Let’s be real, both of them would have an argument over Lu Chen’s SP given her UR on her Lutz and her low quality spins. And I love Lu Chen.
True - despite a clean program, Lulu could potentially receive up to:
-0.2 for telegraphing and rotation on the lutz (I personally wouldn't have deducted),
-0.2 for the pause before the 3toe,
-0.1 for lack of rev on layback (I rewatched many times and can't decide, but it was a beautiful spin),
-0.1 for the spirals if you feel stingy (I personally wouldn't have deducted),
-0.1 for the steps for starting too late off the end of the rink (I personally wouldn't have deducted),
-0.1 for telegraphing the 2axel (I personally wouldn't have deducted),
-0.1 for the travel on the final combo spin.
Presentation wise I would be OK with 5.8 or even 5.9.