overedge
Mayor of Carrot City
- Messages
- 37,149
I've watched about 2/3 of it so far. I really like how it shows that T&D came from ordinary families, i.e. putting the lie to the idea that elite skaters are rich and don't have to worry about anything other than skating. But like others I think that some of the melodrama is overplayed. Also, from T&D's books and from photos of them back in the day, the Nottingham ice rink was a lot more, um, basic than it's portrayed. A man driving a tractor with a wet cloth dragging behind it is not going to make ice that looks like that 
One thing that really bothers me about it, though, is that the skating styles that are shown are not the ice dance styles of the late 70s/early 80s. That's important to the story, because part of what made T&D so great is that they pushed the rules and tried to resist that very rigid, upright upper bodies, constrained type of ice dancing. Any ice dancers doing the moves in the earlier part of the movie would have broken about a bazillion rules and not gotten anywhere. Instead of making melodrama about the personal relationships, the writer/filmmaker could have made a lot of genuine drama about the tension between what T&D wanted to do and what the rules permitted at the time. They also could have made more of Torvill's success in pairs prior to doing ice dance.
Also, while ice skating tests are certainly not interesting TV fodder, both T&D almost had their skating careers ended by failing tests - Torvill when she couldn't go back to singles after doing pairs, Dean when he almost failed the senior ice dance test. That should have been part of the storyline too IMO.
And while this movie isn't a documentary, any idea why Torvill's first partner was called "Andrew" rather than his real name, Michael?
One thing that really bothers me about it, though, is that the skating styles that are shown are not the ice dance styles of the late 70s/early 80s. That's important to the story, because part of what made T&D so great is that they pushed the rules and tried to resist that very rigid, upright upper bodies, constrained type of ice dancing. Any ice dancers doing the moves in the earlier part of the movie would have broken about a bazillion rules and not gotten anywhere. Instead of making melodrama about the personal relationships, the writer/filmmaker could have made a lot of genuine drama about the tension between what T&D wanted to do and what the rules permitted at the time. They also could have made more of Torvill's success in pairs prior to doing ice dance.
Also, while ice skating tests are certainly not interesting TV fodder, both T&D almost had their skating careers ended by failing tests - Torvill when she couldn't go back to singles after doing pairs, Dean when he almost failed the senior ice dance test. That should have been part of the storyline too IMO.
And while this movie isn't a documentary, any idea why Torvill's first partner was called "Andrew" rather than his real name, Michael?
