Broken Ice investigation on underage drinking and lack of supervision in skating

Are there any mandates out there for reporting incidents where minors are inebriated? The examples given in the piece linked in Post #1 apparently have nothing to do with sexual assault. Alcohol abuse by minors is its own problem and deserves to be addressed as such. I am not sure, however, that mandatory reporting requirements are going to do very much even if they do exist, especially when the only witnesses are other teenage skaters.
Sexual assault is mentioned in Lori's piece; it just wasn't in the excerpt I posted.
 
How exactly is any authority to stop someone from sneaking out to a party, or drinking or the sexual assaults that often follow the drinking? Lock skaters in their rooms? Put ankle bracelets on them so their movements can be monitored? As the article and skaters have said, the parties typically occur after the competition is over. We've all seen multiple hungover skaters in exhibitions. Their parents are not in the same hotel and not in the same room. Chaperones aren't going to stay up all night sitting outside hotel rooms to make sure everybody is where they're assigned. Making consequences after the fact will stop those who weren't likely to get plastered at a party to begin with and not those determined to do so and two drinks could be enough for a tiny 13 yo girl. The only thing that would have stopped Coughlin was Coughlin himself.
 
Room checks at curfew to start. Even professional sports teams have curfews, at least at times. They event organizers can put security guards physically on hallways between curfew and when curfews are listed. Many hotels have security camera already, so it would mean monitoring.

If that 13-year-old has two drinks, they’ve already violated the most minimum rules whether they weigh 80 or 160 lbs, and they should not be accepted into any ISU competition or competition that counts for minimums or World Standings points for a suspension period.
 
I appreciate this article, as well as the input from others about feds rules, etc. There have been far too many SA incidences from after parties. Terrifying, especially that so many skaters are below legal age.
 
If a parent is really not allowed to stay in a hotel room with their teenager (I'm thinking of the younger end of the JGP age group like 13-16yo), then there have to be clear boundaries and someone needs to be responsible for supervision. It's one thing if a child willfully circumvents the boundaries, it's another if the adults do not have proper boundaries in place. It's been a long time since I was a teen on a trip with peers, but I traveled every year with band from grade 6 to grade 12, and I remember curfews, room checks, and chaperones camped out in the hallways. My mom never would have let me go without knowing how I was to be supervised. I wasn't the type to try sneaking out of the hotel, but I definitely tried sneaking to a friend's room and got caught and sent back to my room.
 
If a parent is really not allowed to stay in a hotel room with their teenager (I'm thinking of the younger end of the JGP age group like 13-16yo), then there have to be clear boundaries and someone needs to be responsible for supervision.
Parents can stay in the same hotel -- if they can get a room. But they can't stay in the same room as their skaters. Often, hotels aren't big, and once ISU books rooms for skaters/team leaders, etc., the hotel is fully booked. So the next option for parents is to stay at the officials'/coaches' hotel (which can be a 20-30 min drive from the skaters' hotel), or find a hotel in the area.

For USFS, team leaders supervise the kids, making sure they are on the bus to get to the rink and checking that they are where they are supposed to be (practice ice, competition, etc.). Remember, a team leader may be supervising up to 16 kids per JGP. I know an instance where a team leader frantically messaged one skater on WhatsApp when they couldn't reach them as the shuttle was about to leave for the rink, only to find the skater oversleeping (and no, that skater didn't drink, just the usual teen habit of oversleeping and the alarm didn't go off).

The skaters have been given clear instructions prior to departure, during the team briefings onsite at the hotel, about what they can and cannot do. They have been made to sign forms that they understand the conduct expected of them. But supervision doesn't mean standing by their doors or on the floor to make sure the kids don't go out at night or that what they do inside the room doesn't violate any rules. Should ISU or organizing fed start installing guards on every floor of the hotel, or a guard by the door?

But this is USFS, where they have clear, established procedures and a team to supervise the skaters. Some smaller feds may not have the infrastructure or budget to send a team leader, medic, and Safesport personnel to oversee their skaters.
 
I'd have three suggestions. 1 - ensure that enough rooms are booked that all chaperones/coaches stay at the same hotels, on the same floors. sure, very determined skaters will still drink and party, but it will put a cramp in some plans.

two, a lot of the partying comes from boredom. organize actually fun events after the competition is over for the kids to take part in - laser tag, trampoline, whatever - the more tired the kids get from fun, safe activities the better.

and finally, and most importantly, ensure the consequences of sexual abuse are enforced. the kids, even if they're the second coming of michelle kwan, be reported to the authorities and kicked off the team while the case is being investigated. if they're over the age of majority, and they go to jail, so be it. safety is more important.
 
