Spun Silver
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 12,130
Classless.
There's still plenty of room in the Pairs PBP for gloating.
I really loved their sp from last season. I think smth in that vain, playful and youthful, suits them better right now.
Everyone can see it! But there is the Russia thread!It's not gloating. T/M have not been given the message all season long aside from GPF and now the Olympics that their fp leaves a lot to be desired. But published reviews and commentary all over the place has warned them all season and they stubbornly stuck with that program. I think that's boneheaded. Why stick with something that wrong? It does nothing for them. All commentators have pointed that out. What's the difficulty?
Still no music suggestions from T/M fans? If they get something worthy of their talent, then they would deserve their high scores. And they do need to project more. If you are their fan, can't you see that?
What a curious thing to say in a cheer thread. Well, this is not exactly the podium I wanted - happy for S/M and S/H, but would far prefer T/M, J/C and even M/H or Z/E to D/R. But it is what it is, and I think the judging was fair, so have to live with that.This is the podium I wanted, and I'm completely happy that it came out the way I'd hoped.
What a curious thing to say in a cheer thread. Well, this is not exactly the podium I wanted - happy for S/M and S/H, but would far prefer T/M, J/C and even M/H or Z/E to D/R. But it is what it is, and I think the judging was fair, so have to live with that.
As for music suggestions, I second the poster from the Russian thread who wrote that they need powerful classical pieces. More Rachmaninov. Or Tchaikovsky, and IMO a symphony would work much better than a ballet which is the most common choice in figure skating. I think they might do a great Shostakovich program - his music is very charismatic. Beethoven and even Brahms would also be a good choice. They just need to stay away from lyrical pieces and choose something majestic and passionate.
Actually, I think that the general idea of having one powerful classical program and one light-hearted program is good. But the specific choice of songs this year was unfortunate. I loved their short last season, and I think this is the kind of light-hearted music they need to look for.
And they definitely need beautiful costumes. They are both so good-looking that it's a crime to dress them like this.
I agree! K/S were never among my favourites, but that music choice was great. IMO Tchaikovsky's symphonies are underused in skating. They have so many lovely and grandiose parts in a variety of moods that would make an amazing impactful program.Reading this just makes me depressed that Manfred Symphony never made it to the Olympics. What a masterpiece!
It's true Elena and Anton constantly made mistakes but they were packaged to perfection and still won many medals. And when your packaged the right way things still can go your way, it won't just collapse. The right package can give you a boost even on your worst day while the wrong one can sink you completely. Don't give the judges any reason to dump you! T/M have unfortunately done that for multiple seasons
I agree! K/S were never among my favourites, but that music choice was great. IMO Tchaikovsky's symphonies are underused in skating. They have so many lovely and grandiose parts in a variety of moods that would make an amazing impactful program.
Serves them right for sticking with Candyman and dying with it. Why couldn't they and their team accept that was not their style? This is the podium I wanted, and I'm completely happy that it came out the way I'd hoped. The only other result which would have been tremendous is J/C landing in third, but 5th place is also a bonus for them, as I think their spirits had been dampened over the course of the season being lowballed by the judges.
In Pyeongchang, the judges overscored so many teams in the sp, and obviously those numbers came down for many in the fp, but not far enough for some teams who had rather poor showings. The Canadian teams were all excellent.
T/M desperately need help finding something more worthy of them, and learning how to bring out their connection on the ice. They are just not soulful at all. And when they skate great, there's still something lacking, but they've been so over-rewarded in the marks generally. I'm so glad they were properly dinged this time for another sad fp performance.
What would fans suggest T/M do for next season? They seriously need to ask for ideas, like Cain/LeDuc did.
Reading this just makes me depressed that Manfred Symphony never made it to the Olympics. What a masterpiece! Poor K&S And poor T/M for having to be the ones who repeat what K&S went through in 2010. I was hoping no Russian team would have to go through that again
But I totally agree with you. I think the Rachmaninov SP proved that the dramatic classical pieces are their best friend. It really shows them off in the best light. They also seem really comfortable with it and that makes a huge difference in how they come off. They seem to come more alive with the more powerful then the softer
Manfred was a great program, but K/S did not have anywhere near high quality elements, and really never did.
Your post does not indicate that you care. You are here to gloat about your favorite pairs that made the podium last night...
There's also a Pairs discussion thread in the Trash Can.If you want me to take it to Russian thread...
Exactly! I'm surprised that people blame Candyman for their failure. Candyman did not prevent them from winning two GPs and the Europeans. But they had three major mistakes at the Olympics, and that's why they didn't medal. The program is not to blame, unless one believes that there is some Polka-Dotted Candyman Curse involvedI posted this earlier (in another thread)- they lost because they made mistakes last night and not because they skated to Candyman.
It's true he doesn't have the personality for that music (he did try his best bless his heart) but she does which is why I guess they went for it, hoping she could carry it (which is unfair to both of them). She defiantly does have star quality.
If they both had "it" the program, still an atrocity, would have been far more palatable. But they definately do need to stick to music where they both have "it." It will only make the better