1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.
  2. Hi all! No longer will threads be closed after 1000 (ish) messages. We may close if one gets so long to cause an issue and if you would like a thread closed to start a new one after a 1000 posts then just use the "Report Post" function. Enjoy!

Johnny Weir joining NBC as skating analyst

Discussion in 'Great Skate Debate' started by victorskid, Oct 23, 2013.

  1. flyingsit

    flyingsit Well-Known Member

    I'm sorry, but I found it ridiculous when Johnny let his love of all things Russian influence his commentary about Kovtun. The skating world is terrified of him? Really? Of a 17th-place finisher at Worlds?
  2. aftershocks

    aftershocks Well-Known Member

    :lol: You think Johnny meant that literally? Regarding 2013 Worlds, don't forget that Kovtun was under extra pressure as a newbie on the senior scene after the controversy of his being sent to Worlds over Menshov who placed ahead of Kovtun at Russian Nationals.

    In any case, right now I'd agree that competitors aren't especially "terrified" of Kovtun but I'm pretty sure they respect his talent. Definitely, Kovtun is a very talented jumper and what with being Russian and having Tarasova to refine his rough edges (not to mention he cuts a compelling and handsome figure on the ice), there's no doubt that the skating world will be singing Kovtun's praises should he consistently put together his jumping ability with artistry and at least a semblance of good musical interpretation. At this point, Kovtun seems to have a better chance than Gachinski of being the next great Russian male skater. Johnny and Terry had an interesting discussion regarding why there are fewer talented Russian male figure skaters these days versus the abundance of young Russian female single skater phenoms.

    As far as the scoring of both Kovtun and Han at Cup of China, I think both their scores were overly high, especially in view of their developing maturity. Nothing new though the way some men are overrated when they land quads. I thought Machida was perfect competitively (clean performances with great music and costuming) at Skate America, for example, but OTOH IMO Machida is not a complete skater re skating skills and not that great artistically to warrant his overly high PCS.

    That's great. I'm glad to hear it and I'm looking forward to the NHK broadcast this Sunday. :) I wonder will Johnny be joining both Terry and Tara in the booth for the ladies event?

    ETA: BTW judiz, I noticed you started another thread that didn't get many views mentioning that Johnny will begin choreographing for competitive skaters (starting with some Japanese skaters). Do you know who the Japanese skaters are? That's interesting news. I recall that Johnny has done a lot of his own choreography mainly for exhibitions. Very memorable exhibitions including Imagine, My Way, Ave Maria, and Heartbroken. Plus Johnny once mentioned that he'd improvise sometimes during his programs depending on how the music moved him at the time. I believe this tendency is part of what ultimately made it difficult for Johnny to transition to competing under CoP with the expected level of international success. Wishing Johnny a satisfying and rewarding career in skating as a commentator and a choreographer!
    Last edited: Nov 6, 2013
  3. DimaToe

    DimaToe El Chen-te Fernández

    Did Johnny mention during the NBC broadcast that he had spoken to :TT1:? I wonder if Johnny was just repeating what TAT told him :lol:
  4. skatesindreams

    skatesindreams Well-Known Member

    Wonderful news; and something to anticipate, with pleasure!
  5. aftershocks

    aftershocks Well-Known Member

    Do any Russian fans have answers to viennese's questions?


    Johnny tweeted about an hour ago:

    Johnny Weir-Voronov‏@JohnnyGWeir
    Feeling quite honored that I just got a call from the legendary Dick Button and his appreciation of my commentary! #PushDicksButton

    Ain't that great!!! Very special coming from the legendary Dick Button, a great figure skater as well as the founding pioneer of figure skating broadcasting on television. Dick has taught a generation of figure skating fans how to understand and watch this beautiful sport, and I'm one of his students! What a compliment, Johnny!
    Last edited: Nov 6, 2013
  6. Artistic Skaters

    Artistic Skaters Drawing Figures

    I'm looking forward to hearing his commentary for the ladies event. I hope it becomes a long term assignment & not just as a cover for Lipinski while she judges Miss Universe.

