HeatherC
Searching for Sanity
- Messages
- 12,376
So happy for Donnell and Brody! World Champs!! 
Gymnastics #25 - Onward to LA
- Thread starter Rob
- Start date
bardtoob
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 14,714
Is this how it goes with gymnastics these days? Basically, controversial results are argued based on nickle and diming the last event performed rather than looking at each individual event and pointing out how each was under or over scored?
ilovesalchows
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 2,867
Most fans are only following what the announcers are saying, and the OOB and the fall out on the turn were mentioned and also obvious to the layperson. Gymnastics scoring doesn’t have a little COP box in the upper left corner to follow along with. Can you imagine?
Tesla
Whippet Good
- Messages
- 4,715
Holy sh*t! I just saw Donnell's routine on Threads, and it was insane!
Theatregirl1122
Needs a nap
- Messages
- 34,801
I'm so happy Donnell won! I stayed up late to watch event finals on demand because I didn't want to get spoiled for it, and I'm SO glad I got to see it live. What a wonderful result!
And great that he won it especially because I've read some more code changes are going to devalue his dismount (remove a bonus actually), which would make it a lot harder to win.
Honestly, 4th on bars was an absolute WIN for Skye. Many people felt she'd have a hard time even making the final. 4th was better than could have been expected.
Overall, I'm pleased with the American ladies. Dulcy is very young, and she has time. Suni had a lot of inconsistency issues when she was younger as well, and look at her now!
That being said, I did hear a lot of "Dulcy proved the doubters wrong!" after quals, which surprised me. I don't think I've ever heard anyone suggest that Dulcy's gymnastic wouldn't score well internationally The concern for her has always been consistency, and I think worlds showed that continued to be a concern. But like I said, she's young, especially now that people don't act like gymnasts expire at 18 anymore. She may improve on that front.
Before worlds, I heard a lot of "US fans better get ready to come home with 0 medals for the women" and "when was the last time US won 0 medals," so I'm glad to see Leanne and Josc prove the doubters wrong! Certainly it was not as strong a showing as in the past, but we have a lot of injured gymnasts as well. I expect the US to be less dominant, not only without Simone, but because the world is catching up. I don't think that's a bad thing. But I still think they'll be competitive. It's only the first year of the quad.
And great that he won it especially because I've read some more code changes are going to devalue his dismount (remove a bonus actually), which would make it a lot harder to win.
Honestly, 4th on bars was an absolute WIN for Skye. Many people felt she'd have a hard time even making the final. 4th was better than could have been expected.
Overall, I'm pleased with the American ladies. Dulcy is very young, and she has time. Suni had a lot of inconsistency issues when she was younger as well, and look at her now!
That being said, I did hear a lot of "Dulcy proved the doubters wrong!" after quals, which surprised me. I don't think I've ever heard anyone suggest that Dulcy's gymnastic wouldn't score well internationally The concern for her has always been consistency, and I think worlds showed that continued to be a concern. But like I said, she's young, especially now that people don't act like gymnasts expire at 18 anymore. She may improve on that front.
Before worlds, I heard a lot of "US fans better get ready to come home with 0 medals for the women" and "when was the last time US won 0 medals," so I'm glad to see Leanne and Josc prove the doubters wrong! Certainly it was not as strong a showing as in the past, but we have a lot of injured gymnasts as well. I expect the US to be less dominant, not only without Simone, but because the world is catching up. I don't think that's a bad thing. But I still think they'll be competitive. It's only the first year of the quad.
Rob
Beach Bum
- Messages
- 15,596
I saw a clear freeze frame of Melnikova FX from behind her. Her right heel was out, her left ball of foot was on the line with her heel in the air. So the left foot did not touch out of bounds.
Theatregirl1122
Needs a nap
- Messages
- 34,801
It’s very hard to tell from a freeze frame because there’s no way to know for sure if that’s the farthest her foot went or just a moment that happened.
That being said, I think all discussion about the OOB is a distraction from how criminally high her E scores were on beam and floor. With E scores that reflected her performance, the 0.2 would not matter.
Rob
Beach Bum
- Messages
- 15,596
Agree on her scores in general. The .1 should have made no difference.
bardtoob
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 14,714
Can you imagine
- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.
youtu.be
Last edited: