Simon Reed is indeed the one who seems clueless sometimes (mostly because he doesn't really get the judging system). but he's also the unabashed V/M fan among them. Chris Howarth (former British singles champion) and Nicky Slater usually have valid opinions, and well-argumented, even if you agree with them or not. My only reproach towards them is that they seem to go with the current flow and be easily impressed by frantic skating over elegant, finished moves, by skaters who play to the crowd/project outwards over those who really apply their skating skills to dance. And this goes for the other disciplines as well.