2019-2020 Programs and Choreographers

skategal

skategal

Bunny mama
Messages
11,988
believed said:
Piper Gilles/Paul Poirier (CAN):

FD: Both Sides Now by Joni Mitchell

twitter.com

Golden Skate on Twitter

“Fan favourites @PiperGilles and @PaulDPoirier say they are ready to be Canada’s top ice dance team and expect their Both Sides Now by Joni Mitchell FD will take them there @SkateCanada #HPC2018”
twitter.com twitter.com
Click to expand...

I literally can’t wait!

I didn’t think they could top the “Vincent” masterpiece but now I think they will. Wheee!
 
VGThuy

VGThuy

Well-Known Member
Messages
41,023
Wyliefan said:
For a musical that didn't do very well onstage, B&C is pretty popular with skaters!
Click to expand...

They want their own Mack & Mabel I guess. :lol: Or I guess the concept of Bonnie & Clyde simply lends itself to male-female ice dancing pairings.
 
Colonel Green

Colonel Green

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,941
Dobre said:
So that's three Bonnie & Clydes, though the others are in juniors. (And quite good, IMO, though I've never cared for the Bonnie & Clyde programs I've seen before)
Click to expand...
Galiyanova/Lochhead and Shanaeva/Naryzhnyy use the same two pieces of music (though the uses of "The World Will Remember Us" is so different between the two programs that it doesn't feel at all the same), so I'll be interested to see what Laurence and Nikolaj use, particularly since their pattern requirements are different. Fingers crossed that some of "Picture Show", my favourite song on that soundtrack, makes it in (though that one would probably make more sense for a junior program since it starts with Bonnie and Clyde when they're kids).

Wyliefan said:
For a musical that didn't do very well onstage, B&C is pretty popular with skaters!
Click to expand...
Doesn't surprise me, since it presents two very well-defined roles for the dancers to play.
 
love skating

love skating

Clueless American
Messages
2,997
Do I get a prize for correctly guessing Both Sides Now? :p:D Anyway, I love the song - one of my all time favorites. And I'm sure they will have a lovely FD, however I see it as being very similar to Vincent and thought that they would do something vastly different as Gilles and Poirier have tended in the past to reinvent themselves every year.
 
Colonel Green

Colonel Green

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,941
love skating said:
Anyway, I love the song - one of my all time favorites. And I'm sure they will have a lovely FD, however I see it as being very similar to Vincent and thought that they would do something vastly different as Gilles and Poirier have tended in the past to reinvent themselves every year.
Click to expand...
I agree that it seems like it's going for a very similar effect to "Vincent", though I suppose I can't begrudge them the desire to replicate their most well-received program to date.

Plus, it's CanCon for a home Worlds.
 
rfisher

rfisher

Let the skating begin
Messages
73,891
skatfan said:
Burning a bridge refers to damaging a particular relationship, in this case with SLB. I doubt that Shaw Lynn will work with her again.
Click to expand...
She's also a professional. The skater purchases her services as a choreographer. If the skater then decides not to use said services after they've paid for them, that's just business. It's also the skater's right to use the choreographic moves however they wish after they've paid for them. I suspect if Liza approached Bourne again with cash in hand, she'd say what can I do for you?
 
missing

missing

Well-Known To Whom She Wonders
Messages
4,882
rfisher said:
She's also a professional. The skater purchases her services as a choreographer. If the skater then decides not to use said services after they've paid for them, that's just business. It's also the skater's right to use the choreographic moves however they wish after they've paid for them. I suspect if Liza approached Bourne again with cash in hand, she'd say what can I do for you?
Click to expand...

We'll never know, because we're not going to be flies in that room, but my guess is Bourne would turn down the request. She's not exactly desperate for work these days and choreographers quite probably take pride in their creative endeavors and could also take offense at the implication that their work is so cookie cutter that it can be applied to any piece of music without significant changes.
 
rfisher

rfisher

Let the skating begin
Messages
73,891
missing said:
We'll never know, because we're not going to be flies in that room, but my guess is Bourne would turn down the request. She's not exactly desperate for work these days and choreographers quite probably take pride in their creative endeavors and could also take offense at the implication that their work is so cookie cutter that it can be applied to any piece of music without significant changes.
Click to expand...
Maybe it would depend on whether or not she needed to buy a new car or add to her IRA account. :)
 
T

Tavi

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,233
rfisher said:
She's also a professional. The skater purchases her services as a choreographer. If the skater then decides not to use said services after they've paid for them, that's just business. It's also the skater's right to use the choreographic moves however they wish after they've paid for them. I suspect if Liza approached Bourne again with cash in hand, she'd say what can I do for you?
Click to expand...

