ISU Statement on Russia's war against Ukraine - Participation in international competitions of Skaters and Officials from Russia and Belarus

Status
Not open for further replies.
Let's get real here, I cannot imagine the ISU punishing athletes for celebrating Victory Day on the ninth of May, commemorating the FSU's/Russia's victory in Europe in the Great War (WW II for most nations) where they lost roughly 27 million soldiers and citizens. Completely unimaginable casualties. The great alliance among Great Britain, Russia, and the United States was essential to defeat Hitler's Nazi Germany, and the US and Britain celebrate Victory-Europe day on May 8th (and the US also celebrates Victory-Japan day on September 2nd). Heck, even Ukraine normally celebrates Victory Day since they were part of the Soviet Union back then.
We do? I've never seen May 8th or Sept 2nd commemorated in the US in the 50 years I've been alive.
Russian athletes have been competing all along in ice hockey in the NHL and (Wimbledon-excepted) mostly on the pro tennis tours, albeit those athletes generally don't live and train in Russia like most of the figure skaters. I expect most Russian figure skaters to be back participating in ISU events for the 2023-24 season (to begin earning full slots internationally for 2024-25), but I don't see the ISU awarding any Grand Prix or other skating events to Russia -- or allowing skaters to participate under the flag -- until some time after the hostilities cease.
I don't think Russian skaters will be back next season - or, at least not next fall. Maybe by Euros next winter, they'll be allowed back in, but they'll be lucky if any of their skaters are assigned to the GP if Russia's still warring in July.
 
You do know that the Leningrad siege went on for YEARS and that more than a million people died because of it?
The show was meant as a celebration of a historic event and I bet had the war not started and had Averbukh done the show anyway, everyone would've liked it and celebrated this date.

No, I am not for Russia in the war that is going on right now, I condemn it and I, in no way, want to play down the atrocities that are being committed in Ukraine right now, but facts have to be gotten straight.
Do you know that the Ukrainians fought alongside the Russians? Ukraine suffered more in World War II. But Russia behaves as if the victory belongs to Russia and no one else. RUSSIA DOES NOT OWN THE VICTORY!!! And these shows are disgusting.
 
Again: This picture is from an Averbukh show that commemorated the 80th anniversary of the ending of the siege of Leningrad.
And timing, "entourage" etc of this show - just like the number Averbukh had in his TV show - have absolutely no connection to what is happening right now (because I don't remember something like this happening 10 years ago, no any ice show, not any anniversary commemorated, you see).

russia's truly unhealthy relationship with WWII history, their victory in it (and their definition of who actually won) is the whole other topic. Probably not very related, but still related, as this - and their nauseating slogans "we can repeat"- was one of the heaviest tools of propaganda leading to this war.
 
Short answer would be no, they are not. They’ve given up that right when they started a brutal war against their neighbor, and topped it off with propaganda that rivals Nazi Germany. And threatened to use nuclear weapons.
They have done this many times in recent years why is Ukraine so special?
Chechnya - internal but with republic status within Russia
Georgia
Syria

People have decided to make Ukraine special for some reason!
 
We do? I've never seen May 8th or Sept 2nd commemorated in the US in the 50 years I've been alive.

I don't think Russian skaters will be back next season - or, at least not next fall. Maybe by Euros next winter, they'll be allowed back in, but they'll be lucky if any of their skaters are assigned to the GP if Russia's still warring in July.
To tell the truth it makes me really uncomfortable when there is this assumption of "if the war is still ongoing they will be banned". Even if there is no war in July (and we all hope and pray for that, of course), the damage russia caused can't be "undone" the day after any peace agreement is signed. I mean, Japan and Germany were banned from the 1948 Olympics, I don't see why for russia it should be earlier than that.
 
Russian athletes have been competing all along in ice hockey in the NHL and (Wimbledon-excepted) mostly on the pro tennis tours, albeit those athletes generally don't live and train in Russia like most of the figure skaters.
A tennis player at the Australian Open is competing for himself. When that same tennis player competes at the Olympics, he is competing as representative of his National Olympic Committee based on the nomination of his national tennis federation.

Those Russian professional tennis and ice hockey players are going to have just as much difficulty being allowed to compete in Paris in 2024 as Russian figure skaters are going to have for Milan in 2026.
 
A tennis player at the Australian Open is competing for himself. When that same tennis player competes at the Olympics, he is competing as representative of his National Olympic Committee based on the nomination of his national tennis federation.
Exactly. The issue isn't whether athletes live and train in Russia or even whether they support the war. It's whether they represent Russia, raise the Russian flag and get the Russian anthem played. Personally, I hope many years pass before this happens again.

