1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Hi all! No longer will threads be closed after 1000 (ish) messages. We may close if one gets so long to cause an issue and if you would like a thread closed to start a new one after a 1000 posts then just use the "Report Post" function. Enjoy!

Survivor Caramoan (Season 26)

Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by Catherine M, Jan 11, 2013.

  1. Sparks

    Sparks Well-Known Member

    It looks like the spoiler Prancer posted is coming true.
  2. Catherine M

    Catherine M Well-Known Member


    We'll miss you Jenny but I totally understand giving the Philip show a pass. He doesn't bother me at all so I'm actually enjoying this season alot. Doesn't hurt that I have loved seeing Reynold & Eddie's alliance of cool kids completely fall apart the past few weeks. Its amusing that neither has a clue how to play this game yet are called "fans"!
  3. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    I barely noticed Phillip in this week's episode. I thought it was the Reynold show. I'd really like an episode without him throwing things.
  4. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    Philip is just one factor for me. It's more a general pissedoffedness that they are presenting this sham as "favourites" rather than going with new players (and maybe 1-2 returnees), which has been interesting the past few seasons. I just couldn't get excited about it, and tuning in last night didn't spark my interest at all sadly. Plus, I have enough tv on the go, especially w BB Canada on three nights a week!

    But do carry on - I'm not watching the Bachelor either, but enjoying that thread nonetheless :)
  5. jamesy

    jamesy shut in

    Yes, and everyone knows that everyone else is in and has a codename. :lol: I loved Andrea getting mad that Phillip was giving names to outsiders. :drama:
  6. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    how long has it been since we've had a season with ALL new players?

    never mind - it was just a couple seasons ago (One World). it just feels like we've had an endless parade of "favorites" shoved down our throats.
  7. Fridge_Break

    Fridge_Break #HotMessExpress

    It makes for "better" and "more exciting" seasons, according to Jeff & Co. :rolleyes: The unfortunate coincidence that One World sucked while it being the only season out of the past 5 to not have returning players doesn't bode well for an entirely new cast at some point down the road.
  8. Erin

    Erin Well-Known Member

    I liked One World :shuffle: But I guess seeing a competent, sane person strategize her way to victory isn't for everyone (and doesn't make for high ratings).
  9. Prancer

    Prancer Slave to none, master to all Staff Member

    Next season is all new players.
  10. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    The big negative for One World is that it included a hateful crazy, and once he was mercifully gone the season got a bit boring (although Kim was great). I don't need non-stop drama, but a great player/strategist basically owning the season isn't very memorable, unfortunately. Just wish it weren't hard to find maybe two great strategists/players in a season.
  11. PeterG

    PeterG Well-Known Member

    Reynold might be a bigger idiot than Eddie. Eddie's docile, so there's no expectations. Reynold you can see has some intelligence, but he remains antagonistic. As soon as it was clear he was in a minority, he should have distance himself from his group. He should have sucked up to whoever would have let him and found where the weakness in the main alliance was and worked his way in there. He hasn't tried to make a connection with anyone. He remains only because of his physical strength. Other than that, he means absolutely nothing to anyone. And he's doing nothing to change that.
  12. purple skates

    purple skates Shadow Dancing

    He keeps saying that he has no respect for anyone else there. Um, ok. How do you think they feel about that, genius?
  13. Prancer

    Prancer Slave to none, master to all Staff Member

    From Reynold's Survivor profile:

    Why You Think You Will Be the Sole SURVIVOR: With my charming personality and a long history of thriving in and adapting to new social situations, I am the best equipped to manipulate the actions of my fellow competitors to play my agenda.
  14. Kasey

    Kasey Correcting President Trump's grammar on Twitter :)

    AKA, with my delusional personality, I will get my arse handed to me by a badly botoxed and Bullock-lipped aging Barbie, and somehow still believe that I can control the game, even when hanging on by my jock (and I don't mean underwear, I mean Eddie)
  15. PeterG

    PeterG Well-Known Member

  16. KHenry14

    KHenry14 Well-Known Member

    A few musings after finally getting a chance to watch this ep...

    You would think it would be impossible to have worse tats that Matt, but Lil' Hantz' new ones are horrific

    Reynold is clueless. You don't get the vote you wanted, then you go back to camp and all out all the others, saying you didn't like any of them. Seems to me if you are down to two in your alliance, you are going to need someone from the other group. Dont alienate them. He got lucky this week since Laura was so inept in challenges, but dude, at some point you will need them. Weren't you supposed to have watched the show before????

    And this really has morphed into the Phillip show. He's not a crazy this time around, but sheesh it's really getting boring this time.

