Path forward for Canadian figure skating

Skiing and snowboarding are affordable in Canada?? Somewhat serious question here, as I have no idea what it’s like. In the U.S., it’s definitely not affordable.
Here in Toronto there are cheap skiing/boarding lessons offered by the city at very, very tiny hills. And it's probably cheaper to ski at somewhere like Vancouver's Cypress Mountain than it is to figure skate at Joanne McLeod's rink.
 
Canadian girls no longer interested in figure skating , they are more interested in sports like Swimming and Soccer Canada girls have developped into a powerhouse in those 2 sports.
 
I know funding would be an issue, but it would be great if clubs offered more canskate lessons with fewer people, maybe more levelled and focused on a few skills rather than just moving around hoops or lines drawn on the ice. And with an actual coach dedicated to each group, rather than just tween skaters who just got off their own practice ice (though the skaters can be there to assist). It would involve more ice time and more coaches getting paid, but IMO it's necessary. I'm just imagining a canskate session with maybe 25 kids max on the ice, split into groups of 5ish, each group with an actual coach.

My nephew did canskate a few years ago, and it was pretty much useless. The tweens barely looked at him, and the only time he was able to do more than just shuffle along was when a coach focused on him for a few minutes. In those times, with her assistance he was able to go forward and backwards, glide on one foot, etc. When the coach left, he was back to shuffling along, being ignored by the tweens. The groups weren't even instructed on what they were supposed to be doing at each designated 'station'. How is he supposed to enjoy skating and improve if nobody is giving him any guidance or encouragement?
 
Agreed - but the question is what does that mean? What does a SC program focused on elevating and training the most talented youngsters look like?

I think we all wish for an SC future that results in training that keeps our skaters competitive - and I think most (all?) of us are uncomfortable with the training programs we see in certain other countries that have resulted in skaters that are ranked at the top.
Skate Canada doesn't really have anything at the younger levels. It's pretty much parents and former skaters teaching kids how to skate. There's no identifying potential talent. SC needs to focus on how to encourage the early skaters, and for that to happen, it would take a lot of changes.

Everyone wants to learn how to skate, whether it's for hockey or figure skating or ringette. It's easier to go the team route, so SC needs to bring in former elite skaters to inspire the next generations. Regional competitions also need to return because they help the skaters prepare (also another way for SC to identify those with potential). There's a huge disconnect between SC and "CanSkate".
 
I have read of a number of top skaters who watched figure skating during the Olympics as a child and felt an instant connection. Movement to music and all the other things that set figure skating apart will always appeal to some. Skate Canada has to refigure out how to find these kids and open up a path for them.
 
Skiing and snowboarding are affordable in Canada?? Somewhat serious question here, as I have no idea what it’s like. In the U.S., it’s definitely not affordable.
They aren't dirt cheap, and neither is hockey, but they are lower cost at the mid-range level where potential talent is recognized before plans for big moves to elite training centres start being considered. It's also a lot easier to grab sponsors in skiing and snowboarding to help with expenses, and hockey is so pervasive in Canada that nearly every community has a solid peewee to pro pipeline talented kids can rely on along with access to used gear, local business financial support, and group training sessions.
 
Canadian girls no longer interested in figure skating , they are more interested in sports like Swimming and Soccer Canada girls have developped into a powerhouse in those 2 sports.
I teach 7 & 8 year olds. Most of the kids (girls and boys included) play soccer in the summer and hockey in the winter. They take skating lessons until they are good enough skaters to play hockey and then quit. Many ski or snow board recreationally and have pools in their backyards, but these are leisure/family activities to them, not 'sports'.
 
Skate Canada skate Ontario- those at the top…..mostly care about their salary, and it’s power. Imagine being paid and compensated over 1/4 million dollars annually to travel the world as an official congratulator as skaters come off the ice. Start there! It’s disgusting and skaters are forced to kiss the hand of some self appointed king/queen. The programs and operations are merely a means of control and the ability to qualify for more government funds which go 90% towards administration and ultimately 10% to the skaters. This needs to change. Bring a broom and get them the hell out.
 
