Did China only qualify one lady?
I didn't even think about China earlier.
@Tony Wheeler How do you see China being so close to USA in the SP/SD? They will win pairs over us and possibly men, but we would win ice dance and ladies. I would think that Sui/Han's advantage over Knierims in the SP would be mostly offset by the Shibs' advantage over Wang/Liu in the SD. (But I haven't looked closely at any numbers.)
Yes, one lady.
Well there you have it, my head hurts.
So, it has to be two men and two pairs, because they seem to have no other choice.
So China could consider Yu/Zhang SP, Sui/Han LP. Both teams can pretty much do clean SPs in their sleep. OTOH, if you're looking at placements in the SP as most important (not points), Sui/Han almost certainly give you 1st place in SP, whereas I would see Yu/Zhang as 2nd, or maybe 3rd.
Is the team SD/SP score just the sum of all the individual scores of each team member?
Total points after the short:
Russia 42 points
Canada 34 points
USA 30 points
China 26 points
Japan 24 points
---------------------top 5 qualify to the free
France 22 points
Italy 17 points
Germany 15 points
Korea 11 points
Australia 10 points
Czech Republic 8 points
(This may look very encouraging for the U.S. team & the short programs ARE very important for Team USA. Note, however, that it requires Mirai Nagasu to compete in the SP and Chock & Bates to defeat Papadakis & Cizeron--lovely World Team Trophy scores. But I totally support putting C&B/H&D up here and the Shibs in the free. If we haven't figured out that putting C&B up in an FD in team competition is a bad idea after 3 years of losing ground to W&P there, we deserve what we get).
Now things get tricky because it depends on who you put up & which disciplines you swap out. Using this year's LP/FD season's best scores & making the best judgment calls I could for each team based on what would be best for each team but allowing the maximum number of athletes for every team, except possibly the men's spot in China:
Pairs LP:
1. RUS Stolbova & Klimov 10 pts
2. CAN Seguin & Bilodeau 9 pts
3. CHN Peng & Jin or Yu & Zhang (they are back to back) 8 pts
4. USA Scimeca-Knierim & Knierim 7 pts
5. JPN Suzaki & Kihara 6 pts
Men's LP: (Scenario 1--with Nathan & Jin)
1. JPN Uno 10 pts
2. CHN Jin 9 pts
3. USA Chen 8 pts
4. CAN Chan 7 pts
5. RUS Kovtun 6 pts (Kolyada finishes here as well)
Men's LP: (Scenario 2--without Nathan & Jin)
1. JPN Uno 10 pts
2. CAN Chan 9 pts
3. USA Brown/Rippon/Zhou 8 pts
4. RUS Kovtun 6 pts (Kolyada beats Brown/Rippon/Zhou with his SB)
5. CHN Yan 5 pts
Men's LP (Scenario 3--with Nathan & without Jin)
1. JPN Uno 10 pts
2. USA Chen 9 pts
3. CAN Chan 7 points
4. RUS Kovtun 6 points
5. Yan 5 points
Men's LP (Scenario 4--without Nathan & with Jin)
1. JPN Uno 10 pts
2. CHN Jin 9 pts
3. CAN Chan 8 pts
4. USA Brown/Rippon/Zhou 7 pts
5. RUS Kovtun 6 pts (with Kolyada, #4 & 5 swap and Russia gets 7 points and the U.S. gets 6)
Dance FD
1. CAN Virtue & Moir 10 pts
2. USA Shibs 9 pts
3. RUS Bobrova & Soloviev 8 pts
4. CHN Wang & Liu 7 pts
5. JPN Muramoto & Reed 6 pts
Ladies LP
1. RUS Medvedeva 10 pts (If Russia swaps ladies, they lose one spot by swapping her with Anna's SB or two if they swap her with Zagitova's/Radionova's)
2. JPN Mihara 9 pts
3. CAN Daleman 8 pts
4. USA Wagner 7 pts
5. CHN Li 6 pts
Total LP/FD Points using Men's scenario #1:
RUS: 34 pts
CAN: 34 pts
JPN 31 pts
USA 31 pts
CHN 30 pts
TOTAL SP & LP points combined:
RUS: 76 pts
CAN: 68 pts
USA: 61 pts
CHN: 56 pts
JPN: 55 pts
Random analysis you may feel free to ignore:
China gains two points by putting up Sui & Han in the free. China loses three points by swapping out Jin in the FP.
The U.S. loses 1 point should Chock & Bates lose to Papadakis & Cizeron in the SD. (U.S. loses a lot more should the U.S. team lose to Bobrova & Soloviev and Cappellini & Lanotte, but the U.S. teams are capable of getting this job done). The U.S. loses 1 point by swapping Nagasu's SB with either Wagner's or Chen's. The U.S. loses 2-3 points on top of that point by swapping out Nathan with Brown/Rippon/Zhou, depending on what Russia does with Kolyada/Kovtun.
While I do think Hubbell & Donohue are legitimate factors to make the team, their current SB scores do not. H&D's SB would lose the same likely spot in the SD to France as C&B or the Shibs. H&D's SB in the free would also lose one spot to Russia. Should Canada choose to put up Duhamel & Radford twice and swap Virtue & Moir with Weaver & Poje in the free, the Shibs' SB--and only the Shibs' SB--would gain a point.
Surprises:
So Youn Park has Korea's highest short program score. (Korea & Italy factor in the ladies SP).
Both Seguin & Bilodeau and Mirai Nagasu made "surprise" appearances on this list. Courtesy of scores dating clear back to the Autumn Classic.
I do think the Knierims may return to their quad twist, which would up their scoring potential in the LP. Still a big ask to pass China's #2 in the LP. Also quite plausible China's #2 passes Canada's #2 there.
Except Russia has 32 points after the short.
You have Canada winning as well.
Thank you. I edited Russia's totals.
Nagasu's SB in the short is above Kostner's. I pointed it out because it's not likely to play out that way in a head-to-head, but those were the numbers I crunched.
Is Aliona even going to compete in the team event? She didn't in Sochi. If she didn't compete there, I don't know why she would here. I don't think the German team has any shot at a medal, so it probably doesn't make much sense for her to compete.
The Germans and Russians probably have a comfortable cushion over Y/Z. And if the Canadians (whoever competes) can go clean, they also could spoil. The French if they keep improving might even make it interesting. A difference between 1st and 3rd or 4th might be enough to determine the bronze medalists.. I really think it will be that close.
Men - Ralf will not let Chen do both; too much punishment for one competition. Biggest point haul would be for him to do long. Jason has scored mid to upper 90's for short. As he is very dependable it doesn't leave the US too far behind going into long. So, Jason for short.
Dance - This takes care of the 1 entry requirement.