1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Hi all! No longer will threads be closed after 1000 (ish) messages. We may close if one gets so long to cause an issue and if you would like a thread closed to start a new one after a 1000 posts then just use the "Report Post" function. Enjoy!

Survivor Philippines (Season 25)

Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by Catherine M, Aug 20, 2012.

  1. PeterG

    PeterG Well-Known Member

    I agree. People take pride in being honest and having integrity...and get kicked out pretty quick. But if you're going to make an a**hole move, own it. Let's face it, the a**holes are the ones who most often win these games, not those who "stayed true to themselves". :rolleyes: But for Jeff to say this move made him "manly" instead of a "proud liar" is what got to me.

    If you look at it from the point of view that Jeff is somewhat delusional, I can see the humour in that. I'm just looking forward to seeing his manly exit from the game. :D
  2. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    Finally! Got to see some other tribe dynamics instead of the pathetic lump that is the blue tribe.

    yellow is indeed interesting. I'm already over Abi. I think whoever asked if she has more male friends than female ones is right - she seems like someone who stays away from other women "because of the drama", but she's the one who causes ALL the drama :lol: Seeing RC trying to reason with her was funny...I feel bad for her, because she's got some strategy going on, and - forget Denise, RC was the freakin' ROCK STAR in the challenge - she took 3 consecutive trips. I can't believe no one else caught on how much time you save when the person doesn't have to get out of the water and tag out - but she hitched her wagon to the unstable drama girl who has fabricated a lack of trust to validate her own deception....I think the only way RC survives this is to get Abi out before the merge, and I don't know if that's possible now.

    And that kid - Pete? where did he come from? Interesting that he took Lisa aside and wants to keep her. Of course it's at the expense of Skupin and RC, but yes, I'd love for him to get the idol and hand it to Lisa :p Based on the very little we've heard from Artis, I can see why he hasn't gotten any air time.

    Good move by Penner to connect with Jeff, and just when I was starting to like Jeff he pulls that douchey "manly handshake pinky swear" crap. :rolleyes: Happy to see Dana also did well in the challenge, and her twin brother said something this ep, even though I immediately forgot what it was.

    OH BLUE TRIBE :wall:

    once again, a tale of three losers and poor Denise. Malcolm did fine at this challenge (tho not as well as Denise), but he's a much better whiner than competitor. Russell :wall: I was afraid he was going to faint into the water. He WAS right to point out that it's better to abandon what you're doing and go back so someone else can try to catch up, but the way he did it was so weird it was almost ineffective. But Angie is just too immature for this game. And it's not just her age...she is just too immature to know anything about what giving it your all really is. And I would swear that she did say she couldn't do it when her turn came again, but whatever. I'm glad she's gone, and continue to hope Denise finds some way to stay in this game for the long haul.
  3. BaileyCatts

    BaileyCatts Well-Known Member


    I would LOVE for this to happen!!!

    Wish they would have gotten rid of Russell. He's even more useless than Angie. I would have hung on to Angie one more week and hope for some kind of merge into two teams.

    Man I hate it when I have to catch up on my shows and miss the commentary until I have watched. :lol:
  4. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    Indeed, that was all but overlooked in the edit - did her team even notice??

    And I did wonder about that strategy, in fact I was surprised that you could pick and choose who went - would have been nice if they explained that, no?

    For Russell's second disastrous try, I'm pretty sure Denise was ready to go and he insisted - I don't know why they didn't just have Denise go several times in a row with the tag up, because she was clearly very, very fast and could have caught up.

    Angie would have been good past merge, because she seems nice and loyal and would have likely stayed true to Malcolm and Denise, without even realizing she was third wheel in the alliance. Although why they think Russell is the better challenge bet is beyond me - he clearly has zero endurance, plus is continual bad judgement and lack of team is a huge liability.

