Discussion in 'The Trash Can' started by martyross, Dec 8, 2012.
Guys, did Radio Canada showed CSOI already?
No it's Sunday at 3h00 pm.
Hi, where can I watch all ex event? I thought, adress was posted there, but I can't find it
Ioana posted it awhile back, but here it is: http://russiasport.ru/user/226/node/8413.
This wonderful lady took some really great pics of T/S at the gpf gala: http://mimishka007.livejournal.com/58761.html. Just click spoiler (click to open) to see all of the pics.
I couldn't help but notice how well toned Tessa's arms are. She is so buff, but still very womanly..........lovely.
Wow. I love how V/M have so many camera-perfect moments. Those pictures were amazing.
i know im being nitpicky, but there is one thing that i would like tessa to improve on--her fingers. tessa has very graceful and expressive arms, gordeeva arms, but sometimes her fingers dont flow with the rest of her arms. i wish she could have katia's flowing fingers consistently. i know i have brought this up before, and it's still something that bothers me that she does sometimes. someone here mentioned before that the flow stops at her wrists, whereas with katia, the flow comes from her core to her arms, to the tips of her fingers (to paraphrase what i remembered).
I feel the same about Tessa's hands. I don't know the proper way to describe this, but when she holds her arms up, she often times has her hands in kind of a closed position that breaks the line completely for me. I can't find an exact picture to describe what I'm talking about, but something along these lines:
The way her fingers are stuck together puts a sudden stop to the elegance that the rest of their bodies carry. & perhaps it's more appropriate for the tango piece, but I've seen it in practically all of their programs. I'm extremely nit-picky, so this is probably something that I just have a problem with. I don't think I've seen Meryl or Maia with similar hand motions as often. I wondered if it was a Zoueva technique.
there are skaters who I could only *wish* had Tessa's arms -- buff and graceful and expressive. That such expression doesn't extend all the way to her fingertips -- that I can live with. When I see other skaters attempts at being graceful through the arms, well I almost shudder sometimes. And no, this is not a slam at any particular skater(s) in particular.
I like the way she uses her arms and fingers, particularly in-between holds. I don't know, I feel she groups her fingers gracefully and accordingly. She places her hands ever so gently on Scott's shoulders, she doesn't grab him as others do. Her hands are big so maybe that's why you guys feel she doesn't extend her fingers as well? I don't know, I just saw them in Hallelujah and I was noticing that she's even more graceful these days than, say, a year ago? Which you wouldn't think possible. So, yeah, I don't know.
I see absolutely nothing wrong with how she manages her hands/fingers. With her ballet training, all that would have been instilled in her from an early age. I think her hands and wonderful arms are very expressive and add detail to whatever emotion they endeavour to display. Perhaps I'm not nitpicky enough.
OMG, feel like i am on GS now
I think you feel free to watch on ideal Meryl and let Tessa along, please
So, Radio Canada will show CSOI today? Cant wait to see full version.
Totally agree. Its not she does have the bad extension, line or toe point of some other dancers!
yes, you guys arent nitpicky enough
like i said, she has VERY GRACEFUL AND EXPRESSIVE ARMS. did i say ANYWHERE that she has bad lines and extension? im just pointing out one little thing that i feel that tessa needs to work on more, and then you guys blow it up as if im saying she has terrible lines. i just cant help but compare her to gordeeva (similar balletic lines and grace, same choreographer) who i think has the best hand expressions in the business even though she's not an ice dancer.
I don't think anyone blew anything out of proportion, we just disagreed with you, and it's ok to do that I would assume
i know not all would agree, especially the ubers, but like some have replied it's like im saying that tessa has bad lines and extension, and no toe point at all, when all im pointing out are her hands for goodness sake. and did i say anywhere that it's NOT OK to disagree?
Honestly is nothing personal. Just disagreement in one point. At least this is uber thread
My reaction was so strong, just because i just read GS and were angry on what people are saying about V-M
and just because it's an uber thread, we can't put out constructive criticisms?
well i guess not
No, but i hope we will not come to "fat Tessa" in this thread soon And maybe i dont like this, because all about D-W is perfection.
I didnt pay so much attention to Tessas fingers, so maybe i need to pay more attention to this. Sometime i noticed Scott hand not such great, like Tessas. For example in SD, where Tessas hands in 5 position, but Scott not look like ballet dancer But in my opinion - its compare to Tessa, but not to other guys, who didnt pay attention to this at all.
c'mon, pani, you're assuming again that im comparing tessa to meryl, someone else did. can you read my posts again? did i even mention meryl in my posts about this? i just mentioned katia gordeeva.
it's just that tessa's expressions in soft, mellow programs like hallelujah remind me of katia's in programs like vocalise, and the softer programs tend to highlight the little details more. and because of katia's images in vocalise that make me find tessa's hand expressions a bit distracting sometimes.
I don't see the need to include D/W in this conversation other than to stir the pot, so let's just not.
Of course we can, it's just that the ubers' protective instincts come out when the constructive criticism coincides with a load of nasty criticism going on in other parts of the web.
I'm another one who hasn't noticed anything wrong about Tessa's hands. I absolutely love the way she uses her arms in both programs this season, and in Carmen especially.
That doesn't mean, however, that different opinions can't be expressed.
I know, i just try to explane my reaction on criticism =s in this thread.
Like i said before, maybe i need to pay more attention to Tessas fingers.
And i wish T-S will use Vocalise for OG. With some modern choreo from Swan
I think they will change this lift before Nationals.
Honestly i like original SS more - it better going with music and get level 3, like news one. Nut they have team arround them who know better, what they need to do.
I actually think we spend a lot of time criticizing V&M and their work here, much more than in other threads around the site. Last year we did nothing BUT criticize their programs
This year many have expressed the thought they need to tighten up the concept of their SD and wondered about the final choreographic lift (whether they should persevere or find something just as suitable artistically that would work).
It seems to me one of the problems is people questioning the motives of what people are posting here which I think has a lot to do with the tone and negativity V&M are getting at goldenskate. I don't read there regularly so not sure the whole hand thing is a topic over there but I have read it before somewhere. Regardless the bias over there is so strong and negative that I think if you do feel sensitive you should probably avoid it until April 2014 But as zilam said, the hand thing is a petty nitpick that it shouldn't be anything for anyone to get upset about. And I don't think that three posters disagreeing with you is also something to get upset about
Thats what i try to say And i try find place, where i could relax and didnt read all that negative posts about V-M.
Its funny, that at GS you could post everything about V-M, but nothing bad about there rivals
Could someone give me link to Radio Canada translation? I thought CSOI must be shown now...
Am watching CSOI on the web now (Radio Canada). Love it.