I give this film an 8.7/10. I thought that the cinematography, visual effects, sound, and editing were superb. And few can perform comedy in serious situations like Ryan Gosling can.
One nickpick - and it’s a big deal enough for me that I can’t rate this film 9.0+ like what’s in Rotten Tomatoes right now - is while the friendship between Dr. Grace and Rocky is superbly done

, the film could have done a much better job of explaining how Dr. Grace didn’t have any friends on Earth. And he’s chosen to stay with Rocky on his new planet because he has friends there. The novel does a much better job of explaining this. The film just shows Dr. Grace……just staying where he is for now.