Broken Ice's Lori Ward denied media accreditation to Skate Canada and Skate America

Just because her work has, of late, focused on the culture of the sport that has led to abuse doesn't mean that she isn't looking to expand her reporting on the sport to something more general - after all, like Phil Hersh, she's got a Substack that needs subscribers.
She could start by interviewing skaters on more general skating-related topics
I enjoyed Lori Ward's recent article that I've posted in this GSD thread: https://www.fsuniverse.net/forum/threads/skaters-and-social-media.114043/#post-6961371

BTW, Phil Hersh doesn't have a Substack - he started his "Globetrotting" blog in 2015(?) after he stopped writing about Olympic sports for the Chicago Tribune.
 
For whatever this is worth, applications for press credentials for Grand Prix events must be submitted to the ISU, not the individual federations. This could account for the rejection verbiage to be the same.
I was going to mention this, it is a completely different process this year so you do not deal with the skating federations she noted? It’s now all done through the ISU.
 
As an American nobody myself who was credentialed several times for Canadian events in the 2010s (and one American ISU event, reporting for Ice-Dance.com), but has also had photographers sometimes approved and sometimes denied for unstated reasons, I think it's certainly possible Ward was denied for the reasons many assume. But for independent outlets, priority is given to those who will provide event reporting -- I don't recall ever necessarily having to promise this during the application process, but it felt like an understood part of the bargain. And as @cholla mentioned, GP events aren't the ideal venues for conducting more sensitive interviews. It's possible she's hoping to branch out into more event-based coverage, but her post about this didn't leave me with that impression.

Anyway, it is unfortunate, but I don't care for the tone some are taking about it on social media, making snide remarks about the "lesser" independent journalists and bloggers they assume will get credentials. I think as long as someone is writing about the sport in good faith and fairness, accreditation is a win.
 
At Worlds in Montreal, we (credentialed media) were told NOT to ask N. Sørensen any questions NOT pertaining to the competition itself, although none of us were investigative journalists (besides Brennan who's also much more than this). So I'm not surprised Lori Ward is denied credentials at SC and SA now. At Worlds 24, Brennan of course didn't comply. But it's big loud Christine (don't be mistaken, I like her a lot) and Ward's career, as great as it is, can't compare. It's unfair because as Karen-W wrote, if she was working for a mainstream media she would be treated differently. It's clear the ISU and national federations don't want journalists to make waves, we all know that.

It's just wrong that journalists were told not to ask certain questions when it's very much a matter of interest to the sport and the public.

I disagree that a competition is the wrong time for it. Insisting on another time is just a way to protect wrondoers. I'm not a huge fan of Christine Brennan's but at least she isn't serving as a mouthpiece for TPTB.

As for the skaters, if you want to commit sexual assault and try to dodge the consequences, be prepared for some tough questions. And if skaters want to make public statements in support of that person through the safety of a paid documentary, then be prepared for some tough questions.

She could start by interviewing skaters on more general skating-related topics and publishing these interviews on Substack first and then apply for credentials
:lol: There's no way they would grant her credentials just because she adds in other coverage. Let's be real.
 
It's just wrong that journalists were told not to ask certain questions when it's very much a matter of interest to the sport and the public.
I didn't say it was right. It felt like Stalin regime and none of us liked it at all. No media wants to be told what to say or not to say. The process was rather underhand as nothing was written, we didn't receive a note or something. It wasn't even told by an ISU official, it's volunteers who came to us in the mixed zone with the instruction and they looked pretty embarrassed to have to deliver it. I've been around competitions for several decades, and it was the only time it happened.

I disagree that a competition is the wrong time for it.
As a psychologist I cannot agree. For abused people to feel confident enough to talk, you'd better pick out a time when they are not already under pressure and above all when they are away from their partner or coach who more often than not is the abuser. And confronting the abuser in public generally does no good to the victim either, especially if she has never come forward.

