Sums up most of my feelings too, but I rated it higher once I learned more about the messages the movie was conveying about Spanish history, Franco, the civil war, and the way it haunted that whole generation and how Janis, Ana, and Ana's mother were all showcases of different products of that history. Not Almodovar or even Cruz's best, but I really held it in high esteem. My fave Cruz/Almodovar is still Volver by far. I'm sure you've seen that one already, so if you're up for another Almodovar, I would suggest Broken Embraces just for Lluis Homar, Penelope Cruz, and Blanca Portillo's performances, if you haven't seen that one. I would say more, but I don't want to influence your impression.