skatingguy
decently
- Messages
- 18,627
I like it.I find it very interesting that the JSF didn't give Team KoKo the Worlds spot for ice dance but are, instead, obviously using 4CCs as a skate-off for the spot.
I like it.I find it very interesting that the JSF didn't give Team KoKo the Worlds spot for ice dance but are, instead, obviously using 4CCs as a skate-off for the spot.
I think Yamamoto had his shot last season at Worlds, and missed, and he had his chance to make the Grand Prix Final this season, and missed. Miura has shown to be the more consistent skater. He also won a Grand Prix event, and won World Juniors, and Four Continents last season. It makes sense to send Miura.No outrage over the men´s world spots?
Because last year, all hell broke loose when Sota Yamamoto was selected fo Worlds. He came to Nationals as a GPF silver medalist, he had his body of work speaking for him, but people acted like he was just some random dude the "incompetent" JSF was selecting for Worlds- over Koshiro Shimada, who had zero results at international competitions but medaled at Nationals.
But now we have Sota as a GP winner and National bronze medalist, but no anger over Kao Miura being selected over him for Worlds? The double standards are glaring...
Where?Because last year, all hell broke loose
In Lambiel's camp mostly, IIRC, lol.Where?
The only person I can remember caring all that much about that injustice was Uno, who is Shimada’s training mate and friend. I don’t blame him for standing up for his friend, but I think most impartial observers realised Shimada’s national medal was a bit of a fluke and JSF’s criteria allowed for flexibility in the selection process, so…No outrage over the men´s world spots?
Because last year, all hell broke loose when Sota Yamamoto was selected fo Worlds. He came to Nationals as a GPF silver medalist, he had his body of work speaking for him, but people acted like he was just some random dude the "incompetent" JSF was selecting for Worlds- over Koshiro Shimada, who had zero results at international competitions but medaled at Nationals.
But now we have Sota as a GP winner and National bronze medalist, but no anger over Kao Miura being selected over him for Worlds? The double standards are glaring...
This was what I'd thought last year lol. IDK why Uno's interview would have been about Yamamoto's worlds spot or Uno's (absent) 4CC spot as was being suggested on this board last year.FWIW if anyone had been "pulled" from the world team to make room for Shimada (or Kao or Shun Sato), it probably would have been Tomono (3rd at nationals, just a point above Sato), not Sota Yamamoto, who was pretty locked in as the GPF silver medalist.
Were you here last year for this "all hell broke loose" because you only joined a month ago? Neither skaters are favorites of mine but I think the situation if very understandable considering that last 12 months of results and actual skates. Kao needs to fix his spins and stop putting them on the backburner or at least that is what is appears like.No outrage over the men´s world spots?
Because last year, all hell broke loose when Sota Yamamoto was selected fo Worlds. He came to Nationals as a GPF silver medalist, he had his body of work speaking for him, but people acted like he was just some random dude the "incompetent" JSF was selecting for Worlds- over Koshiro Shimada, who had zero results at international competitions but medaled at Nationals.
But now we have Sota as a GP winner and National bronze medalist, but no anger over Kao Miura being selected over him for Worlds? The double standards are glaring...
And it worked out ..a sixth for Kazuki combined w Shoma's first..kept those three spots. #thelittleenginethatdidFWIW if anyone had been "pulled" from the world team to make room for Shimada (or Kao or Shun Sato), it probably would have been Tomono (3rd at nationals, just a point above Sato), not Sota Yamamoto, who was pretty locked in as the GPF silver medalist.
Because there’s a process to which Japan considered the spots. Sota won a gold medal on the Grand Prix and then skated so poorly in the second event that it knocked him out of the Final while three of his teammates earned tickets. He also had his less than stellar showing at Worlds last season.Sota Yamamoto's Japanese Nationals 2024 freeskate was the absolute best that I have ever seen him skate. As ultra-impressive as his jumps were (2 quad toes w/one in combination, a quad salchow, a 3-axel half loop 3-salchow combination, another single 3-axel that was even better than the 1st one, a 3-flip/2-axel sequence, and a beauty of a 3-lutz to close the program), I was more impressed with everything happening in between the jumps, the incredible shapes and pictures that Sota created on the ice, the way he used and emoted to his music, the fantastic line, stretch and turn-out that he maintained throughout the program, the fast and centered spins (with innovative positions)...even his crossovers seemed artistic...as he seemed to caress the ice...the glide and flow was sublime! I am truly mystified as to how anyone who skates like Sota skated could be left off the World team. It does not make any sense to me.- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.www.youtube.com
I’m not sure if saying that is the best he has ever skated etc and he only got third. Who said they don’t want Sota but he skated well 1.5 competitions this season.The USA would kill for Sota Yamamoto (on their World Team), as no American skater not named Ilia has skated as well this season as Sota did at his Nationals. If Japan does not want Sota, send him our way!
