so I don't think the USFS/USOPC are limiting which GP assignments "count" for this.Am confused about this from page 4 (emphasis mine):
"Qualification to each of the events linked within the international calendar is dependent on the
type of event.
• Grand Prix: Selection based on World Standing
o Exception: Skate America athletes are selected by respective Discipline Groups as
they are not based on World Standing"
Not results at prior Worlds? Top 24 SB? Top 75 SB? Being part of a split couple or return skater? Reaching specific Jr. results?
Thank you for posting, @ice coverage !
As most of us expected, Max Naumov has withdrawn from 4CCs and been replaced by Tomoki Hiwatashi.
Just gonna say it right now - there's no way Jason Brown is going to Worlds. If he was in decent competitive shape, he would be the one competing at this competition.
Ok, why? I think Jason going to Worlds hinges on how well the US men do at 4CCs. USFSA wants those three spots for the Olympics. If the US men can hold their nerves and lay down corkers at 4CCs, I expect one of them to be going to Worlds.Just gonna say it right now - there's no way Jason Brown is going to Worlds. If he was in decent competitive shape, he would be the one competing at this competition.
I'm thinking more cynically here and I'll say that Jason Brown WILL BE going to Worlds banking on the USFSA giving him the green light through its little monitoring session.Just gonna say it right now - there's no way Jason Brown is going to Worlds. If he was in decent competitive shape, he would be the one competing at this competition.
I'm thinking more cynically here and I'll say that Jason Brown WILL BE going to Worlds banking on the USFSA giving him the green light through its little monitoring session.
Your thoughts...
Ok, why? I think Jason going to Worlds hinges on how well the US men do at 4CCs. USFSA wants those three spots for the Olympics. If the US men can hold their nerves and lay down corkers at 4CCs, I expect one of them to be going to Worlds.
I don't see any reason why the USFS would give Jason a private monitoring session while subjecting Isabeau to a real event in order to demonstrate competitive readiness - which is part of the "Return to Play" protocol under which both of them were conditionally assigned to the Worlds team.I'm thinking more cynically here and I'll say that Jason Brown WILL BE going to Worlds banking on the USFSA giving him the green light through its little monitoring session.
Your thoughts...
I don't see any reason why the USFS would give Jason a private monitoring session while subjecting Isabeau to a real event in order to demonstrate competitive readiness - which is part of the "Return to Play" protocol under which both of them were conditionally assigned to the Worlds team.
Pure speculation on my part. I do think the USFS is moving slowly into a more transparent approach to demonstrating readiness - we know that last season they had both Chan/Howe and Liu/Nagy show up at Synchro Nats and skate at least their FSs as an exhibition that was scored by USFS judges to determine who really got the Worlds spot.Do we know that Levito was asked by USFS to compete here and/or that it was a condition of her being named to the World team? Or is it just speculation?
I hope that she was asked (or told) to compete, and would be very supportive of COMPETING PUBLICLY being the sole standard to demonstrate readiness. I've not like the subjective standard ever since Michelle Kwan's secretive monitoring session.
I agree that Brown (and Levito, for that matter) likely being on the initial entries/substitutes list is a reasonable & logical conclusion. Safe to presume that neither would want to compete at 4CCs, but would be open to competing at the Olympic test event.Preliminary entries were due for this event in December. The press release is very clear in the you snooze, you lose aspect of this competition- entries were only considered in the order they were received up to the maximum quota being reached. For men and women, that number is just 12.
Each country was allowed to name 1 entry plus two substitutes, so we don't know what the USFS was thinking and who they actually named as other considerations at that time. I would suspect Brown, who hadn't yet withdrawn from US Nationals, would have been on that list, but since Levito is there-- who knows.
It's not much more unusual than most Nats or ISU Championship weeks where competitions can start on Wednesday or Thursday. I can see it maybe being an issue for some skaters who share coaches who have other skaters at 4CCs that same week, but there's not that much overlap and most skaters have at least two coaches who handle travel responsibilities.Also, the competition takes place on an unusual Wednesday & Thursday. That may have narrowed a few choices, too.
Possibly? They could always go into the ISU system and eliminate any skaters/teams from the substitute list before it was officially published by the ISU today.These entries were due before nationals, right? Including subs? So the sub list should indicate who they were deciding between.
Possibly? They could always go into the ISU system and eliminate any skaters/teams from the substitute list before it was officially published by the ISU today.
Good point.True, but they left Ma and Naumov on there
I don't think anyone has started it yet since the Results link isn't available yet and the comp doesn't start until next Wednesday.Is there a thread for this Road to 26 Trophy in the K&C? I can't find anything.
Do we know that is actually the case or Isabeau wanted to shake off some rust at a zero pressure event/skate at the Olympic venue?I don't see any reason why the USFS would give Jason a private monitoring session while subjecting Isabeau to a real event in order to demonstrate competitive readiness - which is part of the "Return to Play" protocol under which both of them were conditionally assigned to the Worlds team.