Judges Draw by number/country for ISU Figure Skating & Synchro Championships 2019

Sylvia

Not yet ready for club comp. season to be underway
Messages
56,191
Ratings
56,377
ISU Communication No. 2204 (published today, Oct. 15): https://www.isu.org/communications/18289-isu-communication-2204/file
The draw was held in Geneva, Switzerland on October 11, 2018.

ETA:

Worlds 2019 drawn judges by country:

Men: CAN CHN TPE CRO CZE FRA GEO ISR MEX POL ESP SUI TUR

Ladies: AUT CHN TPE CZE EST GER GBR KAZ LAT NOR KOR SLO USA

Pairs: AUS AUT CAN CHN GER GBR HUN ISR ITA JPN KOR RUS SUI

Ice Dance: AUS BUL CHN FRA GER HUN ISR JPN POL KOR RUS TUR UKR

:watch:
 
Last edited:
Messages
139
Ratings
156
ISU Communication No. 2204 (published today, Oct. 15): https://www.isu.org/communications/18289-isu-communication-2204/file
The draw was held in Geneva, Switzerland on October 11, 2018.

4.Judges drawn for the ISU World Figure Skating Championships
2019, Saitama / JPN(Rule 521, paragraph 6)

CHN
MEN 1
LADIES 1
PAIR SKATING 1
ICE DANCE 1

Why does China cover all events? Chinese judges continue their national bias this season.
Considering the disposition for the Chinese judge last season, I think that the Chinese judge should be excluded from all events this season.
 
Last edited:

peibeck

Simply looking
Messages
24,944
Ratings
23,239
Just because 4 Chinese judges are drawn it doesn't mean they are seated for both portions on the competition.

Let's let the events happen before we start criticizing the marks. :lol:
 
Messages
139
Ratings
156

Sylvia

Not yet ready for club comp. season to be underway
Messages
56,191
Ratings
56,377
Why are the Chinese judges not excluded? They repeated unfair actions.
Because their 2 judges were punished by the ISU for their actions and the punishment didn't extend to China being excluded from the draws for the 2019 ISU Championships?
 
Messages
139
Ratings
156
The problem of national bias has a great relationship with the federation of each country.
Because the federations of each country chose judge.

Chinese judge is also doing national bias this season.

17.41 Ms. Hui LIU CHN ISU JGP Canada 2018 Junior Ladies Siyang ZHANG
12.20 Ms. Hui LIU CHN ISU JGP Canada 2018 Junior Pairs Yuchen WANG / Yihang HUANG
6.50 Ms. Hui LIU CHN ISU JGP Canada 2018 Junior Pairs Feiyao TANG / Yongchao YANG

ISU warning does not work against them. Despite repeated warnings last season they did such a judge at the Olympic Games.
 
Messages
139
Ratings
156
https://www.isu.org/communications/18289-isu-communication-2204/file

ISU Four Continents Figure Skating Championships 2019

4  CHN,JPN,USA

ISU World Junior Figure Skating Championships 2019

3  CHN,BUL,JPN,ISR,ITA,UKR
2  USA,RUS,CAN,BLR,CZE,FRA,GBR,ESP,SWE,TUR

ISU World Figure Skating Championships 2019, Saitama / JPN

4  CHN
3  GER,ISR,KOR
2  JPN,RUS,CAN,FRA,GBR,HUN,AUS,TPE,CZE,POL,SUI,TUR
 

Tony Wheeler

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,817
Ratings
10,217
The ladies' Worlds draw is fascinating. The USA is the only country that had a skater in the top 10 in the event last year, and it's the only event USA got drawn for. CAN, JPN, ITA, RUS, BEL all without.

There's even a very, very slight chance that the nine judges drawn for either the SP or when rotated out for the LP are nine whose country failed to make the LP!
 
Messages
31,232
Ratings
22,777
There's even a very, very slight chance that the nine judges drawn for either the SP or when rotated out for the LP are nine whose country failed to make the LP!
There have been suggestions here that a good panel is one without skin in the game.

Of course, that doesn't mean that they don't have their alliances.
 

zebobes

Active Member
Messages
559
Ratings
72
There have been suggestions here that a good panel is one without skin in the game.

Of course, that doesn't mean that they don't have their alliances.
Well, this is a great opportunity to see if that is REALLY the case or not. Like Tony said, fascinating.

Of course, we could end up with really questionable choices amongst the lower ranked skaters, with judges trying to get their skaters into the FS, but with lower ranked skaters, people tend to not care as much about scoring injustices.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top