Skate Canada skate Ontario- those at the top…..mostly care about their salary, and it’s power. Imagine being paid and compensated over 1/4 million dollars annually to travel the world as an official congratulator as skaters come off the ice. Start there! It’s disgusting and skaters are forced to kiss the hand of some self appointed king/queen. The programs and operations are merely a means of control and the ability to qualify for more government funds which go 90% towards administration and ultimately 10% to the skaters. This needs to change. Bring a broom and get them the hell out.
100%. Dismantling Canadian jr team (which means no funding) and coming up with the joke of a next-gen team they put together, especially in ladies 🙄. Obviously, someone is kissing *ss or greasing palms there. The percentage of revenue that goes to skaters vs their "overhead" is obscene.
 
So I'm going to be a contrarian. Does anything have to be done? There are plenty of countries that don't regularly get skaters on the podium. Canada has a similar population to Poland and slightly less than Ukraine. They don't get someone on the podium at every Olympics.

There is only so much money to go around. Maybe other sports are a better investment. As Judy says, parents like their kids in team sports. Figure skating is not a team sport. And it's very expensive.
 
So I'm going to be a contrarian. Does anything have to be done? There are plenty of countries that don't regularly get skaters on the podium. Canada has a similar population to Poland and slightly less than Ukraine. They don't get someone on the podium at every Olympics.

There is only so much money to go around. Maybe other sports are a better investment. As Judy says, parents like their kids in team sports. Figure skating is not a team sport. And it's very expensive.
This. Canada won no medals in 1980 and the 4-medal haul in 2018 was not the norm. That said, if Skate Canada would stop trying to appeal to the mainstream and just embrace figure skating as the fabulous, over the top, outrageous LGBTQ-friendly🌈 sport that is, maybe they'd have more success.;)
 
What SC needs to do is find something that will keep skaters engaged. USFSA did this with the National Solo Dance series. Local clubs have frequently said that Solo Dance has kept them open! They have made Solo Dance a prestigious discipline to do with all the fanfare of Nationals. Plus their National Showcase and Theatre on Ice also keep skater involved. There is nothing in Canada for the recreational skater to keep them engaged. Kids pass their golds at a young age. To be competitive in Star, you need to skate at least 5 days a week ( unless you have fun getting 15-18th place at every competition )

Not that this will win Olympic medals but it will create healthy clubs where a future Olympian might start
 
SC also needs to send skaters out to international assignments. Like the Challenge Cup this weekend. Skaters not going to Worlds or Jr Worlds could be getting out there again on the international scene, getting minimum scores, etc. Same with any of the Challenger series events. SC needs to take advantage of the opportunities to get skaters out there! We need to see more than just the previous year's national medallists getting international assignments. Even if that means they remove the criteria like senior ladies must have a triple lutz. Like FFS, what if a lady had a few different triple-triples and a triple axel (heck, even a quad or two), but couldn't do a triple lutz? When I myself was a skater, I could land all my triples up to lutz with varying degrees of consistency, but could not land a double axel.
 
Like FFS, what if a lady had a few different triple-triples and a triple axel (heck, even a quad or two), but couldn't do a triple lutz?
A skater like that would obviously be sent out. But that’s neither here nor there, since the skaters not being sent out are people who don’t have the big jumps and/or consistently fail to land them.
 
A skater like that would obviously be sent out. But that’s neither here nor there, since the skaters not being sent out are people who don’t have the big jumps and/or consistently fail to land them.
I know, though SC has been very stringent with their criteria. But the skaters who aren't consistently landing the big jumps need to experience the competitive environment. Skating against stronger competitors can be a huge motivator. And even feeling that your federation has some faith in you can help motivate as well. If you don't feel like your federation things you deserve to compete, what's going to make you want to continue in the sport?
 
So I'm going to be a contrarian. Does anything have to be done? There are plenty of countries that don't regularly get skaters on the podium. Canada has a similar population to Poland and slightly less than Ukraine. They don't get someone on the podium at every Olympics.