    I wonder if they lose again, if they will just split Malcolm and Denise with the other two tribes? If Russell finds the HI, it will be a crime if one of those two goes instead. Malcolm and Denise better smarten up and get on that.
  5. smurfy

    smurfy Well-Known Member

    As much as tonight's show outcome was predictable, it was pretty entertaining.
    Oh Russell - what an arrogant ass! So glad you are gone.
    And after a TC where all 3 were nice to each other, he doesn't even say good bye. Even Angie had a more mature exit.
    Malcolm - is almost too good to be true. For such a young guy, besides being cute, social and physically capable is smart and very aware of his surroundings. Hope he goes far. And Denise is still awesome.
    Malcolm and Denise have a real alliance, it will be interesting to see how it progresses. If they are split up and survive to the merge - could be awesome.
    And some action in the other tribes....
    Abi & RC - being played by Pete (?) or whatever his name. Hee hee. And Lisa will provide extra oxygen for those 2 girls to get themselves voted out. Lisa just seems like a sweetie.
    Interesting developments with the guys vs girls on Penner's tribe. Don't remember seeing Carter before tonight. Jeff's baseball skills got themin 2nd!
  6. Fridge_Break

    Fridge_Break #HotMessExpress

    Soooo glad rASSell is gone! One veteran down! I think Denise & Malcolm may be one of my favorite pairings we've had in recent memory. I sooo hope they can survive to the merge together. I'm betting there's going to be some sort of tribal mix-up next week, my betting would be that each tribe will get one of Malcolm and Denise, but who knows.

    :respec: for Denise being the only woman participating in the challenge and holding her own. She's a rockstar. I read a tweet tonight from Janelle (Big Brother) and she said something along the likes of, "Malcolm has to throw a ball against a former baseball player... how is this fair?!" :lol: I never thought of that until I read her tweet, it'd make sense for Jeff to step up and do the throwing on his tribe. But there's still no mention of people recognizing him? Then again 2/3 of their tribe is completely invisible, so.. who knows.
  7. Rogue

    Rogue Sexy Superhero

    Pete is an excellent schemer. It will be interesting to see if anyone catches on to him. He's already managed to break up the strongest alliance pair and has them both turning to him, as well as roping in Lisa.
  8. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    It would make sense to split Denise and Malcolm onto the other two tribes - I don't see how two people can compete in a team challenge, and then at TC they'd have to purple rock or doing firemaking, which is just dumb at this point.

    The issue of course is that their carefully planned sekret alliance will now be out in the open - the two of them voted off their whole tribe, plus if they weren't already they'd be bonded by this experience. When Stephanie was all alone, didn't they give her one round immunity with the other tribe?

    Pete is turning out to be all kinds of awesome. What might be saving him from the classic playing-too-hard-out-of-the-gate mistake is that they haven't had to go to TC, so while he's been stirring the pot, he hasn't had to go out on a limb and actually start targeting people, which often gets you voted out first.

    Almost - almost - felt sorry for RC. But she was so arrogant at first, to see the rug pulled out from under her is just desserts. Abby is so hypocritical I can't stand it - she's accusing RC of betraying her, but it's Abby who broke confidence about the clue and blabbed, and Abby who went looking for it, and Abby who hasn't told RC she found it.

    Interesting that like fans who mostly didn't want Penner on again and now are appreciating his love of the game, his tribe is seeing the same thing.

    Poor blondie though - while she was making a good case for the girls to stick together, the other two just looked like they wanted to head over to the beach and play with the boys. #epicfail on a girls alliance on the yellow tribe I think.
  9. smurfy

    smurfy Well-Known Member

    Right now, I am intrigued and rooting for:
    Denise & Malcolm
    Penner & Jeff
    Pete & ?? Lisa?

    And for their hopefully soon boots: Abi & RC
  10. jamesy

    jamesy shut in

    With the blue team dwindling down we finally got to see other people from the red tribe who are not Penner and Jeff Kent. :lol: And an episode where Skupin didn't hurt himself!

    No. She got a little bit of a reprieve her first week when they voted out Coby (who had voted for Stephenie) and the week after when Janu went crazy and quit, but she was never formally given any kind of immunity.
  11. Prancer

    Prancer Slave to none, master to all Staff Member

    I can't stand Abi. Ergo, Abi will be there for a long time.

    Sneaky Pete! Making the game interesting in an evil but much more subtle way than Russell the Troll.

    Russell the Stupid is a real piece of work. I hope he means it when he says he is done with the game. If he doesn't, I hope Survivor is done with him.

    The Sucksters are all going crazy over Russell's comments about Denise at final tribal council and are proclaiming a winner's edit. Don't get excited; the edgic people are always wrong. But it was interesting that Denise is seen as such a likeable person. I always wondered how a therapist would do on this show.

