Discussion in 'Off The Beaten Track' started by Cyn, Apr 19, 2013.
I know it's amazing isn't it. I would be more impressed if that wasn't a rerun.
Why is Amber crying?
Well, I hated that
Amber was fantastic.
i wouldnt say i hated it, i dont think it was interesting enough to hate. but i was glad when it was over.
Not impressed by Amber either time tonight, but knew she'd get a standing o for at least one performance.
I guess I'm just not hearing what the judges are. Candice was by far the best so far tonight, IMO.
they've had a lot of mentors over the years who had really good advice for the contestants. for whatever reason, not one of those people have ever been part of this turnstile of revolving judges.
Candice is just incredible. I would listen to her sing anything.
Candice is making the others look like little girls tonight compared to her. Stunning.
Candice is a , that's all that needs to be said.
And even Mimi stood up for that!
Really Randy?!?? Stop calling them church girls and Harry Connick JR has forgotten more than you will ever know you daft bint.
Still behind. Thought Amber was blah. Tears for votes.
They need to hire Harry Connick Jr. immediately...
Kree's voice is not strong enough for this song.
She went over like a lead brick for me, topaz. Far from her best.
I can't enough for Candice. She is my favorite contestant in years.
Absolutely. He's been awesome.
So this week, Kree isn't bluesy enough. Poor girl.
Seriously Minaj?! are you kidding me right now?
It will be either Candace or Kree, even though Kree sucked tonight.
Only Candice could have sung Stormy Weather.
One of my favorite version's of SW is Dinah Washington's version.
Harry Connick Jr.
Woohoo Harry Connick Jr.!! Tell him.
Totally love that he's calling Randy out on his total B/S
Harry just stated the reason why Candice is the best. Candice learns the song first and then she changes it to a "Candice" song. Mariah was right, Candice's musicallity gives her an edge over the other contestants. Heck it gives her an egde in the current music industry.
I don't think Kree could have done anything right for the judges tonight. It wasn't in the script.
I have to agree with Randy that the arrangement for Kree was not good. A bluesy arrangement would have suited Kree's voice better.
But this song exposes that the fact that Kree is not an artist yet, she can perform a song, she is not the place where she can "sing" a song.
Tonight, Kree was the weakest tonight. She struggled with difficult songs.
I wish Kree had listened to Harry. I hope it's Amber who gets the boot. I really like Candice and Kree.
Randy is sounding like a mainstream record producer which is what he is; Connick sounds like an artist, which is what HE is.. Can't say either one is wrong.
what in the name of up with people is this?