Discussion in 'Great Skate Debate' started by millipied, May 3, 2011.
He's still alive right ? I'd sue Lara Fabian if I was him
Chaplin wasn't one of my favorite programs of theirs, but I agree that it was definitely in character.
I also agree that Dr. Zhivago was very elegant and I liked the music for the Golden Waltz.
Do I like some of their more esoteric programs more, yes, I do, but I think the point may be that the judges seem to respond more positively to programs like the ones they used last year. Unfortunately, it seems that the judges only like a narrow genere of music/choreography. When I think back to the early 90s in dance, there was such variety. I know that a lot of the changes have to do with the rules and especially this BS rule about uplifting music. However, there is tons of non-generic, "uplifting" music out there.
Doesn`t he get royalties from her? The price to pay to get your songs butchered.
There is also a version by Dalida. That would have been more uplifting!!!
Corpses don't generally perform seriously and stoically. They tend to just lie still and rot.
Was is the Serge Lama version that Plushenko skated his exhibition to last year? That was fabulous!
Ok so I've just listened to Lara Fabian's version and I can sort of see why they would pick, it's a little more suited to be danced on.
But no way in hell are the lyrics uplifting! Here's an english translation.
And if I were Jacques Brel and alive in 1971, I would've sued Lama for copying me slavishly This doesn't excuse that Fabian wench though
Yes, that puts you in suicide mode instantly. I can`t imagine having to listen to it every day during practice.
Evidently I'm the minority here, but I just listened to the Lara Fabian version of "Je Suis Malade" and loved it. It has a haunting quality to it, and I think it is SO them. I think they'll really pull this one off. Above all, I'm relieved that the FD isn't to La Strada. While its one of my favouite scores ever, I don't think I could have handled Weaver & Poje skating to yet another movie theme.
I personally much prefer Dalida's version. Lama's version is also wonderful (though it does sound like he imitates Brel a bit). Fabian's version, though beautiful, leans too much towards Celine Dion for my taste. Still, gorgeous song, Fabian sings it well, and I think the music is a great choice for W/P.
Yeah, I guess if any of the skaters watched the original film they just ignored the entire story.
Translation: "I am sick." How appropriate.
Whenever Lara Fabian is mentionned, I can't help but think of a sketch from the Guignols : Incredible Lara !
Or how Lara Fabian has been exposed too young to an overdose of Barbra Streisand and now, when she goes on stage, she tranforms into Incredible Lara, who breaks glass when she shou ... err sings.
Nah, if you want a canadian who sings a huge classique of the chanson française, you take Avec le Temps or Ma Fille by Isabelle Boulay. Ferré or Reggiani, I can't help but cryyyyyyyyyyyyyyy. And Boulay is a good interpreter. But Incredible Lara ?
Yes, that's the one.
Problem is, they don't exactly look like lovesick, desperate people in self-destructive mode but more like an ad for toothpaste.
I really like W/P and I like that music.
Gotta say that the uplifting rule is bizarre. I am pretty sure it was around last year and it looked like quite a few people kind of ignored it (like Crone/Poirier and their Eleanor Rigby.)
I agree. I would like to see more dramatic programs in ice dance like we had a few years ago
I'd like to see Meryl & Charlie skate to Carmina Burana or Firebird. I think with their power, they could do something incredible with that kind of music. But that's just me.
Well, now I've listened to the Serge Lama version.
It would be nice, if he could sing. Unfortunately he sounds like he's reading an essay on how his day went, set to music from which he occasionally selects a note to sing, sometimes on pitch.
The Dalida version is a great improvement. However, I liked the Lara Fabian version the best. I don't see how they can possibly make an ice dance out of that, however. It would have to be extensively rearranged to make it danceable, IMO. The outcome of this choice will be intriguing. It could be a disaster or, if the arrangement is well-done, very successful.
I wonder if Weaver and Poje will incur the penalty for not having uplifting music. There is nothing uplifting about the lyrics nor the tone of the song. After last year's program, I would like to see them do something less angsty.
I am wondering when we will get our first Lady GaGa medley free dance.
Eh, point taken. I respect their athleticism, and ability to bring it , I'm just not crazy about their programs/ Shpilband style. I really find that much of what they are given does not suit them well.
The lyrics are not uplifting for sure unless you're planning an immediate suicide...but I find the music quite uplifting..just IMO of course!!
THAT would be great!
They skated to "Moulin Rouge" last season. I didn't think that was angsty at all. Or do you mean that you would like them to continue in that vein? Loved that programme in any case.
My secret ambition in life is to make heart shaped poses with Andrew Poje. Or Kaitlyn if Andrew isn't available.
This week, Japanese Skating Federation is having the national camp.
Some skaters joined the camp and show their new programs.
(Mao and Daisuke do not joined.)
According to the article, Kanako Murakami's New FS is Mendelssohn's violin concerto.
Kanako is working with foreign choreographers this season
The choreographers are not announced yet, but she had been to North America (USA maybe) for choreography in this summer.
I hope Tom Dickson for her
Tatiana Tarasova has worked with Murakami on new program(s).
I like the music choice for Kanako's long. A step forward after last year.
Kanako had worked with Trasova!!??
When did she go to Russia....?
(Tarasova is working with Sotnikova, so I think she does not work with other young ladies....especially not Russian )
Anyway, I think this collaboration will be quite interesting!
Something new for lovely Kanako
I heard that Kanako Murakami worked with Tarasova in Hackensack, NJ earlier this summer (not sure if it was SP or FS or both).
As far as I know they worked in the US...
Sylvia, Eris, Thank you very much for your quick response!
I cannot to wait to see Kanako's new program!!!
I got new article about Kanako.
SP music : no information / Choreo by Tatiana Trasova
FS music : Mendelssohn's violin concerto / Choreo by Marina Zueva
According to the article, Kanako said the Trasova's SP is too difficult for her.
The writer said that she has not decided if she skates this SP or not....(not sure this is Kanako's comment or not)
This part sounds wonderful. I am really looking forward to seeing this.
I am not surprised, Tarasova is a choreographer of deep emotion.
Did she say it was too difficult for her emotionally? Or technically?