Insisting on another time is just a way to protect wrondoers.
Who insists on what? When I wrote the piece Sylvia linked, it took a while for people, first to agree to talk to me, then to arrange a meeting. The location and the time of the interviews were always their choice, not mine. For those still in activity, it was always somewhere else than the rink where they trained/worked. How can you talk when eyes are on you or when your abuser is around? And what time do you have for this at a competition where everything is tightly scheduled? The piece I wrote meant 23 hours of recordings. Some people talked to me for 3 hours. Not because I grilled them at all but because it was the first time they were given the opportunity to open up. How do you find 3 hours to talk during a competition? And for the record, I ressent the fact you mention that it's protecting wrongdoers. It's false and unfair both to the victims and the reporter. Federations protect wrongdoers, most of media don't.
I'm not a huge fan of Christine Brennan's but at least she isn't serving as a mouthpiece for TPTB.
Not sure what TPTB stands for but if it's "that's beside the point", not being able to act as freely as Brennan is NOT serving as a "mouthpiece" for anything or anyone. Being an investigative journalist and a sport reporter are two different things even if some people do both. Not every journalist has investigation for a mission. And not having this for a mission doesn't mean we're useless cowards parroting/yaking on meaningless subjects. Edit: thanks to @Sylvia I know what TPTB means and my position remains the same. Very few of us are at competitions to shine the shoes of organizing bodies. For information, websites like mines are entirely financed from our own pockets and it's time consuming and extremely expensive. I'm known to be politically incorrect and it never barred me from being credentialed, even by FFSG while lambasting some of its governants. Gailhaguet used to say that bad publicity was better than no publicity at all. The only rebutal I got was from G. Noury who never accepted to be interviewed but she was refusing all ITWs, it was not even personal. None of us writes about how great ISU is. You don't need to lick their boots to be admitted anywhere. Lori Ward writes about a particular subject that we sometimes mention too. But governing entities focus on the rest, because there is one. Ward's work is necessary but I think she doesn't need accreditation to do it. On the contrary, for what she does, it's better to have entirely free hands. Again, not that ours are tied. But we write about something else.

As for the skaters, if you want to commit sexual assault and try to dodge the consequences, be prepared for some tough questions. And if skaters want to make public statements in support of that person through the safety of a paid documentary, then be prepared for some tough questions.
They will never be ready for tough questions. They don't even see what's wrong with their behavior. They think they are misunderstood and victims themselves. Tough questions won't deter abusers either. You can fill a room with 100 media people all firing tough questions to a known abuser and he will only pull a Sørensen's outraged face and leave. The frontal approach doesn't work or everybody would use it and the problem would be easier to solve. Investigating abuse in sport is the work of an ant at first, before you can make big and effective noise. Undermining and smoking out abusers works generally better than bombing them from above or in the face.
 
Last edited:
I was going to mention this, it is a completely different process this year so you do not deal with the skating federations she noted? It’s now all done through the ISU.
It was always all done through the ISU, it hasn't changed. I get my credentials for Grand Prix de France from the ISU not FFSG. But national federations have their say in the matter, they review accreditation requests (it's the job of the competition official press officer who is not necessarily a member of the skating fed but who acts as a coordinator) before the ISU gives its OK. There are always some local or regional media that goes directly to skating feds, generally because they don't know how to proceed or because they wake up past the deadline for requests. In this case the fed has to submit the request to the ISU anyway. Feds are the 1st filter, ISU is the second.
 
I agree with @cholla that while I appreciate what Ward is doing, a competition isn't the best place to ask victims of abuse within the sport to open up, and she hasn't shown interest in covering the competition aspect of the sport. And this response to her credential applications seem to double down that she doesn't have interest in traditional competition coverage.

I've been in Skate Canada media rooms and mixed zones where the journalists are shoulder-to-shoulder, sometimes trading off and sharing power outlets and seats with colleagues because there's not enough space. Skate Canada often holds events in smaller arenas that don't have much back-of-house room. US arenas are often a bit bigger, but I've been in some pretty packed media rooms in the U.S. as well. I don't know either of these venues specifically, but I can't blame either organization for prioritizing media that's doing more traditional event coverage.
 
I'm not sure Ward would be at competitions to ask victims of abuse anything?

I think she would be there to question the skating organizations (Skate Canada, Skate America, ISU, TPTB) about what they are doing/planning to do to address this?

I think this is why she didn't get accreditation. The organizations don't want to answer any questions.
 