    I have friends & co-workers who are not really skating fans. They saw Johnny skate at Skate for Hope & now they're even tuning in since I told them I was enjoying his commentary.
    PeterG and (deleted member) like this.
  7. judiz

    judiz Well-Known Member

    Johnny will be commentating without Tara, she is in Russia judging Miss Universe pageant
  8. aftershocks

    aftershocks Well-Known Member

    ^^ Oh, interesting. I see ArtisticSkaters mentioned that too. When is the pageant airing? Haven't Johnny and MKwan also officiated at beauty pageants?

    I wonder if Johnny will just be filling in this weekend for Tara re the ladies commentating?
  9. Lacey

    Lacey Well-Known Member

    So, I think Johnny meant that, at regular practices, US coaches encourage complete run-throughs, sometimes double ones, and that, at competition practices, the US coaches would only do a little of this and that, so as to not exhaust the athlete right before his real program. Whereas, at regular practices, Russian coaches would encourage let's do a little of this, say footwork, and a little of that, say spins, but not complete run-throughs. And then, at competition warmups, where there are six minutes to practice and one doesn't want to exhaust oneself doing a complete run-through right there before one goes on the ice for the real program, both American and Russian coaches would do the little piece of the program mode for practice. The question remains do those who train with American coaches have more stamina and mental fitness--you can get through this because you do it every day--attitude or do skaters who train with Russian coaches have less stamina and mental fitness built up because of their regular practice policy. Is this what others thought Johnny meant?
  10. Skittl1321

    Skittl1321 Well-Known Member

    That's definetly how I interpreted, but I'm not sure a little of this and a little of that means footwork or spins. It might be more like "today we work from first salchow to first combo spin"; like 1/4 of the program. And then they perfect every movement that goes on between those two things, which might be salchow, lutz-toe, then spin. But paying very careful attention to every movement in between.

    I know American skaters also focus on details- but because they run the whole program everyday, I think less attention is on "where is my wrist, what angle is my head at, when I step out of the landing position from my second toe-loop" type detail. To me, that's the difference of artistic vs. athletic. These details are in there (the choreographer is going to bring them up), but they get less attention, and stamina training gets more attention.

    Having watched American skaters ("at home") though- they do parts too, and focus on skills, it is just rare to not have a run-through or multiples during the practice.
    Last edited: Nov 7, 2013
  11. acraven

    acraven Well-Known Member

    I don't know precisely what Johnny meant; I hope he'll elaborate at some point. However, I don't think the 6-minute warm-ups are at issue. Most skaters primarily skate around to get the blood flowing then warm up jumps with their planned entrances. Maybe do each spin once if there's time. Maybe a bit of footwork.

    The regular 40-minute practices and 20-minute practices (the latter confusing called "warm-ups") at competitions are a different story, especially the longer practices. The skaters' music is played during the 40-minute practices, and each skater has the right of way while his music is playing. There's more room for variation there, and it does seem that Russian-coached skaters are more likely to do just segments on their programs while their music is playing. But other skaters sometime do that, too--at the first practice when they're jet-lagged, or if their music is first to be played and they don't fell totally warmed up. In the latter situation they may not really jump at all during the run-through. It's not always easy to see a clear pattern during competition practices, since skaters who miss jumps often skate over to their coaches consultation, thus skipping part of their run-throughs.

    I'm very curious about how what we see at competition practices differs from what the skaters typically do during a single practice session at home. I've seen quite a lot of competition practices, but what goes on at home is a big unknown. I wonder whether Johnny meant that Russian coaches build each week toward a single pseudo-competition, when the skater does a complete run-through.
  12. Carolla5501

    Carolla5501 Well-Known Member

    My understanding years ago was that the old Soviet style, which I assume would be the Russian style, was to do "segments" So one day you did section A of the program and one day section B etc.. rarely did you do the entire thing. part of that was to allow for the "details" to be really worked on. Back in the day I remember Peggy and Dick discussing this and saying that created a problem if the skater fell or something. Where in the US the run throughs had trained the skater to get up and keep going that training was missing from the old Soviet skaters.

