Plushenko's Son

[Tinami Amori]

I mean was the short video I linked not edited and it’s exactly what she said?

That video is not the original interview which caused the issue. It's a much later interview where Yana explains what happened and is getting upset and saying not very smart things, or rather not in a very smart forms which itself can be misquoted and twisted, sort of this "no we're not beating our kids with a belt, and we're not locking him up in a dark trunk...... but what if we did? in our days our parents did that".

 

[Meoima]

That video is not the original interview which caused the issue. It's a much later interview where Yana explains what happened and is getting upset and saying not very smart things, or rather not in a very smart forms which itself can be misquoted and twisted, sort of this "no we're not beating our kids with a belt, and we're not locking him up in a dark trunk...... but what if we did? in our days our parents did that".

I am very much confused. If Yana and Plushenko didn’t hit and lock baby Sasha in the dark room, why so many Russian fans are getting mad?

 

[Tinami Amori]

I am very much confused. If Yana and Plushenko didn’t hit and lock baby Sasha in the dark room, why so many Russian fans are getting mad?

for many reasons probably..... did not read the text carefully, read the headline only, media misquoted, twisted, Yana did not give calm reasonable response and only made it worst, people don't like them, some are jealous of their wealth which Yana displays in videos (vacations, two luxury homes), Yana is half jewish (a wealthy jew who rips off poor russians), she is known to be rude and kurz with people..... just typical human situation...

 

[Meoima]

for many reasons probably..... did not read the text carefully, read the headline only, media misquoted, twisted, Yana did not give calm reasonable response and only made it worst, people don't like them, some are jealous of their wealth which Yana displays in videos (vacations, two luxury homes), Yana is half jewish (a wealthy jew who rips off poor russians), she is known to be rude and kurz with people..... just typical human situation...

Have you watched the whole video? I mean the original video which was 55 minutes?

 

[Tinami Amori]

Have you watched the whole video? I mean the original video which was 55 minutes?

The original long interview is about many issues, Kemerovo fire, politics, etc... the "kid issue" is just a small part of it. What is your question?

 

[lala]

One does not comprehend happiness in the truest sense when they are physically, mentally and emotionally abused. What 5 year old grasps that concept?

This disgusts me. Evgeny Plushenko was never a favourite of mine and I agree with the outcry. Take the kid away and lock them up...

Oh I'm waiting somethin like this. He didn't like him as a skater , didn't like him as a person, but didn't know him thus you believe this immediately...
This disgust me..

 

[lala]

I've found the original source - Rudkovskaya's video interview on Dozhd TV (Russain independent channel), you can't watch the full video without subscribing, but the source is pretty reliable
https://tvrain.ru/lite/teleshow/sindeeva/rudkovskaja-460891/

I ask again:

Did you heard this from Rudkovskaya?

"Millionaire mother of five-year-old Russian skating prodigy admits beating him with a belt and locking him in a dark cupboard so he can become 'the best skater in the world'"

 

[Twilight1]

Oh I'm waiting somethin like this. He didn't like him as a skater , didn't like him as a person, but didn't know him thus you believe this immediately...
This disgust me..

I disgust a lot of people... but then I don't abuse my kid for the sake of my need for fame.

 

[lala]

I disgust a lot of people... but then I don't abuse my kid for the sake of my need for fame.

A lots of people who don't know anything. But they are happy this is a scandal!!! But you are happy this is a Russian scandal they are cheaters and animals!

 

[Twilight1]

I just happen to think abuse is wrong. You could be from any country, it doesn't matter.

To be honest... not sure what his being Russian has to do with this and not sure why YOU are making it an issue.

BTW- I am team Yagudin. Last I checked... he is Russian.

 

[giselle23]

Where is Plushenko in all this? He can't condone any of it.

He is doing the abusing, according to the article.

 

[Twilight1]

He is doing the abusing, according to the article.

At best complacent to the mom doing it, and according to the article he uses a belt to dole punishment.

 

[oleada]

If this is true, this is child abuse. Poor kid

 

[lala]

He is doing the abusing, according to the article.

No. I recommand you read carefully this thread..

 

[cholla]

It's part of what i translated, she told the story what happened in the original interview, and what son said and what she said. Then she is getting upset that people twisted it, etc..

Thanks Tinami for the explanations, including the ones in your previous posts. I wish people could actually take them into account instead of jumping in the bandwagon to slaughter the so-called culprits. I'm not fond of people who instrumentalize their kid for marketing purpose but there is a huge difference between that and actually beating up a child.

 

[Judy]

One does not comprehend happiness in the truest sense when they are physically, mentally and emotionally abused. What 5 year old grasps that concept?

This disgusts me. Evgeny Plushenko was never a favourite of mine and I agree with the outcry. Take the kid away and lock them up...

This is horrible. That is child abuse. The fact that the child isn’t being given a choice what he wants to do - that is disgusting.

 

[Twilight1]

We stopped corporal punishment in schools for a reason.