It was always all done through the ISU, it hasn't changed. I get my credentials for Grand Prix de France from the ISU not FFSG. But national federations have their say in the matter, they review accreditation requests (it's the job of the competition official press officer who is not necessarily a member of the skating fed but who acts as a coordinator) before the ISU gives its OK. There are always some local or regional media that goes directly to skating feds, generally because they don't know how to proceed or because they wake up past the deadline for requests. In this case the fed has to submit the request to the ISU anyway. Feds are the 1st filter, ISU is the second.
As an Italian nobody working for Art on Ice Italy, I got my credentials for CoR 2010, Skate America 2013 and NHK Trophy 2013, through the respective federations, without going through the ISU system. Starting with 2014 Worlds we had to go through the ISU system and credentials were denied.
 
I'm not sure Ward would be at competitions to ask victims of abuse anything?

I think she would be there to question the skating organizations (Skate Canada, Skate America, ISU, TPTB) about what they are doing/planning to do to address this?

I think this is why she didn't get accreditation. The organizations don't want to answer any questions.
She can always ask the questions outside of competition, and they can always decline to answer.

This is an altogether different situation from, say, attending the top three skaters' press conference after the Short Program, where the precise moment and mindset can never be recaptured.
 
Last edited:
I have been credentialled for events, and I have no negative opinions about Lori Ward, but it isn't practical to have a journalist in the mixed zone asking, for example, I-AM ice dancers about their opinions on Sorensen and/or how they feel sharing the ice with
F-B/Cizeron. It has already become difficult to move skaters through the mixed zone efficiently, due partly to the newer (not so new anymore) form of journalism emphasizing social media with photos/short video clips -- journalists wanting their own photos of skaters, with and without team jackets, posing for "silly" photos, asking questions about their favorite foods, etc., rather than "What happened on the twizzles?" None of that is wrong, but it is time-consuming. That's why ISU is "cracking down" on credentials.
 
Accreditations are granted by the ISU so reporters can, well, report about the competitions and promote the sport. It's free promotion, it costs them only a plastic card and a laniard. Ward doesn't want to cover the competitions and report about them. I'm a subscriber to her blog and she definitely does a fantastic and essential job. But that's really not a job you do at skating events. A competition is not the right place nor time for this.
In talking about this with someone else who gets credentialed for these events, they suggested that this is the most likely reason Ward didn't get credentialed (that she doesn't report on events). However they also support her in her efforts to get credentialed.
 
It was always all done through the ISU, it hasn't changed. I get my credentials for Grand Prix de France from the ISU not FFSG. But national federations have their say in the matter, they review accreditation requests (it's the job of the competition official press officer who is not necessarily a member of the skating fed but who acts as a coordinator) before the ISU gives its OK. There are always some local or regional media that goes directly to skating feds, generally because they don't know how to proceed or because they wake up past the deadline for requests. In this case the fed has to submit the request to the ISU anyway. Feds are the 1st filter, ISU is the second.
It actually changed for us, in the past for Skate Canada international we dealt with our national federation but now all applications go through the ISU. Just for the internationals, not for the domestic competitions. Previous years we just dealt with the national federation? Apparently it is the same for Skate America now? But I don't have first hand experience with that, just what I was told.
 
I've been in Skate Canada media rooms and mixed zones where the journalists are shoulder-to-shoulder, sometimes trading off and sharing power outlets and seats with colleagues because there's not enough space. Skate Canada often holds events in smaller arenas that don't have much back-of-house room. US arenas are often a bit bigger, but I've been in some pretty packed media rooms in the U.S. as well. I don't know either of these venues specifically, but I can't blame either organization for prioritizing media that's doing more traditional event coverage.
This was painfully true for Skate Canada in the Hanyu era, not sure if it is still a big issue.
 
In talking about this with someone else who gets credentialed for these events, they suggested that this is the most likely reason Ward didn't get credentialed (that she doesn't report on events). However they also support her in her efforts to get credentialed.
I believe this is true, as someone who gets credentialed if I was just doing my typical published articles I won't get credentialed for Skate Canada or other competitions as I'm not actually reporting on the competition event itself. However, if I am specifically working for/with our skating organization (last year I was helping with the press conferences etc, or interviewing after their skate) then I can get credentialed. So I immediately thought perhaps that is why Lori didn't get credentialed as she typically isn't in the press interviews reporting on the event itself.. if that makes sense?
 
