I want to continue my campaign/idea that it makes more sense for the top JGP spots to be decided in priority of the countries that have at least two skaters/teams that have made it into the FS. You wouldn't need to have so much of this complicated replacement procedure...
Ehhhhh... I'd actually make it more complicated, because I don't think it's necessarily fair to punish countries that harshly at the JGP level - it IS a developmental series after all, and there are often skaters coming up through the pipeline from Advanced Novice who deserve a shot if someone from their country does exceptionally well at Jr Worlds, and find a way to reward countries for utilizing the JGP spots they earn.
I think maybe the better way to do it would be to allocate the spots the first season a country earns them but if they don't use at least as many spots as the next highest tier in the next JGP season & they earn additional spots again at the next Jr Worlds then they are dropped down to the next tier the following season & the next highest placing country gets moved up a tier, though still allow all countries who have at least 1 entry at JWC to earn at least 3 JGP spots for the next season regardless of whether they used 3 spots that JGP season.
So, in this scenario - 2024 Jr Worlds results
Men -
Tier A - 14 spots
JPN - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 10; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 14 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
KOR - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 10; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 14 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
USA - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 6; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B, moved up to Tier A as the next highest finishing country due to SVK only earning Tier B based on JGP24-25 spots used
Tier B - 7 spots + any relinquished spots from Tier A, B & C that are reallocated
SVK - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 6; they can only achieve Tier B, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier A, but only earned Tier B based on JGP24-25 spots used
GER - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4; they can remain at Tier E or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B
ISR - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C, moved up to Tier B as the next highest finishing country due to EST only earning Tier C & NZL only earning Tier D based on JGP24-25 spots used
Tier C - 6 spots
EST - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, used 4; they can only achieve Tier C, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier B, but only earned Tier C based on JGP24-25 spots used
SWE - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
CHN - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
CAN - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, received 2 add'l spots, used 9; they can remain at Tier B or move up to Tier A at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D, moved up to Tier C as the next highest finishing country due to NZL only earning Tier D based on JGP24-25 spots used
Tier D - 5 spots
NZL - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier D, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier C, but only earned Tier D based on JGP24-25 spots used
HKG - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
FRA - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, used 5; they can only achieve Tier C, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
SUI - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4; they can remain at Tier E or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
FIN - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E, moved up to Tier D as the next highest finishing country due to ITA & BEL only earning Tier E based on JGP24-25 spots used
KAZ - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E, moved up to Tier D as the next highest finishing country due to ITA & BEL only earning Tier E based on JGP24-25 spots used
Tier E - 4 spots
ITA - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 3; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, but only earned Tier E based on JGP24-25 spots used
BEL - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, but only earned Tier E based on JGP24-25 spots used
UKR - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E
CZE - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 (+2 host spots); they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E
GEO - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 1; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier F, moved up to Tier E as the next highest country due to ESP only earning Tier F based on their JGP24-25 spots used
BUL - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 2, they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier F, moved up to Tier E as the next highest country due to ESP & SLO only earning Tier F based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier F - 3 spots
ESP - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier F, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E, but only earned Tier F based on JGP24-25 spots used
SLO - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 2, they can only achieve Tier F, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
GBR - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 6; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
TUR - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 3 (+2 host spots); they can remain at Tier E or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
LAT - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4 (+ 2 host spots); they can remain at Tier E or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
ARM - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier F, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
HUN - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
POL - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 6; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
Women -
Tier A - 14 spots
JPN - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 14; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 14 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
KOR - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 14; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 14 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
USA - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, used 7; they can remain at Tier B or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
Tier B - 7 spots + any relinquished spots from Tier A, B & C that are reallocated
FRA - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 6; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B
EST - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 6; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B
SUI - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, used 7; they can remain at Tier B or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier C, moved up to Tier B as the next highest country due to GEO only earning Tier D based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier C - 6 spots
AUS - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4; they can remain at Tier E or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
FIN - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 14; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 14 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
CHN - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2; they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
ITA - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, received 1 add'l spot, used 8; they can remain at Tier B or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, moved up to Tier C as the next highest country due to GEO only earning Tier D based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier D - 5 spots
GEO - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 3; they can only achieve Tier D, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier B, but only earned Tier D based on their JGP24-25 spots used
AZE - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
ISR - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
NED - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
HUN - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
CYP - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2; they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
LAT - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 (+3 host spots); they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
