2026 Olys Womens SP PBP - Cheated Rivalry

Where would you have Petros-IAN?
I can't stand the paint by number choreography nor the jerkiness that is built into every single Tutberidze skater aside from maybe Kostornaia. But I do think she is gives a little bit of her own flair and the elements are quite strong. I can't really fault her skating skills seeing what some of the women in the final 2 groups pull off on wobbly edges, bad posture, and little to no speed.

I think the 3Lz had a little hitch coming out, so below +2 is actually fine.

Gubanova's jump technique is hideous, Hendrickx got away with jump rotations and an empty program. I'd actually say maybe put this ahead of Chiba and put Levito in the final group ahead of both of them based on PCS that is just so much better all-around.

Flame away!
 
I have a bad feeling that we're going to wind up with a podium of Kaori, Alysa & Adeliia in some order. Two of whom I'd be fine with.

Nakai's 3A is wildly inconsistent. Chiba has fallen apart in her last 3 free skates. Neither of them are going to be on the podium, so this talk of a Japanese sweep is ridiculous. None of the rest of the women behind Petrosian have the tech base value to catch up with her even if she falls on both of her under-rotated 4Ts.
 
I think I'd have Isabeau 4th place

Me too. The q call on her loop was very harsh. That jump normally gets high GOE because of the spiral, steps, and spread eagle into it. Without that call and with normal GOE, Isabeau probably would've been fifth.

She was lucky to escape without a call on the combo, though... even though it was one of her better ones and fooled me in real time.

Speaking of fooling people, Glenn's footwork had -3 to +3 GOE. Some judges saw it; some didn't. I was exasperated after the 3Lo and stopped paying attention.
 
When folks kept saying Amber should skate the SP in the team event I kept thinking "are you crazy? " This is why the only choice was to let her do the Free (and even then I would have gone with Alysa). So sad for her but not shocked. I'll be glad when she retires and skates for fun.

Congratulations to Alysa who always keeps her head, to Ami for doing what she does, Kaori is the same as ever was. Mone seems overmarked to me. We'll see what our AIN athlete can do under pressure, I'm not impressed so far.
 
I wonder what will happen on PCS if Ami skates a good free. Her PCS were more than 1.5 below Mone and about 1 point ahead of Petrosian.

I am concerned that being 1st in the SP at the Olympics will be too much for her, but if she did skate a clean free, I have to imagine those PCS would go up. I don't think she should be 1.5 behind Mone.

Of course, if Petrosian skates a good free, hers might also go up.
 
Sh!t. Pedrosian will be in 5th. I hope this isn’t a bad omen.
Eh. I think Ami, Kaori, Mone, and Alysa are more likely to have Solid Skates than either the skate of a lifetime than a complete meltdown. I honestly think Petrosian is more likely to move down rather than up. But we'll see 🤷‍♀️

I do wonder if anyone at the ISU has ever thought to do a study to see how many skating fans they lose versus how many they keep with their inconsistencies in judging. I'm sure there are FSUers--probably the ones who lurk rather than the ones typing I'M DONE but still--who will genuinely not watch skating again if Petrosian wins. I'd like to know: 1. how much of a bounce skating gets after the Olympics 2. how many of those Oly fans turn into actual skating fans. which to me would be watching Nationals, Worlds, and at least one other competition so a low baseline here, versus 3. how many long term fans are lost after each cycle.

While some of y'all bringing up the numbers and judging and blah-blah are f-ing annoying, y'all are also the absolute backbone of the sport--those who pay $$$ to go to multiple events, hype up events, talk about it beyond FSU. My perception is that viewership has gone down and it is inexplicable to me why Eteri skaters are so valued as it's bad for the long-term growth of the sport, it's just not good skating, and it's not good judging.

There's no upside to the promotion of skaters like Petrosian and Gumennik. Especially as most of the "outrage" over his scoring is Russian bots botting. I checked out a lot of the profiles of those saying he wuz-robbed on ISU, The Skating Lesson, etc and the vast majority were obviously not real profiles. This is manufactured rage and those who were real people CLEARLY understood less about COP than I do and did not regularly follow skating. They couldn't even spell SATO. Even I can manage Sato.

I'll still watch skating BUT, and this is a big BUT, I stopped fitting my life around skating along time ago. If I miss a Grand Prix, oh well. If I only see one event at Euros, that's how it goes. If I totally miss 4CC, well, I needed the sleep. Hell, I didn't even know who the Canadian entry for men was until the Team Event. Eight years ago, I'd have been snarling and complaining and angry and overjoyed and ecstatic about...something. Now, it's just a fun thing I watch. Like, once upon a time, I'd have lost sleep over Ilia's skate in sympathy AND M/K's in excitement, replaying both in my head for different reasons. Now, I just close the computer and honestly, I'm done. I guess it's more healthy but it's also sad that something that used to bring me a lot of joy and was an emotional outlet is now...not.
 
Amber got GOE ranging from -3 to +3 for the steps. She was absolutely stumbling all over the place, so I have no idea how some judges didn't see it.

I also thought Isabeau had a few little bobbles and seemed less smooth and in control than usual.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information