I believe this is true, as someone who gets credentialed if I was just doing my typical published articles I won't get credentialed for Skate Canada or other competitions as I'm not actually reporting on the competition event itself. However, if I am specifically working for/with our skating organization (last year I was helping with the press conferences etc, or interviewing after their skate) then I can get credentialed. So I immediately thought perhaps that is why Lori didn't get credentialed as she typically isn't in the press interviews reporting on the event itself.. if that makes sense?
Correct, Lori wasn't credentialed because what she writes about doesn't require mixed zone and press conference interviews at events. When applying, journalists must attach recent articles to their request, along with links to their social media. It is plain that Lori's work relates to off-ice issues. To get interviews, she has to approach coaches individually or go through federations to request interviews with current skaters. Obviously, she is free and capable of asking retired skaters for interviews. Again, not saying this is right or wrong, but it's the rule.
 
In talking about this with someone else who gets credentialed for these events, they suggested that this is the most likely reason Ward didn't get credentialed (that she doesn't report on events). However they also support her in her efforts to get credentialed.
The fact I think she does not need to be accredited for the work she does does not mean I don't support her efforts to be. If that makes any sense...

In her article on the subject, she said she had been asked by the ISU to provide past work. We are all asked to provide past work each and every year even when we've been there for ages. I tend to avoid providing links to anything controversial. I don't consider Ward's work controversial stricto sensu, she reports what she sees or is told first hand, but the ISU and the feds certainly don't see it that way. Sports federations are often monolitic monsters that scare easily when you start digging the dirt they keep on sweeping under the rug. And as much as they all talk about safety measures regarding athletes they still haven't the means to enforce them correctly (when it's not just a facade of hypocrisy to look reasonably concerned while not giving a crap). They are clearly not going to give you a shovel to lift the rug. That's of course not something I condone, all the opposite, but that's a fact.

To get interviews, she has to approach coaches individually or go through federations to request interviews with current skaters. Obviously, she is free and capable of asking retired skaters for interviews. Again, not saying this is right or wrong, but it's the rule.
At competitions, you can request interviews via the ISU app or with contacting the press officers who will pass the requests to team leaders. But AFAIK there is no rule prohibiting you to approach skaters on your own. I do it all the time because the ISU people a d/or team leaders are sometimes slow to answer as they have their hands full. Out of skating events, if you manage to get skaters' contact details, you can by-pass all go-betweens. I'm certain Lori Ward knows how to do that.
 
Last edited:
I almost always had to do so with USFS -- and in some cases, you'll then be directed to take it a step further and communicate via an agent (which sometimes results in requests being rejected) -- but tbh, many of my interviews over the years, including my last few, have come via direct contact, especially once I've forged a working relationship with an athlete or coach.
 
USFS wants requests to go through its communications people, and when I last worked with Skate Canada, it did, too.
It changed this year for skate Canada. It’s direct to the ISU, unlike previous years.
 
It's just wrong that journalists were told not to ask certain questions when it's very much a matter of interest to the sport and the public.

I disagree that a competition is the wrong time for it. Insisting on another time is just a way to protect wrondoers. I'm not a huge fan of Christine Brennan's but at least she isn't serving as a mouthpiece for TPTB.

As for the skaters, if you want to commit sexual assault and try to dodge the consequences, be prepared for some tough questions. And if skaters want to make public statements in support of that person through the safety of a paid documentary, then be prepared for some tough questions.

You seem to be misunderstanding the fact that some people in the mixed zone will be victims. To be clear, do you think it's fine to interrogate victims in the mixed zone and publicly retraumatize them because you think not doing so only protects wrongdoers???
 
You seem to be misunderstanding the fact that some people in the mixed zone will be victims. To be clear, do you think it's fine to interrogate victims in the mixed zone and publicly retraumatize them because you think not doing so only protects wrongdoers???
I'm not misunderstanding anything. To be clear, your belief that Lori Ward wants to interrogate victims about their sexual abuse in the mixed zone is absurd.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top