Good music for a figure skating program will have crescendos so that the skaters can build tension/excitement/drama or whatever the case may be. IOW, places in the cut to do jumps, emoting, MITF and footwork sequences.
There doesn't seem to be a lot of high points or excitement of any kind in Ashley's LP cut. And what a shame? R&J is one of the most famous tragedies in the world. Conveying the drama of the story would be incumbent on the skater, otherwise, why chose R&J, why bother with the dress and the hair and the hara-kiri in the end?
With all that said, I think we will see a lot more of the R&J story unfold in the free skate as the season goes on as Ashley and her team infuse the program with details and choreographic steps (and hopefully, higher level spins!). I think she is capable of making it work but I do worry about the music cut.
"Nature is a damp, inconvenient sort of place where birds and animals wander about uncooked."
from Speedy Death
Last edited by smarts1; 10-24-2013 at 03:37 AM.
I guess they were trying to take a warhorse, but use less familiar pieces. However, Wilson couldn't even commit to that strategy as he uses "Death of Juliet" but then ignores it by keeping her buried in the corners or doing crossovers.
Heck, someone should try editing this program by switching the music that begins with the flying sit and ends shortly after the solo 3loop with the piece of music that follows it. She might need to move around some of the elements, but I think it would really improve the program overall.
The takeaway here is that ...No one puts DEATH OF JULIET in a corner! And by corner I mean the middle section of the program right after the bonus where skaters rip off consecutive jumping passes, lol.
"Puccini cries out for spirals, but really good ones." ~ Dick Button, 1998 Worlds
Ashley was actually smiling during "The Death of Juliet" in the middle section. Since it is a theme that pops out throughout the ballet, perhaps, they could substitute it with a more lyrical/quiet version from Act 2 for instance, then we will get the desired buildup to the finale.
I'm actually surprised they didn't pick "The Balcony Scene" as it is IMHO one of the most romantic themes in ballet.
That said, I'm glad that she is trying to portray social tension R&J and not the usual romantic Juliet.
Ugh, just give her something to work with already! I have just re-watched the Black Swan and Samson and Delilah, just listening to the music--so many highs and so many well-used opportunities to accent them with an element, even if it's something as small as turn of the head and arms. Hence the excitement and the energy of the programs.
from Speedy Death
from Speedy Death
But that wouldn't be bedroom Juliet!
Of course it could be with appropriate vampy choreography. It doesn't have to involve the knights.
from Speedy Death
After the Short Programs at Skate Canada, Gracie finished in first place with a score of 69.45.
Courtney Hicks, sadly, did not fare anywhere close to that, finishing in last place with a score of 50.70 (she botched her combination, doing a 2z-2t, and her skating had nowhere near the attack we've previously seen from her.
Meanwhile Gao is firmly in 4th and some 12 points ahead of Hicks. It's going to be a very exciting Nationals.
I see that Carroll had Gold hold her moves longer which is nice to see. I hope he will also have her take out some weird movements in that short program but overall it's a nice performance and the program isn't as bad as in practice when she turned it on. BTW I hope no one makes a big deal out of the fact that Gold scored more than Wagner did last week. It's a different competition! And Wagner hasn't maxed out her spin points yet!
Gao's program is still lovely and she is stunning on ice. Let's hope her other triples are back.
Hicks has the potential to giant leap in the free but those PCS are not encouraging.
I'm a little perturbed that Suzuki is only ~2 points above Gold in PCS. Suzuki should be much huger in IN, CH, and PE. Wagner scored less than 3 points more at SA, too, though I know it's difficult to compare.
Hopefully, this competition will put an end to the Hicks hype that was surged recently. I hope she develops in time, but it's a shame that Cesario's Carmen will struggled to be in the final flight, while Hicks is likely to deliver her mediocre interpretation of Evita. A 6th and 4CC trip with Cesario and Gao would be nice, and maybe these PCS scores - though they went up in the free - will encourage some hard work on that department over the summer.
Fingers crossed Suzuki battles back later; Suzuki-Lip-Gold would be ideal.
EDIT: FS turned out as I has hoped in essence... Not as worried about Gold's PCS, though I do think they should be closer to GAO than Suzuki.
Last edited by JJS5056; 10-26-2013 at 10:34 PM.
Also, these fields of 8 are depressing. Something must be done re: replacements.
What a disappointing SC event in all disciplines imho.
And GG proved she's no lock at Nationals. Once again she couldn't put together two clean programs. I think her time is *after* the Olympics, when the pressure is off.
Courtney is still my dark horse pick, but she's letting the limelight get to her a bit. However, the lovely Christina Gao could just sneak in and take it all.
Wagner, imho, is the only real all-around skater amongst them all.
That said, Yuna Kim might as well stay home, Tara Lipinski #2 (aka Julia L.) is looking to be an Olympic Champion in her home country of Russia. Therefore silver for Yuna, and the bronze is up for grabs, however I think once again the Americans will come home empty-handed. Ooops, except maybe for the Team Event, they can sneak in and grab the bronze if extremely lucky. jmho.