1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Hi all! No longer will threads be closed after 1000 (ish) messages. We may close if one gets so long to cause an issue and if you would like a thread closed to start a new one after a 1000 posts then just use the "Report Post" function. Enjoy!

Vaitsehovskaya's Tuesday interview -with Maxim Shabalin

Discussion in 'Great Skate Debate' started by TAHbKA, Jun 17, 2010.

  1. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    I would bring back the Russian coaches back to Russia

    When I asked the Olympic bronze medalist Maxim Shabalin what is he doing he replied : `resting'. A day later his status had changed - he became part of the committee of the Russian Ice Skating Federation. That's what we started the talk with.

    Vancouver's bronze is controversial.

    V: Maxim, during the conference you had a change to see the inside processes of the figure skating. Would you like to become an insider of that?
    MS: In order to answer your question I would have to be part of those processes for a while. I was merely a viewer in the conference. It was breathtaking. For me even more so since everything was a new thing for me and before the elections I didn't even know who was to become the president and how things would develop from there.

    the translation to come....
  2. Hedwig

    Hedwig WoolSilk Fanatic

    We are waiting with baited breath! :cheer: Thanks, Tanya!!
  3. skatefan

    skatefan home in England

    Oh, very interesting Tanya!
  4. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    V: Do you find it awkward there are no young or even remotely young people in the Russian federation?
    MS: Not anymore. Oksana and I are there. I didn't even know I would elected, but when was asked during the conference whether I would be interested to hold such a position I said yes.

    V: Did you come to terms with the fact the sport is behind you?
    MS: Yes, and quite easily too. I even like it : finally I have free time and I can do things I never had time to do before. I visit the theatre frequently, for example. I would have clinged to the sport if there was a slightest chance, but with the state of my knees even talking of any chances is an absurd.

    V: Would you mind if your partner would have continued with another partner?
    MS: If only briefly.

    V: Do you dream of the Olympics still?
    MS: Not anymore. It was quite hard right after the games, mainly because of the uncertainty of the future. No one was calling, I didn't have to hurry anywhere... It's something I had to get used to.

    V: As you had to get used to the Olympic games result. I still find it hard to put into words what do I feel about your placement. I realize with the state of your legs the bronze was the best you could had hoped for. On the other hand it's not for the bronze you went to Vancouver..
    MS: No, not the bronze. Hence I have mixed feelings about the medal. It was a hard thing to get. From that perspective our participating the Olympics is a huge win. But we were going for the gold. We were fighting for the gold.

    V: Really?
    MS: Yes. It became clear we don't have a chance after the Original Dance.

    V: It is probably hard to be objective while in the middle of the competition compared to the outside glance. But let me remark: it was obvious for the outsiders that the first two places will be decided between the Canadians Virtue-Moir and the Americans Davis-White.
    MS: I disagree. Oh yes, the Canadians - they are brilliant and it's obvious, even though am not overwhelmed by their programmes. If Oxana and I didn't have to make changes in the programmes according to my leg's state I don't think Virtue/Moir had a chance to beat us. What the Americans showed doesn't look like and ice dance to me at all. I can only see the kids who are running fast across the ice and do some acrobatics. If I were a judge at the Original I would put them outside the top 3.

    V: I understand that in Vancouver the tactics decided with your partner and coaches was the same as in Tallinn during the Europeans: to make a big as possible margin between you and the others during the Compulsory dance and then just hold to it?
    MS: In a way - yes.

    European Medicine is more progressive than the American.

    V: Did you ever think during the time you suffered the injuries that participating the Europeans 2008 in Zagreb just a couple of days after the surgery was a terrible mistake?
    MS: Thousand times. And was really sorry I did. But it was too late to change anything.

    V: In all your interviews you insisted it was your idea to skate. I still can't believe you made such a decision without consulting the others.
    MS: It wasn't my first surgery. The first was on the other leg a year prior to that. That operation was a success but since I didn't have any experience I had no idea how important the meniscus is. It was way too late when I realized I didn't work as well as I should had on my knee after the surgery. But then I didn't even know quite how is it done. So I only recovered half a year after the surgery - in the autumn, when the season already began.
    I didn't have a clue that if one knee is injured all the pressure will be on the other knee. But I was facing the consequences quite fast: in Grand Prix Final that Oxana and I won I injured the other meniscus. I was hospitalized and after the surgery I had an impression the leg was far better than for the first time: a week after I could walk, step on that leg. This is why I started skating again so fast.