1 - ensure that enough rooms are booked that all chaperones/coaches stay at the same hotels, on the same floors. sure, very determined skaters will still drink and party, but it will put a cramp in some plans.
Good idea, but the sheer number of skaters, team leaders/chaperones/fed officials, medics, coaches, and parents makes it hard to find a hotel that can fit everyone in one place.

In Gdansk, for example, the official hotel has 151 guest rooms, which is enough for only the skaters and chaperones, including medics and fed officials. Remember, some JGPs have at least 150 skaters.

ISU will need to find locations willing to host a JGP with hotels large enough to accommodate everyone involved, including parents—which realistically is extremely hard.
 
Good idea, but the sheer number of skaters, team leaders/chaperones/fed officials, medics, coaches, and parents makes it hard to find a hotel that can fit everyone in one place.

In Gdansk, for example, the official hotel has 151 guest rooms, which is enough for only the skaters and chaperones, including medics and fed officials. Remember, some JGPs have at least 150 skaters.

ISU will need to find locations willing to host a JGP with hotels large enough to accommodate everyone involved, including parents—which realistically is extremely hard.

They don’t have to fit everyone in the same hotel. They need to house each team together in a hotel with chaperones.
 
As @PRlady and @rfisher stated, it's a game for those less than 21 to sneak out. And for those to gain alcohol. I didn't try it, but wow did my band classmates do it successfully.

Having a competitor sign a document they will not drink is about as effective as the D.A.R.E. contracts prevalent in the 80's and 90's. They can be disregarded the first opportunity.

Current practice by my granddaughter's show choir is to tape the hotel room doors shut at curfew. Supposedly to determine if anyone leaves the room.

Just like any efforts to stop sneaking out - it can be done. Say a 21+ competitor obtains a roll of said tape. Once the party is over - the 21+ person puts new tape in place.

I'm sure many know that alcohol intoxication to the point of passed out is so individual. One 13 yr levels may not be the same as another 13 yr.

I don't know what the answer is - but ISU and Federations need to be realistic to the success of efforts
 
:huh: That's it?!
I don't understand the “That's it?!” response. You're quoting one bullet from a two-page Tips for Parents handout, not SafeSport's entire travel policy. That same page recommends trained chaperones, approximately one chaperone per 5–8 athletes for larger groups, chaperones staying near 14–18-year-olds and checking them regularly, curfews, hotel common-area rules, misconduct-prevention training and post-trip debriefing.

And the actual MAAPP (Minor Athlete Abuse Prevention Policies) lodging rules https://maapp.uscenterforsafesport.org/ are separate and considerably more detailed. They regulate adult/minor hotel arrangements, one-on-one interactions, training, parental consent and room checks.

If the argument is that JGP supervision should be stronger, that's worth discussing. But simply posting one sentence from a parent tip sheet and saying “That's it?!” doesn't establish that SafeSport has no meaningful safeguards.

And I'm genuinely curious what people think should happen beyond this. If minors have a curfew, responsible adults nearby, regular checks and appropriate chaperone ratios, what additional supervision are people proposing? Someone stationed outside every hotel room all night? At some point there also has to be a realistic distinction between reasonable safeguarding and physically preventing teenagers from ever breaking a rule.
 
I don't understand the “That's it?!” response. You're quoting one bullet from a two-page Tips for Parents handout, not SafeSport's entire travel policy. That same page recommends trained chaperones, approximately one chaperone per 5–8 athletes for larger groups, chaperones staying near 14–18-year-olds and checking them regularly, curfews, hotel common-area rules, misconduct-prevention training and post-trip debriefing.
One chaperone per 5-8 athletes is inexcusable. The Masonic youth groups I've worked with over the years require a minimum of 1 chaperone of the same sex per 5 youth and a minimum of 2 chaperones for groups of any size. I'm shocked that SafeSport doesn't have a stricter standard for the number of chaperones.
 
@marshallpond It’s not just JGP events. It’s also domestic competitions and other international competitions, including Senior events. A seventeen-year-old is just as capable of inducing alcohol poisoning on herself as a fourteen-year-old. And alcohol poisoning can be deadly.
 
