Why did the US stop hosting the US Classic it used to be a Challenger event and it was in early September the Cranberry Cup is just to damn early in the season at the very least they need to try to make it to the end of August or early September like the US Classic was or host another new event in September that might get to Challenger status.
2025 Grand Prix Assignments
- Thread starter tony
- Start date
ice coverage
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 838
Off topic for this thread, but to clarify:
Similarly to previous years, USFS was working with Emerging Athletes alongside 2024 Champs Camp.
JGP singles skaters who were involved that week (not quite all of them were) belonged to the EA group.
ETA: Also in the EA group were several non-JGP singles skaters.
(Past editions of EA have had all four disciplines, but I don't think this particular one in 2024 had dancers or pairs.)
Last edited:
Lutzes&Loops
Active Member
- Messages
- 65
Actually, Sarah won Cranberry. Elyse was second.
Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,469
Okay, the Alysa interview with Boomer Esiason that aired over the weekend where she confirmed she does plan on adding the 3A back to her programs next season has caused me to revisit my Women's GP and GPF predictions.Okay, I've tormented ANL enough and am going to try my lame attempt at handicapping the Women's GP field... These are surely going to be wrong because I'm sure the US women will let me down & the Japanese women will dominate.
GPdF -Chaeyeon;
Kaori;
Isabeau; 4th Petrokina; 5th Nakai - the GPdF magic has finally run out for Rion
CoC -
SCI -
NHK -
SkAm -
Finlandia -
GPF qualifiers -
30 pts - Alysa
28 pts - Chaeyeon, Kaori, Amber
26 pts - Isabeau
24 pts - Mone
GPF Alternates - Bradie, Wakaba, & Petrokina
GPF -
I'm now predicting Amber will win
at CoC, with Alysa taking- I feel like the 3A is going to be a little unsteady/not quite successful at her first GP, but that by SkAm, she'll have it under control. I also think that Amber is going to be buoyed by coming in as the only woman with 2 GP
and she'll pip Mone forat the GPF, thereby securing her place in the TE in Milano-Cortina.
Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,469
Except that if Alysa places higher than Amber at the GPF, in addition to her being WC, it doesn't seem likely that USFS would leave her off the TE.
I guess we'll have to see what happens and what Alysa wants to do. It should be hers to accept or decline, I agree.
AngieNikodinovLove (ANL)
Get it Amber 😝
- Messages
- 16,339
Okay, the Alysa interview with Boomer Esiason that aired over the weekend where she confirmed she does plan on adding the 3A back to her programs next season has caused me to revisit my Women's GP and GPF predictions.
I'm now predicting Amber will win
I also think that Amber is going to be buoyed by coming in as the only woman with 2 GP
Well, someone has come to her senses.
Could you imagine if we have three women doing triple axels this coming season?
Theatregirl1122
Needs a nap
- Messages
- 34,246
In a fair world, women would be split in the TE this year, but I imagine it will be men and dance that get split.
Last edited:
AngieNikodinovLove (ANL)
Get it Amber 😝
- Messages
- 16,339
not if ANL has something to say about
Jarrett
What the hell?!
- Messages
- 3,720
I can't imagine chock and bates splitting with anyone specifically the shibs lol
Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,469
LOL. I can. Ice dance is the first individual event after the team event.
And they were hard done by 2018. I don't think that's something they'll ever forget, especially if they're given the first choice as the 3-time World Champs. I fully expect, if CarPon make the GPF and she gets her passport, that ChoBat will split.
But i don't think they get a choice about who to split with (i wish they did, but...). It goes to the next-ranked team, as determined by USFS. Unless CPom outscore the Shibs on the GP and/or beat them head-to-head at the GPF, I can't see USFS ranking the Shibs behind them.
Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,469
Actually, we do know how the USFS determines the next highest ranked team - it's based on WS. And there's no way the Shibs will be able to overtake CarPon, who are currently ranked #6 & have 3267 points. There's actually no way the Shibs will be able to overtake any of the 4 teams from the 2025 Nats podium. ChoBat have 4080 points, ZingKol have 2724 points and GreenP have 2443 points; they also wouldn't catch NesMark who have 1800 pts & will add some points during the fall. They can overtake any other US team, though, if they won both their Challengers (300 pts each) & both their GPs (400 pts each) & made the GPF.
kwanfan1818
RIP D-10
- Messages
- 39,842
We also know that USFS will do what it wants to. I hope it's sticking to WS, but we'll see.
