antmanb
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 12,639
I love Stuart Price's music editing and mixing for Madonna on her concert tours. I don't think it has been the same since he left. Confessions is my favorite Madonna tour by far and I love the way the music was mixed throughout. I just don't find the music on the album makes me want to dance whereas Hard Candy did. I also thought Pharrell got the dirty disco for some of the tracks (like the "Get stupid" part in "Give it 2 Me") whereas Price had a much more mechanical clean sound to it.
I think you've put that really well and I totally agree Price does have a much more mechanical and clean sound and Pharrell sounds a lot dirtier and free-er, both sounds make me want to dance but I agree Confessions is more...I don't know, controlled maybe?
Ray of Light is my favorite Madonna album. My favorite tracks are actually the non-singles except for the title track which is just perfection production wise. "Sky Fits Heaven" is such a monumental song and both "Drowned World (Substitute for Love)" and "Mer Girl" are shockingly poignant and well-written songs for her. That's when I thought she could be a great songwriter. With that album, she seemed insightful and self-critical without being self-pitying or sounding too self-centered.
Yes I love Sky Fits Heaven. I probably need to listen to Ray of light again because at the time I found a lot of the slower songs too boring in contrast with the upbeat songs that were really upbeat. Plus I really loved the different looks/videos and interviews from that era, together with probably one of her best vocal performances ever when she sang Ray of light on the Oprah show.
Some of her later albums had some personal tracks where she goes on about her life but it becomes a bit meh at times. I think her changed lifestyle and privilege made her experiences less interesting to hear about and I don't think she has the self-awareness or self-hatred to make talking about how lifestyle of the richest and most famous person is a golden cage or how it's all a sham, or anything to make it interesting. Instead, when she talks about it, it's a bit eye-rolling. That's why I loved the angry tracks that were inspired by her divorce from Guy Ritchie from MDNA as at least it was something raw and real to latch on to (like the song "Gang Bang").
Yes totally agree with this - it's a bit like when Eminem made it big and was rich and famous and couldn't really carry on complaining about being white trash and living in a trailer park any more because he wasn't and he really struggled to find anything of any substance to rap about. But back to Madonna I thought the ballad version of Joan of Arc from Rebel Heart hit the right note of being personal without being eye roll worthy (for me at least).
Speaking about that, that's probably why her Hard Candy track, "She's Not Me", is probably my favorite Madonna track from 2008 on. It's just 6 minutes of Madonna going from fun dance song and bragging about her name against her husband's mistress and how "she's not me" to something sadder and more desperate as it starts to sound like she's pleading "she's not me" leaving us wondering who is she trying to convince? It's pretty epic, with Pharrel's great beats and Prince's guitarist Wendy Melvoin providing some great riffs.
I LOVE She's Not Me - it's one of my favourite songs from that album, to me it's an updated version of Thief of Hearts from Erotica (which I also loved) that is done so well. I played that song with a friend after he'd been through a break up caused by cheating and we became obsessed with a double whistle in that song that in the end became a sort of pick me up for him when he was feeling sad. Terrific song.