    BTW, does anyone know if Colton was asked back for this show? I'd hate him, but he'd be at least entertaining, unlike these "Favorites".

    And finally, evidently Probst is getting hammered on social media for this season. Not be a good few months for Jeff, with his talk show being cancelled and this boring ep of Survivor.
  17. Fridge_Break

    Fridge_Break #HotMessExpress

    I know everybody is probably watching Worlds at the moment, so I'm not expecting much conversation about tonight's ep, but...

    Brandon is such a little piece of shit. I seriously hope that with his out-of-control psychopath tirade, and his uncle Willie's violence stint on Big Brother, that this is the last time we will EVER have a Hantz on a reality competition show. Brandon's behavior almost makes me wish that Russell was brought back for this season instead (I can't believe I just said that) -- at least he was just a terrible social player, he didn't go on with verbal attacks and get so out of control.
  18. caseyedwards

    caseyedwards Well-Known Member

    Whoa that behavior was awful! Just like why'd he even get on again? So he could do that! Of course.
  19. Moto Guzzi

    Moto Guzzi Well-Known Member

    That was a whole lot of crazy and one of the most bizarre episodes in Survivor history. Brandon's behavior was very disturbing. I, too, hope it's the last we see of any member of the Hantz family.
  20. smurfy

    smurfy Well-Known Member

    Yes, such a strange and sad episode. During the impromptu TC - I was watching the other Favs and their reactions.
    Corinne - have not seen much of her this season, but the one we knew from the past seems to have shown herself.
    I felt really bad for Dawn and Andrea - they seemed genuinely upset and concerned for Brandon. And Brenda (how little we have seen of her) was upset and knew it was not good. Every fav seemed rattled, but Corinne and Phillip were strange.
    Corrine seemed to be both upset and enjoying it a little. Just strange. Also Reynold seemed to be entertained.
    I find it strange for someone to be so entertained when someone else is breaking down.

    Philliip - seemed quite controlled for someone that seems unstable during Brandon's rants. Phillip is also quite capable in challenges. We are seeing 2 Phillips.
    I hope they show some of the aftermatch conversations.
    I found it interesting how the tribe handled it - instead of throwing a challenge - just forfeit openly.
    I think Jeff handled it very well, getting Brandon to stand by him, keeping him separate and massaging his shoulders, trying to calm him down.
    I felt like I should not have watched, but part of me is thinking - it can't be this bad, why are they letting this be on tv. Have they gone too far?
    Wonder what the fallout will be. Hope no more Hantzs - Jeff is right - something in their blood. Brandon sounded like Russell at times.
  21. Prancer

    Prancer Slave to none, master to all Staff Member

    I don't know if he was asked, but I do know he just got engaged. I find that entertaining enough :lol:.

    The before-season rumor was that Brandon punched someone and was removed from the game, then that Brandon got the boot at an impromptu tribal council and later was removed from the Ponderosa after his boot because he was completely mental and/or punched someone there. Since he's not on the jury (which he was spoiled to be), we will probably never know, but going by some of the tweets from indiscreet bootees and Russell, something happened with Brandon at the Ponderosa.

    The Hantzes are one. messed. up. family. There's a thread on Survivor Sucks where the stalkers fans track everything that gets posted by current and former players on Twitter, and the Hantz stuff gets seriously creepy sometimes. Russell and Brandon have had some freaky fights.

    I thought Jeff handled it amazingly well, but he had at least a hand in bringing Brandon back and you know he was thinking "This is such great TV!" the whole time, so I have a hard time giving him credit.

    I think Corinne enjoys drama, positive or negative.
  22. Moto Guzzi

    Moto Guzzi Well-Known Member

    Jeff did handle Brandon well. I was afraid the medical team was going to have to show up with a tranquilizer dart gun and bring Brandon down like a wild animal.
  23. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    I know that was a horrible tantrum, but I feel sorry for Brandon, always have. He seems to want to be a better person, and he just has no idea how. It's as if trying to rein in the behavior that is the norm for the rest of his family just makes him explode more. I'm not surprised at all that Brandon (maybe) got booted from Ponderosa for punching someone.

    I can understand why the Fans were a bit twittery (old school definition, nothing to do with Twitter) at what was happening - they had no idea what had been going on, and they've been so very demoralized. It was really tacky for Reynold and Julia to ask for the "Gota! Wins Immunity!" from Jeff, though. By that point they knew just how serious things had gotten.


