Repercussions of Papadakis' book & Cizeron's response

"NBC shouldn’t have fired Olympic gold medalist Gabriella Papadakis. They should be thrilled to have her on board to discuss the issues of abuse, power and control in figure skating in her new book."

Unfortunately, that wasn't what Gabi was hired for. NBC doesn't want to have such a discussion. Sadly, Gabi is not the only one to experience this. Skaters in the U.S. have, and NBC has shown little interest in covering it. They definitely don't want to talk about it while they're trying to get viewers for Olympic figure skating.

Christine Brennan, of course, loves the drama. But, I'm all for shedding a light on these serious issues with the hope that things improve and that parents put their kids into skating with their eyes wide open.
 
Guillaume and Laurence truly are amazing. That was great. From just watching the skating you'd not know there was some other stuff going on.

I'm saddened to see what's happened with Gabi and Guillaume. An amazing duo on the ice, to... this. I never imagined all that was going on and the negative feelings obviously very close to the surface. I thought since they'd been together since childhood, with all their shared history, there would be a certain level of connection that nothing could break apart. Obviously not. Well, I wish him the best at Olys, and I hope she's able to come to terms with her history... because it sounds like a work in progress, from where I sit. She's had a very rough go and I wish her peace moving forward.
It was obvious for a long time though that they weren't friends. They moved in different orbits. They had different friends, and different values. But as per earlier sentiments may she rise above this.
 
Continued, vocal support of, even.

There's also the point that when Gabi started skating in shows with Madi Hubbell some interviewers were straight up asking her if she'd asked Guillaume for permission to skate with somebody else - after their partnership had been formally dissolved - while I don't recall seeing any commentator ask the same question of him when he started skating with Laurence. If it were me, I think that casting of her in the public mind as being not just permanently linked to but subordinate to him even once they had nothing more to do with each other would probably make his ability to just pick up and carry on without anyone blinking rankle more than a bit!
I think this is the challenge with most female partners, separating your true identity from your role of prop on the ice. Sometimes it plays tricks on the mind.
 
The book is about Gabi's tough life -- from her childhood where they hardly had any money, to a very crazy skating mom to her insecurity, drugs, alcohol, abortion. She was drinking at a very young age. One time she woke up and she didn’t know how she was covered in cocaine. What she wrote was a very sad life story.

But I guess the book marketing (especially the strategy of dropping excerpts here and there) veered towards the dynamics with Guillaume as that will make the book get talked about even more. Makes a great story that the ex-partner is a strong contender for an Olympic gold medal with a new partner.
 
I think this is the challenge with most female partners, separating your true identity from your role of prop on the ice. Sometimes it plays tricks on the mind.

It sounds from the quote you're responding to like it was the journalists that couldn't separate Gabi from her identity as Guillaume's partner. Gabi was already redefining herself by moving on.
 
I’m completely unshocked at Brennan’s take and wonder if she will be interviewed by NBC during the Olys. I’ll bet not, they’re afraid she will criticize them and she has the stature to do it.

Who are the B/S Scott disliked? Can’t figure it out. And fwiw I think Johnnny’s report was well within the bounds of commentating. He’s not a wire service that has to stick to just the facts.
 
Yes this. Didn't f/b see this? Did she want a chance at a more successful career than she had at all costs?
She switched 2 countries for a career by now, ruined her health and spent her whole life skating. Of course she does want a successful career and skating with Cizeron is a certain mesal
Does she not have an ounce of compassion to how this looked?
Should she care? If she wins a gold medal its a gold medal and it will look good on her neck
Did she think 2 self involved men had her best interests at heart here?
They all seem to have the same interest - to win. And I should hope her fiance and her best friend should have her best interest at heart there
I am just gobsmacked that there wasn't one person that said this isn't really a good thing. Get rid of Sorenson, distance yourself from MTL and maybe say something complimentary about your former partner. Be a human. Be an inspiration not a cautionary tale.
She will be much more of an inspiration if she wins the Olympics
 
Book read.

I totally love it. I think a lot of female ice dancers, female figure skaters, women in general should thank Gabriella for writing it.

Because what she describes through her personal experience is a hitchcockian universe that slowly, step after step, draws her to the verge of madness and suicide, a place that makes her doubt her own memories, her own sanity, destroys any safe place she may have or want to build and ends up making her physically sick.

The little moments she describes of her experience with her partner, her coaches, the world of ice dance are like zooms that make the toxicity tangible. In a world that is all about self-professed good manners and professionalism, theatrics and appearances, you can see a lot of normality and then the needle of the Geiger counter goes close to or wildly beyond the « danger/ price tag you have to pay for success » limit, in an unsustainable, piling-up way.

The toxic obsession for control of women in their every step, at every stage of their career, in their body, in their mind, in their choices, by every layer of their professional environment is sick. And it creates an unsafe environment that poisons everything. And there is no one at any level of the professional scale that feel it’s their job and responsability to say « stop ».

As a spectator, I remember being worried twice about what was happening on the ice : with Oleg Schliakov in general (Berezhnaya could have died) and with Nikita Katsalapov when he dropped Sinitsina for everyone to see. But how many girls are at best « unsure » of whether their partner will actually do their job and catch them up when they are up in the air or in an imbalanced position, in training, in competition or in gala ? That you do not cross your male partner, that he has all the powers, that you shut up or else ? And how many coaches have turned a blind eye to such doubts, or nurtured them ? And what is the general culture in figure skating that enables this situation that even hits an olympic female champion in a self-proclaim « safe and aware » professional training center ? And how many people refuse to pay second thoughts because that’s how the system works ?

Those are undoubtly very incomfortable questions to ask a few weeks prior to the Games but Gabriella has every right to lay them on the table, especially as her coaches, partner, and skating environment were creating a narrative where she had disappeared into the night…

Those are also important for the current female skaters and for the next generations.

As a longtime observator, I will say something else. French ice dance and Lyon in particular have been known for the quality of its boys. Post Delobel-Schoenfelder, there was a junior girl I deemed exceptional (that would be Elodie Brouiller, Tiffany would be another but she was not a fruit of french ice dance) but she was dumped by her partner like a dirty sock (that would be B E N O I T). But the next generation, the one that comes after Théo Bigot, it will be about girls. There is a golden generation that ages between 8 an 15 yo that could IMO could make France contend for olympic gold for the next 25 years, something we have never had before and all internally developped. I think french ice dance owes them to study Gabriella’s book thoroughly to analyse everything that went wrong in Gabriella and Guillaume’s partnership to adapt and offer them a safer environment. I’m pretty sure that Arribert (in a « what are the holes I may have left » way) and Piton (in a « how to engineer olympic champions » ’ way ; Piton is the one I’ve seen switching from focusing on engineering THE boy from scratch – done - to engineering THE girl from scratch, her work with Dania being different, as an « import » from Belfort 5 years ago) will. I hope many other coaches too.

I don’t doubt for one second that this book will have long term consequences, even if right now, everyone « is hiding behind their little finger » as a french expression says, putting their head into the sand.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information