CAN - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 6; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
CZE - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5 (+2 host spots); they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier E, moved up to Tier D as the next highest country due to ARM only earning Tier F based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier E - 4 spots
KAZ - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E
HKG - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 spots; they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E
LTU - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 spots; they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E
GER - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4 spots; they can remain at Tier E or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier F, moved up to Tier E as the next highest country due to ARM only earning Tier F based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier F - 3 spots
ARM - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 1; they can only achieve Tier F, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, but only earned Tier F based on their JGP24-25 spots used
AUT - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
TPE - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
SLO - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
SWE - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
BUL - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
GBR - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
SVK - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
NZL - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 spots; they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
CRO - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
UKR - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
ESP - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 spots; they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
POL - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5 spots (+2 host); they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
THA - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5 spots (+2 host); they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
KGZ - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3 spots; they can remain at Tier F or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier F
Pairs - (only 25 teams entered at JWC2025, so every team entered guaranteed Tier C at the lowest)
Tier A - 12 spots
CHN - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, moved up to Tier A as the next highest country due to GEO, UKR & CAN only earning Tier B based on their JGP24-25 spots used
USA - JGP24-25 earned 12 spots, used 9; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 12 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier B, moved up to Tier A as the next highest country due to GEO, UKR & CAN only earning Tier B based on their JGP24-25 spots used
FRA - JGP24-25 earned 8 spots, used 6; they can remain at Tier B or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier B, moved up to Tier A as the next highest country due to GEO, UKR, CAN only earning Tier B & SUI only earning Tier C based on their JGP24-25 spots used
ESP - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier B, moved up to Tier A as the next highest country due to GEO, UKR, CAN, ITA & SVK only earning Tier B & SUI & JPN only earning Tier C based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier B - 8 spots
GEO - JGP24-25 earned 12 spots, used 0; they can only achieve Tier B, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier A, but only earned Tier B based on JGP24-25 spots used
UKR - JGP24-25 earned 8 spots, used 1; they can only achieve Tier B, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier A, but only earned Tier B based on JGP24-25 spots used
CAN - JGP24-25 earned 12 spots, used 5; they can only achieve Tier B, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier A, but only earned Tier B based on JGP24-25 spots used
ITA - JGP24-25 earned 12 spots, used 6; they can only achieve Tier B, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B
SVK - JGP24-25 earned 8 spots, used 4; they can remain at Tier B if they earn 8 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B
Tier C - 4 spots
SUI - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 1; they can only achieve Tier C, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier A, but only earned Tier C based on JGP24-25 spots used
JPN - JGP24-25 earned 8 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier C, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier B, but only earned Tier C based on JGP24-25 spots used
CZE - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier C, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
GBR - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 4; they can remain at Tier C or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
HUN - JGP24-25 earned 8 spots, used 1; they can only achieve Tier C, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
Ice Dance - (only 25 teams entered at JWC2025, so every team entered guaranteed Tier E at the lowest)
Tier A - 14 spots
ITA - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, used 7; they can remain at Tier B or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
USA - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 14; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 14 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
GER - JGP24-25 earned 14 spots, used 9; they can remain at Tier A if they earn 14 spots at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier A
Tier B - 7 spots + any relinquished spots from Tier A, B & C that are reallocated
FRA - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, received 7 add'l spots, used 14; they can remain at Tier B or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B
CAN - JGP24-25 earned 7 spots, received 7 add'l spots, used 14; they can remain at Tier B or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier B
SUI - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5 spots; they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier C, moved up to Tier B as the next highest country due to UKR & BEL only earning Tier E based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier C - 6 spots
SVK - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 spots; they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier C
CZE - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 5 spots (+2 host); they can remain at Tier D or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, moved up to Tier C as the next highest country due to UKR, BEL, JPN, AUT & TUR only earning Tiers D & E based on their JGP24-25 spots used
EST - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 3; they can remain at Tier E or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier E, moved up to Tier C as the next highest country due to UKR, BEL, JPN, GBR, AUT, TUR, ESP & POL only earning Tiers D & E based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier D - 5 spots
JPN - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 5; they can only achieve Tier D, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier C, but only Tier E based on their JGP24-25 spots used
GBR - JGP24-25 earned 6 spots, used 5; they can only achieve Tier D, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier D
CHN - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 2 spots (+2 host); they can remain at Tier G or move up to a higher Tier at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier E, moved up to Tier D as the next highest country due to UKR, BEL, AUT, TUR, ESP & POL only earning Tier E based on their JGP24-25 spots used
Tier E - 4 spots
UKR - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 4; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier B; but only Tier E based on their JGP24-25 spots used
BEL - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier C, but only Tier E based on their JGP24-25 spots used
AUT - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 2 spots, they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, but only Tier F based upon their JGP24-25 spots used
TUR - JGP24-25 earned 4 spots, used 2 spots, they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - placed Tier D, but only Tier F based upon their JGP24-25 spots used
ESP - JGP24-25 earned 3 spots, used 2; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E
POL - JGP24-25 earned 5 spots, used 4 spots; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E
SWE - JGP24-25 earned 2 spots, used 1 spot; they can only achieve Tier E, regardless of their highest finish at JWC2025; JWC2025 - Tier E