There is only so much money to go around. Maybe other sports are a better investment. As Judy says, parents like their kids in team sports. Figure skating is not a team sport. And it's very expensive.
That would be great if Canada didn't have a long history in figure skating as one of the sport's major countries. While not every year is expected to bring a multi-medal haul, Canada has taken home at least one figure skating medal in almost every Olympics over the last 70 years. It's been more than 40 years since Canada failed to win anything in figure skating at the games. From that perspective, it's something of a big deal to go home empty-handed.

It's not as if there are obvious future contenders waiting for their opportunity to hit the GP circuit either. People are going to question where figure skating is headed in Canada and ways to improve the existing system since it seems to have gone a bit sideways right now.

This. Canada won no medals in 1980 and the 4-medal haul in 2018 was not the norm. That said, if Skate Canada would stop trying to appeal to the mainstream and just embrace figure skating as the fabulous, over the top, outrageous LGBTQ-friendly🌈 sport that is, maybe they'd have more success.;)

I find this interesting as I've been increasingly hearing the opposite. Figure skating is still a very gendered sport, and there are rumblings about how it reinforces gender stereotypes, such as smiling, slim, pretty girls in sparkly dresses preferably doing less technical content than their male peers. I can see calls for change coming via the younger coaches and skaters, like Ash and Tim bringing a non-binary vibe to pairs and Sasha Trusova proving that women can jump five quad programs too, but I also hear commentators continue to laud very gendered choreography with defined male/female roles and in many parts of the world where skating is popular that's exactly how everyone wants it to remain. Athletes who attempt to challenge those perceptions have to battle against tradition in a judged sport, which is always harder than being a change agent in sports less reliant on personal opinions.
 
What SC needs to do is find something that will keep skaters engaged. USFSA did this with the National Solo Dance series. Local clubs have frequently said that Solo Dance has kept them open! They have made Solo Dance a prestigious discipline to do with all the fanfare of Nationals. Plus their National Showcase and Theatre on Ice also keep skater involved. There is nothing in Canada for the recreational skater to keep them engaged. Kids pass their golds at a young age. To be competitive in Star, you need to skate at least 5 days a week ( unless you have fun getting 15-18th place at every competition )

Not that this will win Olympic medals but it will create healthy clubs where a future Olympian might start
It might not directly lead to medals and maybe not even indirectly but it will make figure skating a fun sport with lots of participants many of whom will develop a lifelong interest in the sport. Figure skating doesn't just need Olympic-caliber skaters. It needs judges and accountants and volunteers for local clubs.

That would be great if Canada didn't have a long history in figure skating as one of the sport's major countries.
But things change. The US used to always have contenders in the Womens division. Then we stopped. And we used to rule ice dance, then our dance program was laughably bad and now we have contenders again. At one point we had Pairs who would vie for the podium and now we don't.

SC needs to figure out what they want and fund it. But I hope they don't get so fixated on international medals that they abandon the grassroots.
 
But the skaters who aren't consistently landing the big jumps need to experience the competitive environment. Skating against stronger competitors can be a huge motivator. And even feeling that your federation has some faith in you can help motivate as well. If you don't feel like your federation things you deserve to compete, what's going to make you want to continue in the sport?
That’s what domestic events are for. They’re the stepping stone to the bigger completions.

Faith is earned. If you can’t produce domestically, why would that change internationally?
But why not send them out anyway? Maybe seeing what other skaters are doing will motivate them.
Every assignment costs money. If they’re not motivated to do what is necessary to get out internationally, I don’t see why being sent places where they’re completely out of their element would make a difference.
 
I am very much a homer and I am not ashamed of it. I want Canadians to do well in the sports I like. I think it's great that Canada is doing well in, uhm, ski-cross or whatever....theoretically and logically, at least. And I don't want Canadian kids to be forced to compete in figure skating when they prefer to compete in monoblob. But Canadian success in figure skating brings me personal joy. And I like joy.

Technically, Canada may not leave Beijing empty handed. There is the team event. I suppose they literally left Beijing empty headed, but so did Teams ROC, USA and Japan.
 
