caseyedwards
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 24,066
And It probably will be judged being coached by Zhulin is implicit nonverbal support of the war because he is everywhere supporting the warI believe they're with Zhulin now
And It probably will be judged being coached by Zhulin is implicit nonverbal support of the war because he is everywhere supporting the warI believe they're with Zhulin now
This is incorrect. No Russian is eligible to complete. They are eligible to be evaluated by the isu to see if they have anything in their life that connects them to the war or doping. Connections to the war can be implicit and nonverbal. No Russian is eligible. They are just eligible to be evaluated as of right now. No one should expect any Russians in China or ItalyI'm a bit thick, so in shorthand, is this the current position? -
-1 skater or team from RUS can compete in the 2026 Olympics per discipline. The qualifying competition will be in China (which one?)
-They will compete as a neutral athlete; no flag no anthem
-The skater(s) must have never participated in pro-war activities (the extent of participation is not defined?)
-The associated coaching team must never have participated in pro-war activities
-As is normal, athletes obviously must be doping free (negative doping tests)
-Coaches must be free of doping scandal.
This is what I got out of the thread.
I'm a bit thick, so in shorthand, is this the current position? -
-1 skater or team from RUS can compete in the 2026 Olympics per discipline. The qualifying competition will be in China (which one?)
It is not clear any will be deemed eligible so you can’t say for sure they will compete.The qualifying competition for Olympic spots this year is separate from Nebelhorn and will be held in China. They will compete with all other nations that didn't earn spots at worlds or that earned the chance to compete for an additional spot due to placements at worlds.
The rules have already been set! The rules have already been written to exclude Russians based on implicit nonverbal support. How can they undo what they have already set in motion withe this implicit nonverbal test.I think that with the change of administration in the US, if Putin really cares about Oly participation and we know he does, there might be pressure on US sports federations from theUS government to help facilitate that. Certainly nobody at USFS is going to stand up to a Trumpie leaning on them.
But it's the ISU's decision. So USFS would have to be pressured enough that they put pressure on the ISU which I don't see happening. It's easy enough to nod your head when asked to put pressure on them but then just not do it, for one thing.I think that with the change of administration in the US, if Putin really cares about Oly participation and we know he does, there might be pressure on US sports federations from theUS government to help facilitate that. Certainly nobody at USFS is going to stand up to a Trumpie leaning on them.
I think that with the change of administration in the US, if Putin really cares about Oly participation and we know he does, there might be pressure on US sports federations from theUS government to help facilitate that. Certainly nobody at USFS is going to stand up to a Trumpie leaning on them.
I can't see the USFS or the USOPC putting much pressure on either the ISU or IOC with regard to Russia returning to the Olympics. What I could see, if there is a peace deal by the time the OQE comes around is the ISU, under pressure from the IOC, is the following:But it's the ISU's decision. So USFS would have to be pressured enough that they put pressure on the ISU which I don't see happening. It's easy enough to nod your head when asked to put pressure on them but then just not do it, for one thing.
With the rules put into place for 2022, Shaidorov finishing in the top 10 means that Jirenbeyev presumably would be sent to China to try to qualify another spot. At this point, that would be an extreme long shot.Having just finished watching the 4 Continents I noted there was quite a large team from Kazakhstan, which I expect will be well-represented in the next Olympics.
Sofia Samodelkina is on the entry list for Worlds. I think she has a very good chance of securing a spot for Kazakhstan at next year's Winter Olympic GamesNo Kazakh women at Worlds means one could be sent to China, as well- and they are in the same boat as Jirenbeyev. Extremely unlikely to qualify (at this point).
Yeah I don't know why I skipped right over her. She's not only in good position to secure the spot, but she could even finish top 10. She was great at 4CC. So 2 athletes for 2026.Sofia Samodelkina is on the entry list for Worlds. I think she has a very good chance of securing a spot for Kazakhstan at next year's Winter Olympic Games
So the two youngsters, Petrosian and the D guy whose name I can’t spell, should be ok. MishGal and StepBuk, no.So, apparently, FIG is in the process of reviewing Russian gymnasts for AIN status to allow them to return to competition and rumor is that Viktoria Listunova was rejected simply for posting a photo on her social media about Victory Day.
If the same firm conducting FIG's reviews will be handling the ISU's reviews, then I would anticipate that pretty much anyone who has had anything to do with Putin, even just showing up at the Kremlin for a 2022 Beijing Winter Olympians recognition day, is likely to be rejected. Same with all those skaters who were at that Plushenko show in Tula that had the pre-war rally they were obligated to attend in April 2022.
Women - Petrosian is going to be a question mark since she trains with Team Eteri and has been with her for years, but we'll see. No one knows for sure who the 2nd woman submitted is - I think I've seen rumors it may be Alina Gorbacheva, but that's just whispers. Other option seems to be Anna Frolova.S
So The two youngsters, Petrosian and the D guy whose name I can’t spell, should be ok. MishGal and StepBuk, no.