The skater has the right not to use the program, for sure. And since SLB likely created it as a work for hire, Liza probably does own the rights to the choreography. What she doesn’t have the right to do is make substantial changes to a program (such as completely changing the music) and continue to use SLB’s name unless SLB is okay with it. It’s SLB’s reputation as a choreographer at stake, after all. If she feels like the change of music reflects adversely on her, she would be well within her rights to tell Liza not to use her name. If I recall, Rohene Ward has done that at least once because the skater altered his original choreography.
 
Theatregirl1122

Theatregirl1122

Needs a nap
Messages
30,031
Colonel Green said:
Galiyanova/Lochhead and Shanaeva/Naryzhnyy use the same two pieces of music (though the uses of "The World Will Remember Us" is so different between the two programs that it doesn't feel at all the same), so I'll be interested to see what Laurence and Nikolaj use, particularly since their pattern requirements are different. Fingers crossed that some of "Picture Show", my favourite song on that soundtrack, makes it in (though that one would probably make more sense for a junior program since it starts with Bonnie and Clyde when they're kids).


Doesn't surprise me, since it presents two very well-defined roles for the dancers to play.
Click to expand...

I'd love to see someone reference the Broadway costumes (which were very appropriate to the original time period and some were modeled after photos of Bonnie and Clyde) rather than sort of random ice dance. This dress from the musical was a pretty literal take on one of Bonnie's actual dresses and this one would also be a great look to reference.

I assume that people doing this show want to play Bonnie and Clyde themselves, but Buck and Blanche's song You're Going Back to Jail would be kind of hilarious...
 
S

starrynight

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,234
Honestly, skaters change programs and drop choreography all the time, change music etc. I doubt Bourne is as fragile as you are all making out.

I’ve seen so many skaters change programs and re-use chunks of previous choreography in the new programs.

Given the way singles works the choreography is usually just movements set to the highlights of the music in between all the jumps. Just watch the way some skaters make up exhibition skates to pieces of various choreography from different programs.
 
Last edited:
mollymgr

mollymgr

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,052
I'm so excited about Laurence and Nikolaj's programs. I think they are getting better with each year and they have everything that makes ice dance exciting to watch. I hope they are able to break into the top 5 soon.
 
Colonel Green

Colonel Green

Well-Known Member
Messages
13,941
Theatregirl1122 said:
I'd love to see someone reference the Broadway costumes (which were very appropriate to the original time period and some were modeled after photos of Bonnie and Clyde) rather than sort of random ice dance. This dress from the musical was a pretty literal take on one of Bonnie's actual dresses and this one would also be a great look to reference.
Click to expand...
Irina's costume I believe is meant to reference Faye Dunaway in the movie.
 
T

Tavi

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,233
starrynight said:
Honestly, skaters change programs and drop choreography all the time, change music etc. I doubt Bourne is as fragile as you are all making out.

I’ve seen so many skaters change programs and re-use chunks of previous choreography in the new programs.

Given the way singles works the choreography is usually just movements set to the highlights of the music in between all the jumps. Just watch the way some skaters make up exhibition skates to pieces of various choreography from different programs.
Click to expand...

To the best of my knowledge, noone here said SLB is fragile, and anyway the issue isn’t fragility, it’s the choreographer’s reputation. If SLB doesn’t care, she won’t say anything to Liza, simple as that.
 
Tinami Amori

Tinami Amori

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,156
Theatregirl1122 said:
I think I need a visual.
Click to expand...
Irina's costume looks close enough to Faye Dunaway's in the old film...

however, Faye Dunaway when i first saw her in that film in those outfits, looked like Bridget Bardot... :D



:p
 
S

starrynight

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,234
At the end of the day, the choreography matters diddle all to Liza. For her, it’s an issue of landing the 3A that’s the most important and that’s what will give her a good placement. If the original music etc was negatively affecting the ability to jump it needs to go. End of story. The judges will place her depending on her technical content and won’t be giving her any boost elsewhere if those jumps aren’t landed.

Anyway, As far as I can recall, Nathan Chen won the world title with a free skate with about 15 seconds of choreography and the rest just jumps.
 
nuge

nuge

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,132
Colonel Green said:
I agree that it seems like it's going for a very similar effect to "Vincent", though I suppose I can't begrudge them the desire to replicate their most well-received program to date.

Yes if it was P/C it would be oh they're doing the same style yet again :shuffle:
Click to expand...
 
VGThuy

VGThuy

Well-Known Member
Messages
41,023
Maybe some think Gilles/Poirier have sort of earned the right to repeat considering their track record of having wildly different styled programs and pushing what choreography can be in ice dance. Of course, once the program comes out and it's "too similar" to "Vincent" then I believe the complaints will come in though because G/P have like 1/5 of the success of Papadakis/Cizeron, they may not be scrutinized as much.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 7 (members: 0, guests: 7)

Similar threads

K
2020-21 Programs and Choreographers
8 9 10
Replies
280
Views
48K
Sylvia
Sylvia
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information