I find this interesting as I've been increasingly hearing the opposite. Figure skating is still a very gendered sport, and there are rumblings about how it reinforces gender stereotypes, such as smiling, slim, pretty girls in sparkly dresses preferably doing less technical content than their male peers. I can see calls for change coming via the younger coaches and skaters, like Ash and Tim bringing a non-binary vibe to pairs and Sasha Trusova proving that women can jump five quad programs too, but I also hear commentators continue to laud very gendered choreography with defined male/female roles and in many parts of the world where skating is popular that's exactly how everyone wants it to remain. Athletes who attempt to challenge those perceptions have to battle against tradition in a judged sport, which is always harder than being a change agent in sports less reliant on personal opinions.
My silly comment meant that I WANT Skate Canada to stop enforcing rigid and traditional gender roles. Embrace jock butch women skaters, femme men skaters, non binary skaters like Leduc, etc. And ban Julie Marcotte's treacly music collection.;)
 
Last edited:
So I'm going to be a contrarian. Does anything have to be done? There are plenty of countries that don't regularly get skaters on the podium. Canada has a similar population to Poland and slightly less than Ukraine. They don't get someone on the podium at every Olympics.

There is only so much money to go around. Maybe other sports are a better investment. As Judy says, parents like their kids in team sports. Figure skating is not a team sport. And it's very expensive.
Team sports are what parents gravitate to, and thus their kids. And parents themselves have to invest time in figure skating in some way. Accountants, judges, volunteers for dressing rooms etc. And parents aren't doing it. We're too scattered, we don't really invest in facilities that do just figure skating that accommodates novice/junior skaters. Canada is a big country. We don't send our kids off to Van or MTL or TO and board them like they do in Russia for instance. What can be done, is being done. Identifying talented skaters is part of the problem, but even if they were and they lived in Iktoyutuk, the coaches aren't going to move there and the skaters aren't going to move to a training facility until they're middle teens for sure. We've been lucky and I've liked it. But some years or decades we aren't going to be. I don't really see a solution per se.
 
SC also needs to send skaters out to international assignments. Like the Challenge Cup this weekend. Skaters not going to Worlds or Jr Worlds could be getting out there again on the international scene, getting minimum scores, etc. Same with any of the Challenger series events. SC needs to take advantage of the opportunities to get skaters out there! We need to see more than just the previous year's national medallists getting international assignments. Even if that means they remove the criteria like senior ladies must have a triple lutz. Like FFS, what if a lady had a few different triple-triples and a triple axel (heck, even a quad or two), but couldn't do a triple lutz? When I myself was a skater, I could land all my triples up to lutz with varying degrees of consistency, but could not land a double axel.
Is it possible that SC doesn’t have the funds to send out skaters to any more events than they already are?
 
I am very much a homer and I am not ashamed of it. I want Canadians to do well in the sports I like. I think it's great that Canada is doing well in, uhm, ski-cross or whatever....theoretically and logically, at least. And I don't want Canadian kids to be forced to compete in figure skating when they prefer to compete in monoblob. But Canadian success in figure skating brings me personal joy. And I like joy.

Technically, Canada may not leave Beijing empty handed. There is the team event. I suppose they literally left Beijing empty headed, but so did Teams ROC, USA and Japan.
The thing is Canada did really well in these Olympics. We over exceeded projected medal counts.

Not in figure skating, however…..

Oh well, maybe we will get the team bronze in 2 years time. :shuffle:
 
They would have more money if Slipchuk hadn't been sent to the Olympics. Why did he need to be there?
Zukiwsky was there too, wasn't he? Could have done without one of them.

There were 214 athletes and 85 coaches in the delegation. The total was 414 so they had 115 officials, delegates etc. There were 13 figure skaters and 10 coaches (3 with other country accreditations).

COC stats
 
Is it possible that SC doesn’t have the funds to send out skaters to any more events than they already are?
SC charges $45/yr per skater stepping on any club ice across Canada. There are 130,000 skaters per year registered. There are over 5800 coaches paying over $100 a year to register. And the only real benefit any of them see is accidental insurance coverage. On top of that, they get a cut of all club competitions held across the country AND everything is basically run by volunteers. So I have a really hard time understanding why they don't have funds...
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top
Do Not Sell My Personal Information