    I was afraid that he was going to come running back from around the challenge structure and cold cock Phillip :yikes:
  24. BaileyCatts

    BaileyCatts Well-Known Member

    Good riddance. It was like watching a spoiled little brat throwing a tantrum because he didn't get his way. Brandon, you did not control your fate (or whatever the hell he blathered about). They were going to get you out one way or another and you were gone regardless of what you did or did not do. Please let this be the last time we ever see a Hantz on my TV again.
  25. sk8pics

    sk8pics Well-Known Member

    I, too, thought Jeff handled Brandon really well. I wonder how long it took in reality for that to play out. And I also wonder if they thought Brandon wouldn't be quite as bad as he turned out to be. I also wonder if Brandon might be have a rapid cycling bipolar disorder, with rage in place of the mania. Anyway, I am glad Brandon is out and thankful he didn't hurt anyone, although of course dumping the rice and beans does hurt the tribe.

    I think Phillip is crazy, too, but just not violent. I did have to laugh at Brandon telling Phillip his secret agent stuff was stupid and that nobody liked him. Now I wish Phillip would be gone, but I don't think that will happen for awhile.
  26. smurfy

    smurfy Well-Known Member

    I am glad folks here think Jeff handled Brandon well, as I am thinking. I was reading on TWOP and so many thought it was creepy. I really thought Jeff was trying to help/control the situation. Getting him away from Phillip and keeping the physical contact with Brandon was the best way to prevent a physical altercation.
    Just a sad situation that should have never happened - Brandon, and Phillip both should not have been brought back. I know they want crazy for entertainment purposes, but they have gone too far. They are hurting these individuals, plus making it so public! Brandon's kids will be able to see this on the web someday.
  27. Jenny

    Jenny From the Bloc

    Geez I'm glad I watched the Men's SP instead. Read all your comments and the summary on CBS - all I can think of is how CBS sabotaged their own game by bringing someone as volatile as Brandon back, which is really unfair to the players who came to play, and they should know better because they know him.

    That kid scares me - Philip is loopy, and a lot of players (and a lot of us) have our emotional issues and inner demons, but IMO Brandon is way past that. There is something truly scary about him, and I fear that before long we will hear very sad news associated with him. I know Survivor likes players who have a spiritual journey on the show, but I think they've crossed a line casting him, twice. It's one thing to bring in interesting people and offer the experience of a lifetime, but it's another to exploit seriously disturbed people for ratings.
    dbell1 and (deleted member) like this.
  28. dbell1

    dbell1 Well-Known Member

    I've watched Survivor from the first episode. Last night really went over the reality line for me. I watch for gameplay, challenges, the social interaction, the scenery. I don't watch for psychotic breaks. If they bring on/back one more Hantz, I'm done.

    That inappropriate "can you raise your hands and yell that we won immunity?" was just wrong on all levels. It's not about you or your losing streak, it's about removing someone who looks violent.

    Jeers to Jeff and gang for bringing lil Hantz back, but cheers to Jeff for his handling. He removed him from his tribemates and then diffused the tension.

    Looks like next week is the merge?
  29. genevieve

    genevieve drinky typo pbp, closet hugger Staff Member

    They've shown several times now that bringing crazy people on is their idea of a big draw. I think we will see someone removed for violence against another player before too long.

    I do wonder what type of treatment services Survivor offers to their pet players. though. Coach came in seeming beyond deluded, but by the third time around was playing pretty decently and wasn't quite so crackpot-y. I truly thought it was cruel casting Phillip, as his participation seemed designed to make audiences make fun of him and he was most certainly NOT in on the joke. This time, while he's still got some delusions and personality quirks, he's playing the game quite well, and it seems more of a persona he's putting on than him being mired in the middle of it. But Brandon seems just as lost as he was last time - and I read a pre-taping interview with him over on EW last night, and based on what he was saying before the players left, I don't see how anyone thought he'd be able to handle this season better than the last one.

    It is scary to think that Russell is the Hantz with the most control over his temper and emotions (compared to Brandon and Willie, anyway).
  30. Prancer

    Prancer Slave to none, master to all Staff Member

    All of them see a psychologist as soon as they get the boot and during their stays at Ponderosa. Some of them get more than that and get therapy once they go home as well. Apparently they brought the psychologist in to escort Brandon away from the challenge site and Jeff said that the producers are in touch with Brandon every day even now, which implies that Brandon is still getting therapy.

    Brandon, of course, says he's fine, mentally stable and proud of himself for the way he went out :rolleyes:.

    I don't think it's coincidence that both Coach and Philip are wannabe actors. Both of them function--and apparently function pretty well--in their day-to-day lives. I think they both saw the game as opportunity to play a role on TV, and were encouraged to do so by the producers. It's not that that isn't who they are, it's just that they were given a chance to let their pet fantasies about themselves run amok and they did. When the personas didn't go over the way they expected them to, they both toned it down but recognized that their personas were why they were brought back so the acts couldn't be completely abandoned.