Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by BigB08822, Apr 21, 2011.
Discuss and vote after the show!
I'm watching for the first time all season and that woman who walked out with Randy and Steven can't possibly be the prettiest woman in America.
Oh good, we get to hear the singers that everyone voted they don't want to hear.
And here to prove that America made the right call...
If Pia hadn't gotten the boot, would we be hearing this?
Paul left his voice in the trailer.
I wish we weren't anyway. It was awful. I'm interested to see what she does on Dancing With the Stars next week.
Oh, good. The people we sent home are back.
No, Steven, that did not make me rethink my votes, because I never voted for any of them.
This is not adding a rock vibe to the song.
For Peter: Scotty doing "Swingin'" in a not very interesting way.
Swinging! That was Micah's favorite song when he was little. He and his dog would sit in the porch swing and he'd sing at the top of his lungs.
there was an awful lot of naima and that curly haired chick in that group mess
holy freakin poo, what is this song and why does scotty unhinge his neck like he has a pinched nerve all of the time? he's creepier than constantine ever was
OOOOH, judges offering actual critiques?
Randy calls him boring!
Go for it, JLo!
Who's creepier, Scotty or Jacob?
Oooh, the judges are being critical (although they are being really nice about it ).
James is doing Muse. Potential
The first ever what song from James?
James is going to spring some Muse on us! I hope it's Supermassive Black Hole. I love that song.
Shocked to see the judges actually give some criticism and some critiques, even Steven Tyler!
I thought Scotty sounded just fine but it was really boring and way too predictable.
there is a kitchiness about jacob that could be kind of funny in the right format like on the rupaul show
there is nothing fun or funny about scotty
Muse! I love everything they do so I hope James does them proud.
I would agree. Good vocal as always, but I think he needs to start taking some chances!
I didn't care for Scotty at all, but I rarely do. I'm excited about Jame doing Muse.
James gets the huge production, again. Why isn't anyone else taking advantage of this? I wonder if James is asking for all of this or if he is being offered and having it suggested to him...which would reek of favoritism but that never happens on this show, right?
That being said, this is quite boring and he is absolutely screaming...
Maybe that would work better in an arena...
James knows how to put on a show.
I like it when he sings in a lower register; his voice is much richer.
Yeah, that rocked.
Did someone say "modern arrangement?" This is incredibly 80's (not that that's a bad thing.)
Shut up, Jennifer.
His voice sounded bad.
I loved that performance!
Oh, Peter, it was "Uprising." I enjoyed it.
I might see this year's idols tour for James.