    Almost forgot, but PML at the part where Russell was walking around looking for the idol saying that he was sure the cameras were filming him walking right past it (Russell walks right past the idol), looking for it in the wrong place while there's a big flash on the idol (idol flashes) and so on. That was positively TAR-like :lol:.
  12. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    Me too. Years ago I thought it would be fun to cast a bunch of people who each had some sort of talent or edge that could help their game - psychologist, triathlete, puzzle champion, lawyer, politician, PR person, professional con artist, outdoors person, someone native to the place they are playing, a pakour (sp?), a detective, etc etc.

    I know! I remember once you shared with us that players in the past have said that within a few days they don't even notice the cameras, but as he was saying it and running around looking I thought, "gee, why don't you follow the sights of the camera that's filming you right now?" :lol:
  13. Erin

    Erin Well-Known Member

    I'm actually surprised that they actually cast a likeable, apparently competent therapist. It seems like usually when they cast people like that (whether for Survivor or other reality shows), you wonder how on earth they can actually do their jobs because they come across so terribly on TV. What I'm most impressed about is that she managed to get Russell on her side to vote for Malcolm...given what a mysogynist Russell has been, I was sure he was going to vote out Denise in a "gotta keep the strength" vote, so well-done by Denise!

    I've been loving the Denise-Malcolm alliance from the beginning, so I'm glad they stuck it through together. I hope we don't see an Ulong situation where the tribe goes down to one, as I'd rather watch the tribe vote someone out than a fire-making competition.

    Things are finally starting to get interesting with the dynamics on the other two tribes. I actually did feel sorry for RC. Not sure I would like her in real life, but I don't mind her as a game player. She keeps trying to do all the right things in her alliance with Abi, but Abi apparently has the emotional intelligence of a 5 year-old and there is just no reasoning with her. I'm glad Penner has some alliance-mates now, but I just wish I liked them better.
  14. PeterG

    PeterG Well-Known Member

    I would loooooove that!!! :cheer2:
  15. Rogue

    Rogue Sexy Superhero

    Poor Dana.

    If I were Dawson, I would have departed with a question at large, "Why don't you ask Jeff about his NBA days?"

    ETA Oops - I meant his pro baseball days. Got NBA on the brain since the season has just started.
    Last edited: Oct 18, 2012
  16. my little pony

    my little pony war crawling into canada

    then he could honestly answer he was never in the NBA

    Last edited: Oct 18, 2012
  17. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    Yeah I was :wuzrobbed for Dana that whole ep - she really, really wanted to play poor thing. It was nice to see everyone rally around her too - big points for Penner in my book.

    Also, apparently I was wrong last week about the potential women's alliance on the red tribe. In the edit, we saw Dana doing all the talking while Dawson and Katie looked off into space, so I thought they were just going along with her when they'd really rather be with the men, but both said this time that they were aligned. Mind you, the second Dana was gone that crumbled, they didn't bother trying to get Denise on board (not that we saw at least), and Katie went with the flow and voted out Dawson. I figured Denise would hook up with the men anyway.

    As for Dawson, badly played. I'm not sure when all the baseball taunting was, but if it was after they lost the challenge, then she was building her own coffin because of course Jeff would target her now - when he might have targeted Katie who was the biggest drag on the challenge, or the newbie and future threat Denise. And why didn't she take him aside, tell him what she knew? She could have tried to buy his protection, but from what we can tell, she didn't. On her way out, that skary stalker look she gave Jeff before she mauled him was something - no wonder she didn't have it together to take a parting shot.

    And I can't believe I was feeling a bit sorry for RC again - she's really in a fix now. Mind you, I think that tribe remains quite volatile and things could easily shift.

    Overall, I have to give points to the casting department this season. With just a couple of exceptions, it's an interesting group this time, and the majority really want to be there and know how to play. Loving it so far!
  18. CynicElle

    CynicElle Well-Known Member

    Pete: "Hey, Malcolm! I don't really know much about you or what kind of player you are, but let me tell you all about this tribe and the alliances. And by the way, my alliance has an immunity idol!"

    Malcolm: "Yeah? Cool." -completely avoids mentioning his own idol-

    I really like Malcolm.

    Boy, I worried that Denise would be toast if her tribe had to go to tribal council. I'm so glad I was wrong about that. It sure would be nice to see her actually get to win something for once, although at this point she'd probably collapse from the shock if it actually happened.

    And Penner was so, so sweet when he was comforting Dana. He's such a dad.
  19. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    Cynic I was surprised that Pete told all to Malcolm too as I thought he had more game than that. However, Malcolm also said that everyone was coming up to him - so maybe Pete felt that there was enough competition that he had to sweeten the deal to get Malcolm onside?

