The article above makes me think of MBTI. I know it’s not a real science and is more akin to woo woo astrology (no offense to anyone), but I find the Jungian concepts of cognitive functions helpful.
Samuels touches upon something about Malinin being an adrenaline junkie and use of the voiceover affirmations. IMO, he’s a clear ESTP, where his default mode is to chase sensations in the external (extroverted sensing), supported by introverted thinking, and with a tertiary child-position extroverted feeling following. This means his introverted feeling function is his blindspot.
This is why I was worried when he mentioned Beijing after his skate. If Ilia holds onto the attitude that he “would’ve won gold if only he’d been in Beijing,” and he keeps that resentment alive as the explanation for what goes wrong now, he’s setting himself up for another rough Olympics. Even if you think USFS made the wrong call in 2022, staying emotionally chained to that grievance is going to fester and distort his self-assessment with introverted feeling being his blindspot. He can be angry about it and still recognize that it won’t help him skate better in the present or future.
His tertiary or child position extroverted feeling function is why all the social media posts gassing him up and openly blaming the USFS and Beijing team selection can be harmful…it is where fans can actually hurt him. If he lets the fanbase get in his head and validate this complete blame to where he adopts the mindset that his problems are totally outside himself, latches onto an easy external enemy (USFS), and feeds his ego with a steady stream of “you were robbed” or “they did you wrong”, or “it’s not on you,” then he won’t learn anything from yesterday. He’ll just repeat the same emotional cycle with a different event attached to it.
For his sake, I hope he just lets the fans stay bitter without succumbing to it because he cannot afford to. Instead, he needs to accept reality of the trajectory of his life, including being left off Beijing. He also needs to now feel the frustration and learn to accept yesterday’s mistakes and own them. It’s ok for him to go over what went wrong, what he could have controlled, what changes he needs to implement, and allow himself to feel his feelings and be comfortable with them. I don’t want fan attitudes to make him run back to where he’ll turn this and maybe future setbacks on the USFS and starts blaming them for what went wrong yesterday and in the future.
He does seems to have strong people around him who can help keep him grounded and accountable. I just hope the online noise doesn’t become a crutch, because that’s how you end up stuck in grievance instead of growth.
Again, the system put Jason & Ilia in the same priority group once Nationals was finished.
Yes, Jason had senior results that Ilia did not, but that is more a result of the 2020 JGP being entirely canceled so Ilia's options were - 2 guaranteed JGP assignments or maybe 1 SkAm host GP & whatever Challenger assignments he could muster up between Covid restrictions & the other US men vying for those assignments. He & his team chose the JGP assignments and he did very well in those.
Ultimately, the USFS placed more value on those senior results than on the junior ones, then completely ignored the Nationals results. There was nothing in the selection criteria that said they'd weigh senior results more heavily than junior ones. Had that been made clear, perhaps Ilia's team would have chosen a SkAm host assignment & 2-3 Challengers instead of the JGP.
There are all sorts of ways to pretzel-logic oneself into believing that placing Jason on the 2022 Olympic team over Ilia was the correct choice. Time has proven it was not.
It’s not pretzel logic, it’s just logic. Being logical does not mean there’s only one correct choice. Ilia or Jason were both reasonable choices. You wanted one choice and they went with another. As for time, who the eff knows? You have no idea what would have happened to Ilia’s life if he went to Beijing. As said above, harping on it only feeds resentment and it’s unproductive. It also feeds the need to say “I told you so” even if the alternative was uncertain.