BTW, Russian athletes competing under the flag of their olympic committee shouldn't cut it either. They've already been shown enormous tolerance after the endless systemic doping scandals.
 
Talking about siege of Leningrad, by pure coincidence read just now some FB post about siege of Leningrad memoirs book.

Quote from that book (Google translated 'cause I'm too tired, sorry):
The captured Lovno Rudolf from the 9th battery of the 240th artillery regiment of the 170th infantry division later testified: “Artillery shelling on Leningrad was carried out in the morning from 8 to 9 hours, in the afternoon from 11 to 12 hours, in the evening from 17 to 18 hours, and then from 8 pm to 10 pm. The main task of the shelling was the destruction of the inhabitants of the city, the destruction of factory facilities and the most important buildings, as well as the moral suppression of Leningraders..."

Rings any bells? :rolleyes:
How can you with one hand sincerely mourn and "commemorate" and with the other hand do literally the same to multiple cities in the neighbouring country? Question is rhetorical, of course. russians are pros in doing just that.
 
To tell the truth it makes me really uncomfortable when there is this assumption of "if the war is still ongoing they will be banned". Even if there is no war in July (and we all hope and pray for that, of course), the damage russia caused can't be "undone" the day after any peace agreement is signed. I mean, Japan and Germany were banned from the 1948 Olympics, I don't see why for russia it should be earlier than that.
Not before Russia fully compensates Ukraine for the damage done, in any case!
 
To tell the truth it makes me really uncomfortable when there is this assumption of "if the war is still ongoing they will be banned". Even if there is no war in July (and we all hope and pray for that, of course), the damage russia caused can't be "undone" the day after any peace agreement is signed. I mean, Japan and Germany were banned from the 1948 Olympics, I don't see why for russia it should be earlier than that.
Oh, I agree, but this is the IOC under Thomas Bach. He's bending and twisting every which way he can to get Russian athletes back in international sports competitions sooner rather than later.
A tennis player at the Australian Open is competing for himself. When that same tennis player competes at the Olympics, he is competing as representative of his National Olympic Committee based on the nomination of his national tennis federation.

Those Russian professional tennis and ice hockey players are going to have just as much difficulty being allowed to compete in Paris in 2024 as Russian figure skaters are going to have for Milan in 2026.
It would be a mighty fine trick to see ice hockey players competing in Paris 2024, seeing as ice hockey is still a WOG sport...
 
I can't imagine any athlete except for Davis/Smolkin daring to participate anything even if allowed. The danger they would put themselves in when daring not to tear their shirt on their chest and shout `I shall not skate without the flag, the anthem and the whole world bowing and screaming Russia is the greatest' might not be worth the potential medal.
 
I can't imagine any athlete except for Davis/Smolkin daring to participate anything even if allowed. The danger they would put themselves in when daring not to tear their shirt on their chest and shout `I shall not skate without the flag, the anthem and the whole world bowing and screaming Russia is the greatest' might not be worth the potential medal.
They skated perfectly well without flag and anthem before. So if that would be the only requirement from them I don't see why not. But if they would be asked to publicly confirm that they are against the war, that would be a very different story. But will they be asked? Sounds like they won't.
 
They skated perfectly well without flag and anthem before. So if that would be the only requirement from them I don't see why not. But if they would be asked to publicly confirm that they are against the war, that would be a very different story. But will they be asked? Sounds like they won't.
Yes and no. I mean, they had Tchaikovsky played instead of their national anthem. But their team uniforms and jackets were emblazoned with the Russian tricolor. What if they were told they had to listen to the IOC or IF anthem instead of their precious Tchaikovsky? And that applied to all sporting events, not just the Olympics? What if they were told they could only wear black or grey jackets with absolutely NO Russian insignia or colors and no sponsors patches from sanctioned Russian companies?
 
I can't imagine any athlete except for Davis/Smolkin daring to participate anything even if allowed. The danger they would put themselves in when daring not to tear their shirt on their chest and shout `I shall not skate without the flag, the anthem and the whole world bowing and screaming Russia is the greatest' might not be worth the potential medal.
They will do whatever they want and the government will let them. As you can often read here: athletes are afraid, but they are against war. They are victims of a totalitarian regime. The russian government will say the same thing: athletes are afraid, but they are against Western aggression. They are victims of the West. We must allow them to compete, because we are not like the West. We all know perfectly well that our athletes are real patriots and they support the actions of our great president Putin
 
They skated perfectly well without flag and anthem before. So if that would be the only requirement from them I don't see why not. But if they would be asked to publicly confirm that they are against the war, that would be a very different story. But will they be asked? Sounds like they won't.
Dunno. If they will not be asked by Russia it will be up to the who? ISU? IOC? to.make sure Pluschenkos and Zhulins don't show up. It might be easier for the ISU/IOC if the Russians were asked by Russia, frankly
 