    That would also support the idea that that tribe remains volatile - it was Pete himself that said alliances are only good on the day they're made.
  20. Erin

    Erin Well-Known Member

    I agree that Penner was great with Dana...reminded me of why I like him, even if he's not always a great player. I did think the section was a little bit weirdly edited, like Jeff really wanted to make it clear that she was deciding to quit and not being pulled by medical. Given the sympathy that has been shown to other med-evacs lately, it seemed a bit off to show this tiny girl who was clearly sick and struggling as a semi-quitter.

    Love Malcolm and Denise, too, and thrilled to see that neither of them seem to be targets on their new tribes. I'm also glad we didn't have to see them go down to a tribe of one.
  21. FiveRinger

    FiveRinger Well-Known Member

    Yes, there were a lot of strange happenings in this week's episode:

    1) Why, oh why didn't Dawson make it known who Jeff was? Perhaps she might have deflected some of the heat away from herself. Just like the tribe originally didn't want Penner to win because he's already had 2 shots, surely they would have had something to say about a former MLB playing. Not that I don't like Jeff. He's a nice guy, but an obvious threat that needs to be neutralized. I did have to laugh at her in her exit interview though, telling Jeff what she wanted from him for her "help" in getting him to the million.

    2) Pete is a cocky son of a gun. I understand him wanting to gain Malcolm's trust, but to tell him about the idol was just foolery. It's going to come back to bite him. That entire RC/Abi situation is going to be really ugly when they finally get to tribal. Malcolm couldn't have played it any better by keeping his own idol a secret and just finding a way into the tribe. It didn't even look hard.....very smooth.

    3) Poor Dana. She's got heart. I hate to see when players have strong spirits and their bodies can't live up.

    4) Malcolm and Denise have been reborn. Love it. And even though Denise's tribe lost, I was really glad to see that her new tribe sees her as an asset, not a liability and that they are willing to keep her around. She's going to be dangerous when she gets to the merge.

    5) I loved how Jeff called Abi out for only participating in 2 challenges. RC is physically a stronger player. It will be interesting to see how much longer she lasts, even with an idol. She's not a nice person.....complaining because someone pulled her hair....she's a whiner and a paranoid nut. She's already told us that she's twisted her knee twice. What reason do they have to keep her? RC irritated me a little bit in the beginning, but Abi is just a waste of space. Can we get rid of her?

    6) Am I the only one pulling for Lisa to end up in the final? I really like her....and she's really smart, doing well with the puzzle challenges. It's also interesting that Scubin is the only one who recognizes her and the tribe wants him gone. I'm really starting to like her chances.
    Last edited: Oct 18, 2012
  22. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    One reason to keep Abby is she's a good shield, and if you want to cause a distraction or stir things up to keep attention away from yourself or your actions, she's the ideal starting point. Not sure why Pete is so adamant on getting RC out, but it may very well be because she is an individual challenge threat, and because Pete saw her making alliances early. I'm assuming he wants Skupin out for the popularity factor - that if he makes it to the end, the jury will likely love him. Pete likely doesn't consider Abby any kind of threat - not in challenges, she's not that bright, people don't like her - she's actually an ideal partner, other than being so volatile.
  23. smurfy

    smurfy Well-Known Member

    I wasn't keen on Katie, but I like that she owned her doing poorly in the challenge.
    also interesting editing - Denise aligning with the guys. Did the girls even approach here? the 3-3 split - Denise & Malcolm are useful!
    And I am also very happy that Denise & Malcolm are doing well so far on their new tribes. Malcolm continues to impress, he is very smart and knows how to play.
    Good point about keeping Abi. It will not take much to set her off.
    Penner was so sweet with Dana. Maybe she will come back another season. She seemed like a good player of what we saw.
    Dawson - what a nut job. So funny how she hugged Jeff at the end. I too found it interesting that she said nothing about Jeff K. Wonder if anyone else knows who he is?? Maybe on the other tribe.
    I am rooting for Lisa as well. She seems so nice and normal, plus always got to root for someone who is a fan of the show. She might be able to stay under the radar, let the physical ones and Abis get kicked out first.
    Wonder when the merge is? Now down to 12.
    Like last week, I am still rooting for Malcolm, Denise, Penner, Lisa, ande Jeff. Intrigued by Pete.
  24. walei

    walei Well-Known Member

    Dawson's exit was creepy and hilarious! I found it funnier that before she hugged and kissed Jeff she stared dagger at him like she was going to cut him down!