    Now I may be totally off base :)
  13. jiejie

    jiejie Well-Known Member

    You're not off-base. This is exactly what Johnny was talking about, I'm sure of it. This specific difference in training methods has been talked about for at least a couple of decades by other commentators well before Johnny came on the scene. One method (the "American") favoring regular full program run-throughs to build physical stamina and to build mental fortitude to pick up and regroup in the event of mistakes. The other method (the "European" since it's much wider than just Russia) was to work on segments and details, and do relatively fewer full run-throughs during typical training especially earlier in the season. Sort of the assumption that if you have each segment/section of a program down pat, it should be easy enough to link them together in a full program when competition time comes around. I think you have to take this as a generalization, as I'm sure there are coaches in each region that have always used a hybrid of the two concepts.

    This has to do with regular training during the on- and off-seasons, not competition practices nor warm-ups which have a totally different purpose and rhythm.
  14. PairSk8Fan

    PairSk8Fan Banned Member

    I think Johnny did well enough so far that he may be on the road to becoming the next Dick Button-style commentator. It seems like a nice job to have!
  15. viennese

    viennese Well-Known Member

    thanks for addressing this...it's fascinating to me how different "schools" approach training for the intensity of a 4-4.5 minute performance.
  16. Sylvia

    Sylvia Prepping for club comp. season!

    Just a reminder that NBC's TV broadcast, with Johnny commentating on both the Ladies' & Men' free skates, is scheduled for Sunday, Nov. 10 from 1:30-3:30 pm Eastern.
  17. Jubak

    Jubak Well-Known Member

    Saw Johnny on Friday night at an American Ballet Theatre performance but he didn't seem to stay for the whole show (unless he changed his seat) Wearing a "blonde" vintage old lady mink coat & a huge citron yellow ostrich Birkin (very ugly!)
  18. judiz

    judiz Well-Known Member

    Johnny Weir-Voronov ‏@JohnnyGWeir 1h
    Thank you to everyone who supports figure skating and it's talents by spending your Sunday afternoons with us at @NBCSports! #RoadToSochi
  19. orientalplane

    orientalplane Mad for mangelwurzels

    Someone should give him some punctuation lessons. :lol:
    BittyBug and (deleted member) like this.
  20. IceAlisa

    IceAlisa discriminating and persnickety ballet aficionado

    Johnny is a pleasure to listen to. I watch skaters I am not usually interested in just to hear his commentary. It's always interesting, informative and considerate.
  21. aftershocks

    aftershocks Well-Known Member

    That's cool seeing Johnny in the audience at ABT, Jubak!

    I thought Johnny and Terry were good as usual on this afternoon's GP broadcast. Several comments by Johnny I agree with and appreciate his perceptive points of view expressed with honesty and respectfulness. More later on my thoughts.

    Ha ha, re Twitter punctuation policing.
  22. judiz

    judiz Well-Known Member

    totally agree
  23. judiz

    judiz Well-Known Member

    Johnny and his husband are good friends with Daniil Simkin who is a dancer with ABT, Victor tweeted that they had dinner with him after the performance.
  24. museksk8r

    museksk8r Holding an edge and looking dangerously sexy

    Johnny really shines as a commentator! I often find myself in agreement with his views. Keep up the great work! :cheer2:
  25. aftershocks

    aftershocks Well-Known Member

    Oh thanks for that tidbit, judiz. I used to enjoy seeing famous dancers, choreographers and other notable people in the audience at dance events, plays, and even the movies when I lived in New York.
  26. Skittl1321

    Skittl1321 Well-Known Member

    Daniil is fabulous! An amazing dancer. I wonder if he's a figure skating fan- if so, I wonder if he lurks or posts here? Before he was a professional he posted on one of the ballet-dancer boards I frequent. People used to think he was lying when he'd mention the turns he was doing until he finally posted videos. No one was surprised, but everyone was thrilled when he made it big.
  27. aftershocks

    aftershocks Well-Known Member

    I must say I think it's criminal that NBC doesn't show at least the top 3 Ice Dance performances, especially at events where Meryl and Charlie compete. Not even a mention or a highlight of M&C's absolute brilliance in an Olympic year!!!
  28. Justathoughtabl

    Justathoughtabl Well-Known Member

  29. Suze

    Suze Active Member

    I caught the very end of the ladies competition on tv today and was impressed! He commented on all aspects of the performance in a very even-keel manner. I can't wait to hear his comments/analysis in future comps.
  30. Morry Stillwell

    Morry Stillwell Well-Known Member

    Is he paid by the word?