That is what is currently happening, and has been happening for years

HOTEL 1 = skaters + chaperones + medics
HOTEL 2 = officials + coaches

What I’m saying is that each countries team does not need to be in the same hotel. Parents booking in the same hotel is more critical than team Japan and team USA being in the same hotel.

And I'm genuinely curious what people think should happen beyond this. If minors have a curfew, responsible adults nearby, regular checks and appropriate chaperone ratios, what additional supervision are people proposing? Someone stationed outside every hotel room all night? At some point there also has to be a realistic distinction between reasonable safeguarding and physically preventing teenagers from ever breaking a rule.

If teenagers are sneaking out, drinking, and getting assaulted under the current safeguarding, it is not adequate. Full stop. If this cannot be prevented with any amount of supervision than the events themselves shouldn’t be happening.

I obviously am not saying to cancel the junior Grand Prix. But if it was literally true that the junior Grand Prix presents an opportunity for teenagers under the supervision of the figure skating Federation to get drunk and there is nothing that could CONCEIVABLY be done about it, then I would say it’s an unsafe situation to exist.

In actuality, I’m quite sure there is a solution to this other than throwing our hands in the air.
 
If teenagers are sneaking out, drinking, and getting assaulted under the current safeguarding, it is not adequate. Full stop. If this cannot be prevented with any amount of supervision than the events themselves shouldn’t be happening.
Maybe it's not the current level of safeguarding that's the problem. Maybe it's the culture of the sport, and the unofficial induction into it that the teenagers receive a long time before they attend any international competitions.

Of course, that's much harder to address, and asks a lot more of the sport itself.
 
If a parent is really not allowed to stay in a hotel room with their teenager (I'm thinking of the younger end of the JGP age group like 13-16yo), then there have to be clear boundaries and someone needs to be responsible for supervision. It's one thing if a child willfully circumvents the boundaries, it's another if the adults do not have proper boundaries in place. It's been a long time since I was a teen on a trip with peers, but I traveled every year with band from grade 6 to grade 12, and I remember curfews, room checks, and chaperones camped out in the hallways. My mom never would have let me go without knowing how I was to be supervised. I wasn't the type to try sneaking out of the hotel, but I definitely tried sneaking to a friend's room and got caught and sent back to my room.
As the parent of a skater who competed internationally in the early 2000s from the time she was a preteen, I can tell you that the US did not let parents stay in the room or travel with their child. I can also tell you that some coaches discouraged parents from tagging along, and USFSA didn't exactly promote the idea either. I remember at Junior Worlds, we barely saw our daughter all three times she competed. One year, parents were in a hotel across town from the skaters. The last time she competed at Junior Worlds, she was 17, and there was a serious drinking incident that I found out about later.
 
Anyone have Johnny Weir's memoir? IIRC, he shared his recollections of off-ice activities at the 2001 World Junior Championships that he won.

ETA: I do believe that "those days" and what's happening in the the present day on the JGP/Junior Worlds is more regulated by some federations, like USFS (as already described in this thread).
 
Last edited:
Anyone have Johnny Weir's memoir? IIRC, he shared his recollections of off-ice activities at the 2001 World Junior Championships that he won.

ETA: I do believe that "those days" and what's happening in the the present day on the JGP/Junior Worlds is more regulated by some federations, like USFS (as already described in this thread).
Still not enough. Skaters under 18 should be required to stay with a parent or next door to a coach or chaperone. I heard that going back thirty years or more, skaters were tightly monitored, including their conduct and even how they dressed. Breaking even one rule could keep you from your next international competition. These kids are competitive. Most wouldn't risk the consequences for a night out on the town.
 
Still not enough. Skaters under 18 should be required to stay with a parent or next door to a coach or chaperone. I heard that going back thirty years or more, skaters were tightly monitored, including their conduct and even how they dressed. Breaking even one rule could keep you from your next international competition. These kids are competitive. Most wouldn't risk the consequences for a night out on the town.
I think that's rather extreme and, speaking as a longtime chaperone for youth group conventions, that expectation is highly unusual but it also depends on the size of each delegation. Most youth are housed with each other and the parents/family members/chaperones are housed on the same floor. I shared a hotel room with one of my nieces exactly once during the 15 years of active chaperoning I did - and she was 18 at the time and the only reason we shared a room was because all of the other kids in her local club were 17 & under, so she wasn't allowed to share a room with any of them due to the youth protection policies most of these groups now have in place.