You don’t have to do anything explicit! It’s in the rules you can’t do anything implicit or nonverbal. All these people are taking money from sanctioned pro war channel one to be on their skating show in a few days. It’s a pro war tv channel they are being paid by. Gumenik may not have anything on his social media but he’s going to be on pro war channel in a few days! Implicit nonverbal act of pro war! There is no one you named that isn’t about to be paid to be on sanctioned pro war tv channel.Women - Petrosian is going to be a question mark since she trains with Team Eteri and has been with her for years, but we'll see. No one knows for sure who the 2nd woman submitted is - I think I've seen rumors it may be Alina Gorbacheva, but that's just whispers. Other option seems to be Anna Frolova.
Men - should be Gumennik, who seems to have posted NOTHING on his social media that is even remotely pro-war. I'd be shocked if the substitute isn't Dikidzhi - 4A and all that.
Pairs - MishGal and BoiKoz would be out if the rules are as strict as the ones that have been applied to the gymnasts. Khabibulina/Knyazhuk and Mukhortova/Evgeniev (who were interesting in juniors, IIRC) would be the other options, I think, but I have no idea what their social media history is.
Dance - for sure StepBuk are out, same with Khavronina/Naryzhnyy - her dad is either military or an oligarch, IIRC. The RFSF may have just gone for one of the young teams, to try & set them up for the next quad instead - Pasechnik/Cirisano or Kaganovskaya/Nekrasov.
Just an FYI on the timeline - it looks like FIG submitted their AIN names in early January, and it's taken a couple months for FIG to approve/reject, so we're probably not going to hear anything definitive until after WTT at the earliest.
What about the three pairs from Perm? I think they may be as good as Khabibulina/Knyazhuk and Mukhortova/Evgeniev. I know there have been some injuries but they haven’t split up, have they?Pairs - MishGal and BoiKoz would be out if the rules are as strict as the ones that have been applied to the gymnasts. Khabibulina/Knyazhuk and Mukhortova/Evgeniev (who were interesting in juniors, IIRC) would be the other options, I think, but I have no idea what their social media history is.
Trump/Musk (AKA Mump) will pressure the IOC, the IOC will pressure the ISU, and Mump and the ISU will pressure USFS... Putin wiil be pushing for full reinstatement by 2026.I think that with the change of administration in the US, if Putin really cares about Oly participation and we know he does, there might be pressure on US sports federations from theUS government to help facilitate that. Certainly nobody at USFS is going to stand up to a Trumpie leaning on them.
This is such a ridiculous statement it almost does not bear responding, but it needs to be addressed.Trump/Musk (AKA Mump) will pressure the IOC, the IOC will pressure the ISU, and Mump and the ISU will pressure USFS... Putin wiil be pushing for full reinstatement by 2026.
it really really didn'tThis is such a ridiculous statement it almost does not bear responding, but it needs to be addressed.
YMMV - but, I do think it is worth reiterating that the IOC has been horribly squishy on the question of the continued ban on Russian & Belarusian athletes for the better part of the last 2 years. For the first year or so, they weren't entertaining the notion of allowing RUS/BLR back, despite rumblings from some of the international sports feds who had presidents from Russia or Russia's satellite nations. None of what's happening now with regard to the ISU (and other winter sports feds) allowing for AINs in Milano-Cortina is in any way surprising if one follows the IOC. They certainly won't hesitate with lifting the ban entirely as soon as there is a ceasefire not because of anything any world leader has done to intervene on their behalf but because they're well-inclined to do it all on their own at first cessation of hostilities.it really really didn't
False Russia is banned and likely to not send one person to Italy. This in your mind is pro Russia. What’s anti Russia?YMMV - but, I do think it is worth reiterating that the IOC has been horribly squishy on the question of the continued ban on Russian & Belarusian athletes for the better part of the last 2 years. For the first year or so, they weren't entertaining the notion of allowing RUS/BLR back, despite rumblings from some of the international sports feds who had presidents from Russia or Russia's satellite nations. None of what's happening now with regard to the ISU (and other winter sports feds) allowing for AINs in Milano-Cortina is in any way surprising if one follows the IOC. They certainly won't hesitate with lifting the ban entirely as soon as there is a ceasefire not because of anything any world leader has done to intervene on their behalf but because they're well-inclined to do it all on their own at first cessation of hostilities.
Based on what? They are not. The overwhelming frontrunner is Coe. He is favored to win and it’s not expected to be close. He aims to continue to bans on Russia and its athletes.I agree that the IOC has been chomping at the bit to get theback in and that they've been taking a dismantling approach to their problem.
I wish the Olympics would be put down, but that's after I get my pony.
And what if every European country decided to boycott as well as American Canada Japan athletes if Russia is there? They aren’t going to choose to have only Russia and China at the OlympicsI wouldn’t be surprised if reversing IOC policy is on Putin’s negotiation wish list. It doesn’t cost Zelenskyy anything relative to other concessions and Trump will be happy to facilitate and piss off Europe again.