Dunno. If they will not be asked by Russia it will be up to the who? ISU? IOC? to.make sure Pluschenkos and Zhulins don't show up. It might be easier for the ISU/IOC if the Russians were asked by Russia, frankly
That's the point. I don't think they will be asked, based on very vague definition IOC uses. Also, I don't think anyone will make sure "Pluschenkos and Zhulins don't show up" (and I pretty much expect them to show up even)
 
Do you know that the Ukrainians fought alongside the Russians? Ukraine suffered more in World War II. But Russia behaves as if the victory belongs to Russia and no one else. RUSSIA DOES NOT OWN THE VICTORY!!! And these shows are disgusting.
Thank you for this additional history lesson since I, as a person with Soviet (not only Russian!) roots, have also lost a bunch of relatives during WWII and am alive now because my own father and his family barely survived the siege of Leningrad.

I think any show celebrating the win over Nazi Germany is perfectly alright. No matter where from.
And I am living in Germany.
 
The show was meant as a celebration of a historic event and I bet had the war not started and had Averbukh done the show anyway, everyone would've liked it and celebrated this date.
If the war had not started, Averbukh wouldn't have done that show. Get real. It's not like he doe a show like this every year. He did it to celebrate the war and for no other reason.

the US and Britain celebrate Victory-Europe day on May 8th (and the US also celebrates Victory-Japan day on September 2nd).
As @Karen-W said, no we don't. Where did you get such an idea? I can't find any holidays even remotely close to those dates having anything to do with any World War.

We celebrate Veterans Day on Nov 11th, the day of the Armistice of 11 November 1918, the formal agreement that marked the official end of World War I. And we celebrate Memorial Day to honor fallen soldiers on the last Monday in May but it has nothing to do with any specific war and the first celebrations started after the end of the Civil War (i.e., in the late 1800s) well before the first WW.

There are other days that people talk about but aren't official holidays anywhere and none of them happen on May 8th or Sept. 2nd. They also have nothing to do with either WWI or WWII. The only exception would be Pearl Harbor Day on Dec 7th which is the day the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor. It's not a holiday but sometimes there are specials on TV about it.

Honestly, I've never even heard of these days you claim that we celebrate.

Yes and no. I mean, they had Tchaikovsky played instead of their national anthem. But their team uniforms and jackets were emblazoned with the Russian tricolor. What if they were told they had to listen to the IOC or IF anthem instead of their precious Tchaikovsky? And that applied to all sporting events, not just the Olympics? What if they were told they could only wear black or grey jackets with absolutely NO Russian insignia or colors and no sponsors patches from sanctioned Russian companies?
Like any of that would happen under that weasel Bach.

I think any show celebrating the win over Nazi Germany is perfectly alright. No matter where from.
And I am living in Germany.
Subtext totally escapes you, doesn't it?
 
There have definitely been some claims on reddit from people who saw the show that while ostensibly it was about the anniversary of the Siege, all of the speeches made reference to the invasion and there were other distinct references throughout the show to the "special operation". So it does seem that the anniversary of the Siege was a convenient cover-story for a pro-invasion propaganda show.
 
We do? I've never seen May 8th or Sept 2nd commemorated in the US in the 50 years I've been alive.
I think the closest you could get would be commemorations on the big anniversaries of either VE Day or VJ Day. For example, for the 75th anniversary in 2020, which was rather toned down due to the pandemic.

 
Thank you for this additional history lesson since I, as a person with Soviet (not only Russian!) roots, have also lost a bunch of relatives during WWII and am alive now because my own father and his family barely survived the siege of Leningrad.

I think any show celebrating the win over Nazi Germany is perfectly alright. No matter where from.
And I am living in Germany.
I’d prefer a solemn commemoration of the war’s victims to a rah-rah military parade anywhere. The kind of pro-military celebration beloved in the Kremlin (and Trump, who wanted one for July 4) is actually reminiscent of the Nazis venerating the Wehrmacht.

I’m pretty harsh on Israel but at least Holocaust Remembrance Day doesn’t involve a parade of tanks and airplanes to show how tough we now are.
 
Thank you for this additional history lesson since I, as a person with Soviet (not only Russian!) roots, have also lost a bunch of relatives during WWII and am alive now because my own father and his family barely survived the siege of Leningrad.

I think any show celebrating the win over Nazi Germany is perfectly alright. No matter where from.
And I am living in Germany.
Nazi russian celerating their "victory" is not alright.
It's amazing that I need to explain why.
Russian support for the war is based on such shows. More shows, more support. Probably because the missiles are not flying in your direction, you don’t understand this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information