I took a lot at the summer results from all the JGP girls + subs (except Kaiya given her injury situation).
Lia Pereira
Sara-Maude Dupuis
Justin Miclette
Kara Yun
Hetty Shi
Rose Theroux
Fiona Bombardier (sub)
Audréanne Foster (sub)
I believe these are all their results from this summer:
NextGen Competition (July 22-25)
- Sara-Maude Dupuis — 161.23
- Hetty Shi — 155.10
- Justine Miclette — 150.58
- Fiona Bombardier — 139.48
- Kara Yun — 137.66
- Lulu Lin — 136.66 **not age eligible for the JGP I believe
- Lia Pereira — 134.69
- Rose Théroux — 130.49
13. Audréanne Foster — 116.78
Championnats Québécois D'été (Aug 4-7)
Group 1
- Rose Théroux — 153.34
- Audréanne Foster — 151.15
- Hetty Shi — 137.21
- another skater
- Sara-Maude Dupuis — 133.51
Group 2
- Justine Miclette — 169.74
- Kara Yun — 156.31
6. Fiona Bombardier — 130.75
Cranberry Cup International
- Lia Pereira — 169.05
BC/YK Section Summer Skate (Aug 18-21)
- Kara Yun — 162.83
Skate Ontario August Event (Aug 18-21)
- Hetty Shi — 151.43
Lia got an early assignment after a not great showing at the NextGen event, but she was still top 6 among age eligible skaters there (and we had 6 spots). Then she had that strong result from Cranberry, which was an international event. So she deserved a JGP spot imo. Sara-Maude won the NextGen event, so it makes sense that she got a spot, even though her result at the Quebec event wasn't as strong. Justine Miclette was 3rd at the NextGen event (with a big gap on 4th), and then had that really good result in Quebec, so her getting a spot also makes sense. Hetty Shi was 2nd at the NextGen event, and then had another 150+ score at the Skate Ontario August event (after her Quebec skate wasn't as strong). So again, makes sense. Overall, all four of them getting a spot before Fiona does make sense to me.
Then there are Kara Yun and Rose Théroux. Fiona beat both of them at the NextGen event, although the margin over Kara was less than 2 points. Then at the Quebec event, Kara beat Fiona and outscored her by 25+ points. Then Kara had a strong result at the BC event. So I can see why they picked Kara over Fiona. That leaves Rose. She got 130.49 at NextGen and 153.34 in Quebec. Fiona got 139.48 at NextGen and 130.75 in Quebec. So Fiona beat Rose in the head to head, but Rose's stronger event was better than Fiona's, and their weak events were pretty much the same score. The other argument for Fiona is that she placed much higher at Nationals. I feel like that puts the two of them pretty close, and either could have been picked.
I definitely expected Fiona to get a JGP spot, and I wish she had, but I don't think the decisions made were egregious or unjustified, looking at the summer results. I'm not sure I would call it "doing her dirty". Skate Canada often sends at least a couple girls (usually who didn't get a JGP) out to a junior B in the fall, so we may see Fiona get something like that.