There aren't any easy answers and I've seen situations where our group's convention housing coordinator worked diligently with the hotel staff to ensure that each local group/delegation were housed together in blocks of rooms only to arrive at the hotel & discover, upon registration, that the hotel had turned around and split the delegation up with rooms on different floors, etc, but it does feel like, at minimum, the ISU needs to find a way to ensure that federations can book enough rooms for not just the skaters+chaperones+team officials but also the parents at the same hotel, even if that means more than one hotel for this purpose.
 
I think that's rather extreme and, speaking as a longtime chaperone for youth group conventions, that expectation is highly unusual but it also depends on the size of each delegation. Most youth are housed with each other and the parents/family members/chaperones are housed on the same floor. I shared a hotel room with one of my nieces exactly once during the 15 years of active chaperoning I did - and she was 18 at the time and the only reason we shared a room was because all of the other kids in her local club were 17 & under, so she wasn't allowed to share a room with any of them due to the youth protection policies most of these groups now have in place.

There aren't any easy answers and I've seen situations where our group's convention housing coordinator worked diligently with the hotel staff to ensure that each local group/delegation were housed together in blocks of rooms only to arrive at the hotel & discover, upon registration, that the hotel had turned around and split the delegation up with rooms on different floors, etc, but it does feel like, at minimum, the ISU needs to find a way to ensure that federations can book enough rooms for not just the skaters+chaperones+team officials but also the parents at the same hotel, even if that means more than one hotel for this purpose.
I was at the events. I saw what happened on the JGP circuit. These athletes are not like regular kids. First, it's a wide age range. I think the age range now is 13 to 23? It was 13 to 21 when my daughter competed. The first year or two, my daughter was immune to it. She would tell me stories that you wouldn't believe. Later, she got involved. I only found out about that from coaches and other parents. Second, these kids work their buts off year-round. Many of them have little or no time to let loose. So, when they do, it is epic. Finally, they are representing their country even at a JGP. I have heard of judges having opinions about skaters based on seeing them throwing up outside the hotel at 2 am. When my daughter was searching for a new partner, a judge told her not to skate with one particular young man because of his party-boy personality at competitions.
 
I shudder imagining a young Tonya Harding and her mother sharing a hotel room at a JGP event overseas (or at any competition, for that matter).:yikes:
They live with their parents all the other days of the year. The rules can't be made based on the quality of the parent.
 
I don’t think just putting parents in the same hotel is necessarily the solution. In some of the non-skating-related group supervision stories I’ve heard, it’s the parents who were the suppliers/enablers. Like in one memorable story where a drill team managed to set their rented accommodation on fire after parents had given them alcohol. You know, the teenage girls had worked hard and deserved to cut loose. Well, until they burned the building down.
 
I don’t think just putting parents in the same hotel is necessarily the solution. In some of the non-skating-related group supervision stories I’ve heard, it’s the parents who were the suppliers/enablers. Like in one memorable story where a drill team managed to set their rented accommodation on fire after parents had given them alcohol. You know, the teenage girls had worked hard and deserved to cut loose. Well, until they burned the building down
 
They live with their parents all the other days of the year. The rules can't be made based on the quality of the parent.
If the ISU or federations are relying on the parents to supervise other people’s children, then it matters. If it was just every kid stays with their own parent, then that’s a different story (and would probably be prohibitively expensive).
 
Like in one memorable story where a drill team managed to set their rented accommodation on fire after parents had given them alcohol. You know, the teenage girls had worked hard and deserved to cut loose. Well, until they burned the building down.
Yipe!
 
Wow, didn't think of that. But they need to be very close to their coach and/or have many more chaperones. And rules with consequences. This thread talks about alcohol, but there was also a lot of sexual interaction that may not have broken laws, but it was not age appropriate either.
 
They live with their parents all the other days of the year. The rules can't be made based on the quality of the parent.
A rule that forces a teenager to stay in a hotel room overseas with an abusive parent is not a rule worth having.

As has been explained upthread, JGP competitors cannot get out and explore the host city on their own. Even with an abusive parent, most teenagers can find some time to be alone when they are on their home town.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top