No Tuktamisheva has not had a clean short program at all, but even though they are all bad they are becoming less catastrophic as the season is progressing! Ando and Tuktamisheva TES is like 30 each but Ando is ahead on PCS because of course Liza desperately needs new choreography having done all the same SP's and LP's since she became a senior. As long as Tuktamisheva has the SP problems she can go anywhere and find herself beaten. She was beaten by Leonova at 2013 worlds. Being beaten by Leonova at 2013 worlds couldn't have been a stronger signal to change every single thing about her skating on every level.