I'll chime in to agree with you.The USA would kill for Sota Yamamoto (on their World Team), as no American skater not named Ilia has skated as well this season as Sota did at his Nationals. If Japan does not want Sota, send him our way!
We must be watching two different skaters? I also genuinely didn't like all the fist pumping after the jumps, thought it took away from the music. The step sequence made me keep wondering how Shoma would skate it.I was more impressed with everything happening in between the jumps, the incredible shapes and pictures that Sota created on the ice, the way he used and emoted to his music, the fantastic line, stretch and turn-out that he maintained throughout the program, the fast and centered spins (with innovative positions)...even his crossovers seemed artistic...as he seemed to caress the ice...the glide and flow was sublime!
It is staggering the quality of the Japanese men that aren’t making it to worlds this year. The toughest field in the world!- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.www.youtube.comSota Yamamoto's Japanese Nationals 2024 freeskate was the absolute best that I have ever seen him skate. As ultra-impressive as his jumps were (2 quad toes w/one in combination, a quad salchow, a 3-axel half loop 3-salchow combination, another single 3-axel that was even better than the 1st one, a 3-flip/2-axel sequence, and a beauty of a 3-lutz to close the program), I was more impressed with everything happening in between the jumps, the incredible shapes and pictures that Sota created on the ice, the way he used and emoted to his music, the fantastic line, stretch and turn-out that he maintained throughout the program, the fast and centered spins (with innovative positions)...even his crossovers seemed artistic...as he seemed to caress the ice...the glide and flow was sublime! I am truly mystified as to how anyone who skates like Sota skated could be left off the World team. It does not make any sense to me.- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.www.youtube.com
Exactly. I love Shoma & Yuma’s musicality and movement but they come across as younger, more petit men. To me, Sota comes across as DA MAN!It is staggering the quality of the Japanese men that aren’t making it to worlds this year. The toughest field in the world!
It seems like more of a judgment call than we usually see after Japanese Nationals. Sota defeated Miura in both head-to-heads this season as well as last year's Nationals. But Miura did have a higher placement at his second GP and won a CS so his average placements this season are legitimately higher.Because there’s a process to which Japan considered the spots. Sota won a gold medal on the Grand Prix and then skated so poorly in the second event that it knocked him out of the Final while three of his teammates earned tickets. He also had his less than stellar showing at Worlds last season.
I thought it was extremely likely that Miura was going to worlds unless he bombed at Nationals because he made GPF, since that was a big part of the reason Sota went to Worlds last year. JSF appears to value consistency a LOT, and doesn't usually consider prior year. Sota really hurt his chances by struggling so much at his 2nd GP; while more consistent and higher performing than Koshiro last year, it was still a big ding for worlds selection.It seems like more of a judgment call than we usually see after Japanese Nationals. Sota defeated Miura in both head-to-heads this season as well as last year's Nationals. But Miura did have a higher placement at his second GP and won a CS so his average placements this season are legitimately higher.
- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.www.youtube.comSota Yamamoto's Japanese Nationals 2024 freeskate was the absolute best that I have ever seen him skate. As ultra-impressive as his jumps were (2 quad toes w/one in combination, a quad salchow, a 3-axel half loop 3-salchow combination, another single 3-axel that was even better than the 1st one, a 3-flip/2-axel sequence, and a beauty of a 3-lutz to close the program), I was more impressed with everything happening in between the jumps, the incredible shapes and pictures that Sota created on the ice, the way he used and emoted to his music, the fantastic line, stretch and turn-out that he maintained throughout the program, the fast and centered spins (with innovative positions)...even his crossovers seemed artistic...as he seemed to caress the ice...the glide and flow was sublime! I am truly mystified as to how anyone who skates like Sota skated could be left off the World team. It does not make any sense to me.- YouTube
Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube.www.youtube.com
Agreed. Yes, the jumps were AMAZING. But almost nothing but stroking and crossovers between jumps. Except for the choreo sequence and steps, of course. I feel his upper body is VERY stiff, too, and his arms and hands are, eh. He has a ways to go before I'd call him artistic.We must be watching two different skaters? I also genuinely didn't like all the fist pumping after the jumps, thought it took away from the music. The step sequence made me keep wondering how Shoma would skate it.
Sota's third here is (probably) deserved, but I completely agree with Kao going to worlds.
I just also don't like when skaters don't vary their speed with the music and instead use their arms to 'acknowledge' it.Agreed. Yes, the jumps were AMAZING. But almost nothing but stroking and crossovers between jumps. Except for the choreo sequence and steps, of course. I feel his upper body is VERY stiff, too, and his arms and hands are, eh. He has a ways to go before I'd call him artistic.