    V: And there was no one to stop you???
    MS: You probably imagine that someone was holding me back and I was fighting and willing to train? Not quite. The only one who told me I should pressure my leg in stages was the doctor who operated on me. But I didn't take his words seriously. First I thought everything was fine, but when the leg started hurting from all the pressure I didn't want to put all the hard work I've done in the drain. I thought I'll overcome the pain and nothing will happen to the leg.

    V: For some reason I thought the idea to participate those Europeans was Aleksey Gorshkov's - your then coach. And that it was the reason for your misunderstandings which at the end cause your and Oxana's departure to the USA to Linichuk's group. I also had an impression you were not eager to leave.
    MS: We reached the decision together with Oxana. It was tough. I knew quite well how will Gorshkov take the news. I knew how much he would be offended, that he shall listen to no reason and will stop talking to us altogether. Despite all that I also realized that I do not want to remain in Russia. I felt the change was needed. Some new ideas. After the third surgery when I came back on the ice to Odintsovo I felt I face that ice, those walls. It was all connected in my mind to a constant pain, problems, troubles. So we just left.

    V: Counting on what? The ever powerful American medicine?
    MS: That was too. But those illusions fast disappeared. I realized quite fast the European medicine is more progressive. In the USA the doctors are so worried about being sued that they don't dare trying anything new. They wait for the others to gain enough positive experience and only after that they would experiment. At least that's my impression.

    V: The Russian team doctors were not happy about your changing your lifestyle a couple of years before Vancouver. They even related all your injuries with your becoming a vegetarian : according to them the bones became weaker.
    MS: I think it's an exaggeration. I became interested in yoga and, as a result, became a vegetarian after the first surgery - I spent the summer in Elbrus in yoga seminar that I found about on the Internet. Though I've only been a vegetarian for 3 months - then I was checked into the hospital with an appendicitis and after that I felt that my body "wanted" meat. And well, there were the doctor's instructions.

    "Sometimes one gets tired with their partner"

    V: What did you gain in the 2 years you spent in the USA?
    MS: First of all the impression of the country. I improved my English alot and realized, I don't want to and will never want to live in the USA-

    V: Why?
    MS: Tough question. Let's put it that way : I would send my child to study in the USA. It's a positive experience. More than that, I would not try to convince him that living in the USA is a bad thing. I would allow him to make his own mind. But I would feel uncomfortable there. For example the lack of the sidewalks : you get out from the house and realize there is nothing to walk on.
    It was hard to come to terms with what people wear on the streets. I hated the way they communicate: for example it seems that the person is talking to you, but they are really hiding behind the usual smiles and the templates. And god forbid to answer `how are you?' with `bad'. It causes them panic, some sort of misunderstanding - how come `bad'?

    V: On the other hand it must had been hard to be with the same Russian speakers all the time?
    MS: Oxana and I are often asked about our good relationship. I repled: our secret is not seeing each other after the training and resting from each other.

    V: So you are familiar with a partner overdose state?
    MS: Of course. The same with the coaches overdose. When we just moved to the USA we met with Natalia Linichuk and her husband Gennady Karponosov and discussed the manner of our relationship. Gennady warned us not to expect becoming friends with them. They demanded a distance between the coaches and the skaters. The coach has sometimes to make the skater do things he doesn't really want to. When the coach is your friend you expect an understanding and support and get offended when that understanding and support are not provided.

    V: Were your relationship with Gorshkov different?
    MS: They were definitely more friendly.

    V: Were there times when you wanted to leave the sport?
    MS: Al lthe time. Especially during our first year in the USA. The leg was hurting all the time, we came in quite a state to the Europeans in Helsinki and I fell in the Compulsory Dance. Everyone were saying it's our end - the press, everyone.. It was a hard period.

    V: What did Linichuk said?
    MS: She supported us, was telling we are the best.

    V: And that was the feeling you went with to the worlds in Los Angeles?
    MS: More like fierce. And a will to prove we are not to be counted off yet.

    V: Who is more fierce: Oxana or you?
    MS: I would say Oxana is more about setting the goals and getting to them. In everything. The sport was more important for her. All and all we had always have a great understanding. During our skating career we had only had one fight when we first started skating together. Not even a fight, just near that. When the situation became close to shouting at each other one of us, I can't recall who just left. Since then we never had a fight.

