Another movie I thought I MUST have seen (but couldn’t remember ever seeing) was A Streetcar Named Desire. Maybe I’ve heard so much about it and seen various scenes from the movie it felt like I had seen it. And after watching it? I didn’t have a lot of thoughts about it. Good movie. Downer. Okay then.
But then I read over the plot summary at Wikipedia and thought a couple of times, “Oh…THAT happened during that part of the movie?” Then I read a few other articles and watched the DVD extras. Suddenly I had a lot more thoughts about the movie.
One of those is probably why I didn’t have much to say at first: the censorship. One thing I read was that Brando’s character was supposed to be gay. Then later on, I read that the four lead characters were all supposed to be gay. Four gay men that had to be presented as two heterosexual couples for the play (and then the movie) to even exist.
So as for the censorship:
- Playwright Tennessee Williams self-censors his story to get his work accepted
- The re-writing of the movie for the screen had producers asking for changes
- Filmed scenes were cut to conform to the Production Code
- Cuts were made so as to not offend National Legion of Decency (these might be the same cuts as in point three)
- After test screenings were done, music had to be re-scored as the music in at least one scene was so "provocative" (as music so often is) audiences reacted negatively
In one of the DVD extras, a film historian says, “scenes were all cut up (edited highly), but we know what happened”. Such as Brando’s character raping Leigh’s character. Sorry, but that went right over my head. The two are having a very heated argument, Blanches tries to leave and Stanley moves in her way. Then we see the two of them in a mirror and the glass breaks. Scene fades. Stanley was always threatening to Blanche and now that I’ve been told what happened, I think, “oh…okay…” But if the censors weren’t so hysterical, there could have been more shown such as Blanche being pulled into a bedroom, the door being slammed shut and then hearing Blanche scream. The way the movie runs, it’s like Stanley is getting a free pass for the violent act he commits. Typing this, I’m still not 100% sure a rape happened. If it did, the audience should be more clearly shown what an even bigger f***-up Stanley is compared to what we already think of him.
A Streetcar Named Desire was nominated for twelve Oscars, all seven major categories and in five technical categories as well. In the seven major categories, the movie won three. Actress for Vivien Leigh, Supporting Actor for Karl Malden and Supporting Actress for Kim Hunter. In the technical categories, it won only one: Best Art Direction – Black-and-White. As for the wins, my biggest thought is with Leigh. The DVD extras for this movie have about seventeen minutes of deleted scenes and it’s pretty much all Leigh. Notable not because so much of it was Leigh on the cutting room floor, but how amazing she is. Even with deleted scenes, Leigh can do no wrong. The scenes must have been cut for running time, certainly not because Leigh ever set a foot wrong.
Trailer for A Streetcar Named Desire:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u9YgJjSCT08