Hmmm, OK, I thought they loosely used the BoW criteria that they use for Oly consideration, except the TE has always been a bit murky, i.e. USFS doing what they want. Hopefully they follow that (WS).
But do they? Nagasu had the higher world standing in 2018 (over Tennell by a lot) and we repeatedly hear about how her having an Olympic medal only because of the Shibutanis taking both segments, allowing the women to split.
I do think it’s more convenient for them to not cause drama by just saying they use it (ie. Chen getting first choice in 2022) but they are going to do what they want in the end.
Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,469
Well, that's what fans have always said, but we don't know which woman would have been used in the TE had the Shibs chosen to split. As it is, the Shibs are the reason why we know they use WS. It was explained in either the US Ice Dance thread last month when the Shibs return was announced, IIRC. The Shibs were neither the Nat'l Champs nor the highest ranked team from the previous Worlds going into Pyeongchang. They were, though, the highest ranked team in the WS.
The Shibs were 3rd at 2017 Worlds, C/B were 7th, H/D 9th. In the SD, the order was the reverse...H/D 3rd, C/B 4th, Shibs 5th, but then disaster struck C/B and H/D in the FD.
It has seemed that USFS has used previous season's Worlds results to rank the dance teams. In 2022, I think C/B were ranked higher than H/D in WS and did outscore them in total points on the GP (but no GPF due to Covid) that fall, and of course won Nats, but H/D were the World medalists and had beaten C/B at SA. There was an argument for either to be ranked #1 but USFS went with H/D (I think we can assume that since H/D skated the RD).
Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,469
Alright then. My bad. I just woke up about 30 min ago after a restless night due to a back ache & didn't go searching for the other discussion & was just going off memory.The Shibs were 3rd at 2017 Worlds, C/B were 7th, H/D 9th. In the SD, the order was the reverse...H/D 3rd, C/B 4th, Shibs 5th, but then disaster struck C/B and H/D in the FD.
It has seemed that USFS has used previous season's Worlds results to rank the dance teams. In 2022, I think C/B were ranked higher than H/D in WS and did outscore them in total points on the GP (but no GPF due to Covid) that fall, and of course won Nats, but H/D were the World medalists and had beaten C/B at SA. There was an argument for either to be ranked #1 but USFS went with H/D (I think we can assume that since H/D skated the RD).
kwanfan1818
RIP D-10
- Messages
- 39,842
I don’t think we can assume anything from the program order, since the US was a lock for the frees. I don’t think we know who “agreed” to split, ie, could have refused to, but only that C/B and H/D had a pact to split. I assume that was based on not wanting a repeat of 2018, but I don’t know if they said this explicitly.
TanithandBenFan
Author of the Ice and Edge Series
- Messages
- 9,922
Amber explained how she and Alysa ended up at CoC together on This Week in Skating’s podcast interview. Amber had chosen another GP but was usurped by a host pick. It sounds like she was given the option of doing back to back GPs as a second option, but she chose not to do that. So she ended up in China.
Karen-W
YMCA is such a catchy tune!
- Messages
- 51,469
So, basically, she wanted NHK, but the JSF chose Wakaba as a host pick.
Which tells us -
#1 Alysa - chose SkAm & CoC
#2 Kaori - chose NHK & GPdF
#3 Mone - got what she got - SCI & Finlandia (makes sense since Kaori wouldn't have wanted to do SCI & NHK back-to-back)
#4 Isabeau - chose GPdF & SCI (potentially also wanted NHK, but again, iced out by the JSF selecting Wakaba, which left her with SCI, SkAm & Finlandia as her options & she chose SCI)
#5 Amber - wanted NHK & Finlandia, but the JSF had already chosen Wakaba for NHK, which left Amber with the choice of SkAm or CoC as her 2nd GP & she chose CoC rather than have back-to-back events
#6 Wakaba - wanted NHK & CoC, but wound up with SkAm because Amber had priority over her in the selection of their 2nd events
It wouldn't necessarily surprise me if Amber & Isabeau both decided that since the JSF blocked either of them from NHK by selecting Wakaba, they decided to force Wakaba into the back-to-back intercontinental competitions.
Last edited:
AngieNikodinovLove (ANL)
Get it Amber 😝
- Messages
- 16,339
The other mystery is why did Alysa pick COC? Just wondering.
AngieNikodinovLove (ANL)
Get it Amber 😝
- Messages
- 16,339
Sounds like she done already done had herses.
Users who are viewing this thread
Similar threads