    V: Even when someone made mistakes on the ice?
    MS: Even more so then. I have to admit when you are the one who does the mistake it feels horrible. I fell on the serious championships twice in my life and it's enough to understand what a nightmare it is.

    "No big changes are expected in the ice dance"

    V: Did you ever try to choreograph your programmes?
    MS: No, though I'd love to.

    V: What seems the most interesting in the ice dance next season?
    MS: I don't expect much changes. According to the judging of the first two couples in Turino no one can get anywhere close to them. The first and second places at the worlds are more or less decided now.
    I would love to see what will become of Hohlova/Fedorov. Am even more curious since I've never seen him on the ice. Am also clueless about the young Russian couples. When you skate yourself you simply don't have time to watch the others.

    V: You must had seen them during the competitions?
    MS: Of course. When it;s about the rivals I would try to see their skating, programmes, style, how well it is all executed. The experienced couples can "kill" even during the trainings.

    V: Did Oxana and you learn that as well?
    MS: Sure. Everything is counted : what to show in the training, how to show. We always beat with our confidence. Even though I couldn't do much with my leg.

    V: How did you train in such a state?
    MS: It's weird, but we trained in the USA much more than in Russia. Plus - the constant competition with the Americans Belbin/Agosto and then with the Italians Faella/scali. Working in such a company was, of course, hard, but very productive.

    V: Two times Olympic champion in Ice Dance Oxana Grischuk in her speach during the RSF said that all the coaches who train abroad should be brought back to Russia. What do you think about it?
    MS: If getting them back to Russia was within my powers I would try to do that. Everyone surrounding the good coaches learn from them and it's a shame that Linichuk, Shpilband, Zueva work abroad.

    V: Why don't you want to coach yourself?
    MS: May be I will one day. But right now I want to forget the ice. I don't want to put the skates on. It was too painful in the last two years
  5. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    Have to admit, am a bit :huh: of that interview....

    Is it considered a good taste among the Russian skaters to bash the USA? And I hope Shabalin's role in the Russian Skating Federation is not related to the ice dance. Am not sure whether REALLY there is anything in Virtue/Moir's or Davis/White's skating (I wouldn't know) but the judges obviously thing there is. If Shabalin can't see that - too bad....
    Rafter and (deleted member) like this.
  6. Bostonfan

    Bostonfan Well-Known Member

    To be fair, it's the reporters that love to bait their interviewees to "bash" the U.S. imo. What kind of question is, "The ever powerful American medicine?" Ah, biased much?

    But other than disagreeing with him about American medicine (I once had to have an emergency surgery in Spain, and it was a horrifying experience vs. my niece's 5 star experience at Children's Hospital in Boston), I don't mind what he says. He gives props to the schooling here. And I don't remember where he lived while he was here, but some places don't have sidewalks (although many cities and towns do). And he's absolutely spot on with our cultural "How are you?" habit. To an outsider, I can totally see where they consider this a real inquiry as opposed to the extended "Hi" greeting that it is. It's like saying "God bless you" after someone sneezes. It's a reflex.

    As far as his opinion about D&W, how is that any different than what every other Russian skater, judge, official has said about American teams in the past? It's a different style than the classic Russian style. I never take such comments seriously.
  7. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    Bostonfan, exactly that: while those comments were made by the Russian specialists of the older generations it was somehow understandable. I didn't expect such a remark from someone young and well, not so long ago in the sport. I.e. in the last couple of years Shabalin had no idea how the judging worked and what the young dancers do on the ice that is so different from what they did. And now he's to pass that to the current Russian skaters?
  8. pumba

    pumba New Member

    Thank you, TAHbKA! I always read your tranlsations with pleasure and really appreciate your hard work and SPEED!
    Not that I check each and every word, but I have read the original article first and was waiting for someone to translate exactly this part, so just a minor correction - your translation says - It was hard to come to terms with what people wear on the streets - but the original looks more like - It was hard to come to terms with people wearing slippers and shapeless garments on the streets - imho it is more hilarious and so true to life :rofl:! (maybe we have walked the same sidewalkless streets and talked to same people in the US:shuffle:)

    As for bashing the US skaters - he simply has his point of view which is quite commom btw (D/W = speed and tricks). Look what he says of V/M instead (calls them genius) - this means he sees things quite objectively. Anyway each time I read his interviews I see how intelligent he is.
  9. skatak

    skatak Well-Known Member

    Thanks for the translation ! Very interesting. poor guy, these past two years must have been really difficult, skating in pain... kuddos.
  10. IneZR

    IneZR New Member

    I always enjoy reading interviews with Russian skaters: they always speak their mind and you'll never hear from them politically correct answers.:lol:

    I wish Maxim all the best and hope that his knees heal completely.
  11. ostile17

    ostile17 Well-Known Member

    Here we are, already criticizing him before he even starts!
    Tell me something that I don't already know.... :rolleyes:
    He's a smart, young and very passionate guy, I'm sure he'll do a lot of good for his nation's sport!