    Also I agree this week that Jeff's constant singling people out was weird. He went on and on about Katie's poor performance was why they lagged behind in each phase of the immunity challenge.

    I'm totally rooting for Malcolm and Denise, really reminded me of Tina and Colby. Hope they both can go far!
  25. bmcg

    bmcg Well-Known Member

    My thought on Jeff singling out Abi and Katie in the challenge was to give Malcom and Denise a chance on their new tribes because Malcom and Denise give 110% and Jeff likes that sort of player. By repeating it constantly he plants the seed with both teams that there may be a weaker person to get rid instead of the easy choice of voting off the new kid.
  26. PeterG

    PeterG Well-Known Member

    I'm wondering if Jeff gets on everyone's case. Then when editing time comes around, the editors selectively use just one little bit of what he says to make us think one person might be the one targeted to be voted off, but it's actually someone else. All done for "dramatic purposes".
  27. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    ok, I knew this was coming, but my worst nightmare in one episode! Malcolm is the one to find the HII, and Denise goes to the tribe where other favorite player Dana has to leave due to illness. HUGE BUMMER :wuzrobbed

    Now that Malcolm is feeling like a winner, he's cocky and not so likeable. I had a feeling about him when he was whining about normally being a winner a few weeks out. Ugh, WHY couldn't Denise have found the idol? :drama:

    Pete is doing very well, but I don't particularly like him, and I flat out hate Abi.

    Good for Skupin for figuring out the trick to the reward challenge - throw your statue high in the air and knock your opponent's statue off before yours hits the ground. Most of the wins after that came from those who employed the same strategy. Poor Dana having to go against whatsisname (seriously - what is his name?).

    Penner continues to impress. Talk about NOT GIVING UP. He took over when Jeff was flagging on the rope and got through it quickly, and he almost managed to get the win out from under the yellow tribe. Plus he provided good commentary and great support for Dana while she was so sick. I've been a fan of his and continue to be - I would love to see him make it very far in the game, along with Denise and Lisa, and even RC, although there is no way that's happening.

    PML at the dramatik slo mo editing when they were previewing how the immunity challenge would work.

    Dawson was useless. Her baseball chit chat was stupid. It sounded like coy flirting, not strategy to unnerve Jeff. And her stalker behavior with Probst as she left :eek: He may need to file a restraining order.
  28. MarieM

    MarieM Grumpy Cynical Ice Dance Lover

    I so hope Malcolm and Denise are reunited and finish in the final 3. I so hope :)
  29. Prancer

    Prancer Slave to none, master to all Staff Member

    Katie's boot was rather meh, but the bargaining over the reward challenge was interesting. On one hand, you had the red team devouring this pile of food, then moaning about how hungry they were. On the other tribe, you have everyone bitching about the trade, especially when they realized that they only got one extra day's worth of rice, which I thought was pretty funny of Penner--he had to be gambling that they would merge soon since their supply was so low. And it looks like he was right, because it looks like next week is the merge.

    The yellow team has been so dominant, but there are lots of divisions there that the red team might be able to exploit--and Denise and Malcolm will be reunited. And there are three HIIs in play! I see some tasty plottin' and schemin' coming.
  30. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    ugh, people making a big show of "I'll go with whatever everyone else wants to do" and then complaining that it was absolutely the wrong thing to do! :wall: That's how we ended up with that tribe giving up their immunity last season to kick off one of their own! :wall:

    But eys, that was great of Penner. And I almost fell for it and thought he was a goner tonight - except there's no effing way he could have heard She-Dana's "Katie or Penner?" slip up without knowing something was up. The fact that we didn't see him scrambling or talking about it gave me hope that he wasn't going. Katie was completely useless, so no loss there.

    I'm a little annoyed at Probst about his calling in that immunity challenge - first, he lumps RC with Katie on one turn where they both missed - but RC caught one earlier in the challenge. I think her ability in challenges is seriously underappreciated. At least by Probst, which isn't a surprise. Second - he creams himself congratulating Malcolm, but gives no love to Lisa, who did a great job in that challenge. Plus, she looked like she was having a blast. And who thought she'd be capable of holding Denise down in the reward challenge? I certainly didn't. Go Lisa!

    Jeff continuing to call out Abi's non-performance in challenges, though? Rocks. I wonder if we'll have some sort of new rule next time about how many challenges a person can sit out in a season.