PeterG
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 13,625
Just watched The Whale tonight. It was SOOOOO much better than I expected!! Whoever created the movie trailer should not be allowed to do that job anymore. And the publicity people did an awful job promoting this movie. Every clip I saw on a talk show made me want to avoid this movie. Plus Brendan Fraser's overwrought, breathless talk-show appearances almost turned me off to this movie. Luckily I decided to watch it as an Oscar nominee because I loved it. Such an original and wonderfully overwhelming story. Kudos to screenwriter Samuel D. Hunter and director Darren Aronofsky for working on this project for ten years until they finally got the story and the production to where they wanted it to be. A complete success.
I agree that the entire cast were phenomenal. Ty Simpkins as the Christian missionary and Samantha Morton as Charlie's ex-wife deserve to be mentioned as well. Hong Chau as Charlie's friend/caretaker was so strong, I think she deserved the Oscar over Jamie Lee Curtis. But then I think all the nominees in that category deserved the Oscar over Curtis, who won as a sentimental favourite and as a career acheivement award. Curtis was good in Everything, Everywhere...but just wasn't as good as everybody else in her category. JMHO.
I agree that it was a tough movie to watch, but an important one to watch. I found it very entertaining, with more characters a part of the story than I realized. And not everyone appearing to be what they seem. And how everyone interacted as truths came to light. Such a well-written movie!
I went yesterday to see "The Whale". Very well-done, a bit disturbing and dark, with excellent acting all around. I get the kudos for Brenden Fraser, I can't imagine anyone topping his performance in this for the Academy Award. He really was immersed in the character, and the character was both sympathetic and frustrating. The actress who played the daughter was also very good, as well as the friend. It kind of is a story about addiction, although his addiction is food, because he's using it to numb his emotions. A bit of a challenging movie to get through.
I agree that the entire cast were phenomenal. Ty Simpkins as the Christian missionary and Samantha Morton as Charlie's ex-wife deserve to be mentioned as well. Hong Chau as Charlie's friend/caretaker was so strong, I think she deserved the Oscar over Jamie Lee Curtis. But then I think all the nominees in that category deserved the Oscar over Curtis, who won as a sentimental favourite and as a career acheivement award. Curtis was good in Everything, Everywhere...but just wasn't as good as everybody else in her category. JMHO.
Finally watched The Whale on dvd. It was really tough to watch. I am guessing it would be even tougher in a theater. The acting was great, but I can't really say that I liked the movie. It was well made.The side story of the young man Thomas was interesting. The relationship with the daughter was developed well.
At the end it was nice to see the positive, though it was not what I had hoped for.
It is possible that I don't enjoy movies based on plays, although in this case the stage to screen conversion was done really well. I can't place a finger on what bothered me about it. That's odd.
I may give it 7/10, though it was not a movie I really enjoyed.
I agree that it was a tough movie to watch, but an important one to watch. I found it very entertaining, with more characters a part of the story than I realized. And not everyone appearing to be what they seem. And how everyone interacted as truths came to light. Such a well-written movie!