    And since when is stating one's opinion bashing?

    All the best to him and Oksana for the new job! I'll miss seeing them on the ice...a lot!
  12. equatorial

    equatorial Well-Known Member

    I didn't see any US bashing there. He doesn't feel comfortable with the US culture. What's so bad about it? And he has the right to say what he wants about D/W. It's his personal opinion. Although this opinion is shared by quite a few people, some of whom are on this board ;)
  13. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member


  14. ostile17

    ostile17 Well-Known Member

    You seem to be using that a lot these days! :p

    Anyway, I apologize for forgetting to thank you for your translation in my previous post. Thanks!
  15. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    Lol, I think the usual confusion is assuming I like the skaters who are interviewed. Which is wrong, I actually like the interviewer (Vaitshovskaya. Think she is brilliant in the way she makes them talk and sound)
  16. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    Because the response to "How are you?" is "Hey, how's it going?"
    LadyNit and (deleted member) like this.
  17. newmember

    newmember New Member

    Has he ever praised any of his rivals though?
  18. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    Yes, in the interview above he calls Virtue/Moir genoius
  19. alilou

    alilou Crazy Stalker Lady

    TAHbKA thank you so much for this, and all your translations. I so appreciate it. It's one of the very wonderful things about FSU that thanks to people like you we get a glimpse behind the scenes of what's going on in non-English speaking countries. For people like me who only speak English it's a great bonus. :cheer2: TAHbKA :cheer2: FSU

    I didn't really see any USA bashing. He's living in a foreign country which I would guess doesn't really suit him, he's working extremely hard, he's in pain pretty much all the time. And yet he still can say good things about the country such as he would send his child to study there. Surely he's allowed his opinions, about both the US and ice dancing, without it being called bashing.

    I recently spent some time in Vietnam, and absolutely fell in love with the country and would go back in a heart beat, and yet one of our friends knows people who went there and absolutely hated it. People have different experiences. Given Max's work and health situation it's not surprising his time in the US was not all rosy.
  20. ostile17

    ostile17 Well-Known Member

    I never doubted that you liked Vaitshovskaya! :lol:
  21. Cloudy_Gumdrops

    Cloudy_Gumdrops New Member

    Thanks for the translation.

    I did get kinda annoyed with his comments about the United States, but then I got over it. I'm sure every skater who changes countries or just trains in a different country than their birth has the same kinds of thoughts; cultural differences and all. They just don't usually get asked those questions in their interviews.
  22. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    I feel the same about Davis and White! Why are they so fast? I don't like their speed.
  23. kwanfan1818

    kwanfan1818 I <3 Kozuka

    They sold their missing souls to the :EVILLE: for :gallopin1.
  24. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    Especially when trying to photograph! I always get the empty ice (though it happens with the local novices as well, so perhaps it's my photographing skills...... )
  25. oubik

    oubik Well-Known Member

    It´s opposite, your local novice skaters are so slow you haven´t enough patience waiting for them so long with the finger on the release :dog:

    Tan6ka, thanks for all your translations and hard work.
  26. ostile17

    ostile17 Well-Known Member

    He's actually saying Compulsory Dances (&#1086;&#1073;&#1103;&#1079;&#1072;&#1090;&#1077;&#1083;&#1100;&#1085;&#1099;&#1081; &#1090;&#1072;&#1085;&#1077;&#1094;) here, and not Original dance.
    So the correct version would be :
  27. TAHbKA

    TAHbKA Well-Known Member

    ostile17, you are right. Thanks for the correction (where is the `edit' button when you need one?)
  28. ostile17

    ostile17 Well-Known Member

    It vanishes after 24 hours...Poof!
  29. Fallcolor

    Fallcolor Member

    What an interesting interview...especially the comments on D/W ;)
  30. Domshabfan

    Domshabfan A proud P/C fan

    i agree with him, when he says that Russian skating federation needs evolution rather than evolution. Thanks for the translation TAHbKA.