Parents forcing their dreams and aspirations onto their kids and living vicariously through their children and mentally and emotionally abusing them is nothing new. I speak against them too though.

I get people raise their kid their own way but if your kid becomes abusive themselves... it is because of you as a parent.

There is also a direct link between personality disorders and abuse.

 

[giselle23]

No. I recommand you read carefully this thread..

Yes, the thread, but the article says otherwise. Not crediting it, just reporting what it says.

 

[Tinami Amori]

Yes, the thread, but the article says otherwise. Not crediting it, just reporting what it says.

The "article" is in a stupid western yellow press, which misquoted the original conversation. The Russian interview in Yana's own words explains differently.

===
Yana should stop giving interviews and making videos about how well they live. It pisses people off, and creates animosity against the family, and people are looking for reasons to hate them.

Plushenko family recently went to Maldeives. They rented a huge luxury villa, with private beach, cook and playground. They hired a site-seeing submarine for the day to let the kids see the under-water world. They flown in a private jet, they dress up their kids in famous brand clothing…. Not smart…

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10QX5cXo6NY

She brags how well she looks…. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O_WyBalSAgE
How they hire a private yacht to vacation off the coast of Italy.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Kk5KSckUgg

Plus! Plushenko just opened his own private skating rink on Maldieves…… and that’s out in the press. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sohHBsvEmZk

Russian masses get easily jealous, many people are still remains of "soviet system", and resent success, and it’s not smart to poke a beehive.

Western yellow press on the other hand, are looking for anything that will make anything "russian" look bad. Daily Mail is UK, they know that today a "bad russian" article will sell...

 

[lala]

Yes, the thread, but the article says otherwise. Not crediting it, just reporting what it says.

Don't you believe Tinami?

 

[lala]

This is horrible. That is child abuse. The fact that the child isn’t being given a choice what he wants to do - that is disgusting.

Why do you believe immediately?

 

[Judy]

A lots of people who don't know anything. But they are happy this is a scandal!!! But you are happy this is a Russian scandal they are cheaters and animals!

Absolutely not - this is a child!

For the record Russians are not animals and it is the Russian government that is corrupt.

 

[Tinami Amori]

Nobody is beating Sasha…. Plushenko and Yana are great parents.. and if anything, they are over-protective and over-baring...

They make art with the kid and let him destroy expensive furniture.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aa5mSMjjoFs

Teach him to use internet https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRzvJiJ_x3Y

Take him fishing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6cJBP5ljfTQ

Buy him skates https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6ggJbTaDvc

They let him ride roller skates on 10K Italian marble floor in the formal reception room full of Waterford crystal and collector’s art…. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2HMXWT-R-M

… and let him with mother’s 2K shoes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eZU_ACnoQZE

May every kid be so “abused”… https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ilTWAbY_AG8

 

[UGG]

The Daily Mail is a gossip mag but if this is untrue they will be sued for defamation for sure. Why would a magazine make this up about a figure skater who retired 8 years ago that no one around here cares about? Seems odd and random but at any rate this is really atrocious and I’d its true I hope they go to jail.

 

[lala]

Nobody is beating Sasha…. Plushenko and Yana are great parents.. and if anything, they are over-protective and over-baring...

They make art with the kid and let him destroy expensive furniture.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aa5mSMjjoFs

Teach him to use internet https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qRzvJiJ_x3Y

Take him fishing https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6cJBP5ljfTQ

Buy him skates https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6ggJbTaDvc

They let him ride roller skates on 10K Italian marble floor in the formal reception room full of Waterford crystal and collector’s art…. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L2HMXWT-R-M

… and let him with mother’s 2K shoes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eZU_ACnoQZE

May every kid be so “abused”… https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ilTWAbY_AG8

Do you think someone interested in your post? No. They are abusing their children

 

[Ananas Astra]

The thing is, we don't know for sure what is going on at Casa Plushenko when the smartphones and cameras are turned off...

 

[Twilight1]

lala- explain how a 5 year old kid would lie? It was from the mouth of babes themself. Or do all 5 year old children lie?

I never said they are beating him senseless. Stereotyping abuse is ridiculous.

 

[chapis]

The Daily Mail is a gossip mag but if this is untrue they will be sued for defamation for sure. Why would a magazine make this up about a figure skater who retired 8 years ago that no one around here cares about? Seems odd and random but at any rate this is really atrocious and I’d its true I hope they go to jail.

Nobody cares? Are you kidding? He has more followers on his instagram than the most of the active skaters.

 

[lala]

The thing is, we don't know for sure what is going on at Casa Plushenko when the smartphones and cameras are turned off...

I know!! They humiliate, beat their all sons. Andrei is 16, Nikolai is 15.( Nikolai started his career as a musician.) Probably they will be older will say everything for the media! You just need to wait!!

Or maybe they can move to the billionair father... He could help for them!

 

[lala]

lala- explain how a 5 year old kid would lie? It was from the mouth of babes themself. Or do all 5 year old children lie?

I never said they are beating him senseless. Stereotyping abuse is ridiculous.

Show me please literally and with the whole situation